2010 Vice Captain

[The Exorcist]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

I'm going in a different direction to everyone else and nominate Michael Jamison.

In fact I'd want him to be the next captain after Judd, Jammo just has 'leadership' stamped all over him, has a great attitude and a work ethic, and speaks really well and maturely.

Great pick, CP

 

[serenityNow]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

isnt Stevo vice captain in 2009?


anyway next year i think murph & jamo should get it.

i cant split em.

 

[Silvagnis]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

No question Gibbs put a short one in last week.

I know Gibbs' GF is coming to Melbourne, but that's harsh thy.

Even for you.

Gibbs is soft

 

[Bluebear]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Judd.

He should be coach too when we sack Ratten.

Sticks is also in the gun........rumour has it he is Judd's puppet anyway......why not make it official.

I'm going in a different direction to everyone else

Really?

 

[BlueSnake]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Simpson or Waite for me.

Kreuzer has future leader stamped all over him but I'd think they'd give him at least a few of years yet... doesn't need anymore pressure for a while

 

[BlueYoss]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Shouldnt it be Who should have been VC in 09, or who should be VC in 10?

You're right.

I meant 2010.

Mods, modify thread title?

 

[CUG81]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

When simpson was given the captain role he played brilliantly and really stepped it up, so i wouldnt mind seeing him there.

I also think waite befire his knee injury was playing great football and really stepped it up a notch and became a crucial player for us.

I would have them both.

Jamison, Murphy, Gibbs and Kruezer need more time.

 

[Tanks_Alot]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

I voted Waite but wouldn't mind if Simmo got it either.

Putting on guys like Murph, Kreuze or Gibbs could pressure them if we are having a bad game and they could lose confidence if they feel they didn't show enough leadership. The olde heads have more experience and would probably be able to handle this situation better.

 

[jonoman89]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Don't really have a great option here being such a young side.

I'd say Waite. Simmo is too hot and cold.

 

[Team Mo']

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Would be happy with one of Murphy, Simpson or Jamison.

Russel to captain FTW...

 

[Bluebear]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

You're right.

I meant 2010.

Mods, modify thread title?

.....and here I was thinking you were being clever with the presumption that Stevens would lose the job and someone else would have to step in........

 

[Banga19]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Simpson runs too hot and cold for my liking,i'd prefer Murph he's had a good year so far and you can really see his improvement.

I think Simmo has worked really hard in this area, and is now playing very good consistent footy, and his improvement can be seen.

He'd be my pick.

 

[CarltonSocialClub]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

I love the Jamo idea, but he is too injury prone.

I think it'll be Stevens again if he comes back and plays some good footy, there really is no outstanding candidates at this very moment. Stevens has had the role for 3 years now, so one ordinary patch in that time isn't too bad.

 

[bluesforever]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Murphy. But would be happy with Gibbs also.

 

[juddsentant517]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

I'd back stevens, been there for the hard times and bleeds carlton
im not so mu ha fan of key backman being captains/vice captains, easier to lead in the middle or in the forward line when you can really liven up you team
left field idea, imagine sentanta leading a club like carlton, the passion he would bring, would never happen, but id love to see him lead us!

 

[The Coach]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Simmo by default

I think Simpson. Kruezer and Gibbs are probably too young. I don't feel like it's murph's type of role but he may excel if given the chance.

Simmo is only 8mths younger than Juddy

I think Murphy and Gibbs should both take over Captain and Vice in a few years time. I'd really like to see Waite take VC next year.

or give it to.......













Jordan Russell.

He has shown as much leadership as the other two - better players but no indication they have leadership capabilities

I know Gibbs' GF is coming to Melbourne, but that's harsh thy.

Even for you.

Gibbs is soft

Reword to - not renowned for his hardness

Hopefully a leader or two emerge for most of them don't seem like they would say boo and we are really lacking an onfield general or two.
A market on Carlton's next captain would be interesting - I would entertain wagering on some longshots eg. Robbo, Joseph, McKinley

 

[blue gunslinger]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Kreuzer for sure, work-a-holic, future champion, respected, players appear to listen to him...
Gibbs - soft?
Murphey - will he be as good as Kreuzer?
Simpson - age?

Seconded for those exact reasons
Leads by example in every facet of his game and communicates well

 

[The Coach]

Re: 2009 Vice Captain

Seconded for those exact reasons
Leads by example in every facet of his game and communicates well

Hopefully this will one day be the case but isn't his nickname Humphrey

 

[thylacine60]

Pretty chatty on the field iirc.

 

[Blue Dawn]

Voted for Special K. I know he's a year or two younger than would be ideal but he simply exudes leadership and, over the coming years, will literally grow into a real physical presence on the field.

Otherwise i'd think Waitey (knee recovery aside) is exactly in the right place within himself to make a real success of the vc position.

 

[Cruddy]

Waitey. He has the maturity now. He can also tear the other sides a new one when he is on song. Besides all that what a great Carlton Family he has with dad Vinny playing for the Mighty Blues as well in the past.
The name is well repected at Carlton and he would be ideal for the job.