2010 Team & player threads

[Surkin]

Get the first poll up.

 

[Crimson Azure]

First thread has been started, begin casting you votes.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=622884

 

[Crimson Azure]

Points to keep in mind when voting on the poll:

1. The top 3 (4 in the case of emg) vote getters will make up the positional line on the field.

2. Those not selected will be eligible for other positions on the field, the bench & emergency positions.

3. If you do not think a player fits the position then don’t vote for him in that position/thread as he will get another chance in positions he has, can or will likely play in the future. You can suggest what position you would like to see him nominated for in the thread linked below.

4. Players listed below are the ones that will appear in other threads & those who will only get selected in one position/thread will also be listed (eg: Spencer in the ruck). So those will need to be voted for in that thread or wait until the bench or emergency threads if you feel they don’t warrant a position on the field.

5. The thread will be open for 1 week then we will move onto the next position, so it will proceed as follows:

Back
Half back
Centre
Half forward
Forward
Followers
Bench
Emergencies

The Idea will be to conduct these threads over the next month & then do a similar thing just before the season starts (if this attempt is successful) to see how much we differs from our original nominations.

For further discussion on the ideas behind this you can check out this thread.

Feel free to make more suggestions on this thread so we can leave the threads/polls for a discussion on whom & why we chose a player or to put the case of a player nominated in the poll forward for others to consider. We can also nominate how our preferred line would look or who we expect to be selected.

If you feel any comments need to be added let us know.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Nominations for half back:

Those not selected on the back line:

McDonald
Bennell
Bartram
Martin
McNamara
Cheney
Buckley
Bell
Miller
Morton
Rivers

I will also add the following players to the half back poll:

Bruce
Green
Strauss
Davey
Jetta
Blease
Bail


Any other suggestions?

I will Start the poll at about 3:30pm this arvo as the other poll finishes then.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Half back line poll is open until 9/9/09.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=626527

Players in the poll:

McDonald
Bennell
Bartram
Martin
McNamara
Cheney
Buckley
Bell
Miller
Morton
Rivers
Bruce
Green
Strauss
Davey
Jetta
Blease
Bail
Jones

 

[Crimson Azure]

These are the ones I have so far for the Centre line:

McDonald
Moloney
Sylvia
Bate
Jones
Dunn
McLean
Grimes
Bartram
McNamara
Buckley
Morton
Bruce
Green
Strauss
Davey
Jetta
Blease
Bail
Petterd

Are there any that should not be up for nomination?

Are there any that should be added to this list?

I plan to start thr centre thread tomorrow so please give me your suggestions.

Less than 24 hours to go on the back line thread so if you have not voted on the poll nows the time.

 

[WattsGoodForYou]

Valenti?

 

[Crimson Azure]

Valenti?

But that makes 21 on my list so who should go as we only have 20 spots?

McNamara
Bail
Jetta
Bate - he will be nominated up forward where he has a greater chance for selection.

This thread will be fun after draft time if we go with Scully & Trengove.

 

[WattsGoodForYou]

T Mac.

 

[Surkin]

But that makes 21 on my list so who should go as we only have 20 spots?

McNamara
Bail
Jetta
Bate - he will be nominated up forward where he has a greater chance for selection.

This thread will be fun after draft time if we go with Scully & Trengove.

Jetta stays. Get rid of McNamara or Bate for Valenti