2013 Player/s X versus Y

[Super Hans]

Same as every other year, answer the person above your post player comparison and then ask your own.

Swan and Toumpas vs Mundy and Embly?

 

[cdonny]

Same as every other year, answer the person above your post player comparison and then ask your own.

Swan and Toumpas vs Mundy and Embly?

with 30 trades (overkill) I'd go Mundy and Embly (or even better go Ball)

Dusty or Daisy?

 

[borrat]

has to be both

due to the lack of good forwards available now

you could do what i will do and have one in the midfield and one in the forward line and have varcoe as a foward and trade varcoe for a mid when he is ready to be traded and if thomas doesnt play the first few games sub him on the midfield bench and have a rookie mid cover for him

 

[Zach Package]

yarran and pederson vs duffield and docherty

 

[Super Hans]

yarran and pederson vs duffield and docherty

Duffield and Docherty.

Goldstein vs Dale Thomas?

 

[cotter101]

yarran and pederson vs duffield and docherty

Yarran and Pederson. Docherty will have bad js with Golby and McGrath returning.

Duffield and Docherty.

Goldstein vs Dale Thomas?

Goldstein.

Stefan Martin or Robbie Gray?

 

[matt_bas]

Yarran and Pederson. Docherty will have bad js with Golby and McGrath returning.




Goldstein.

Stefan Martin or Robbie Gray?

Hard one. I would pick gray as their are better cheaper options in your ruck. You could go luenburger and hmac for example.

Staker vs Morris for last spot on my bench in the backline

 

[BlueGibbs2011]

Morris. No great reason but just the fact prior to injury he had more job security.

Yarran vs prem defender (460k+)?

Can he equal the output of a premo defender but at a cheaper price?

Yazzle Dazzle has only shown glimpses rather than staying power but to win this thing you got to spot up some differences. Will he land in 2013?

 

[cotter101]

Hard one. I would pick gray as their are better cheaper options in your ruck. You could go luenburger and hmac for example.

Staker vs Morris for last spot on my bench in the backline

I'd pick Staker(if he is fit for round one).
Forgot to mention that Martin would be a fwd. Dunno if that changes your opinion or not.

Morris. No great reason but just the fact prior to injury he had more job security.

Yarran vs prem defender (460k+)?

Can he equal the output of a premo defender but at a cheaper price?

Yazzle Dazzle has only shown glimpses rather than staying power but to win this thing you got to spot up some differences. Will he land in 2013?

Prem Defender, which might include guys like Fisher or Hanley? Hanley is one to watch as he is likely to play midfield with the return of Golby and McGrath and the possible debut of Docherty.

Matthew Wright or Dustin Martin?

 

[Zim^zuM]

Ablett/Embley vs StevieJ/Fyfe?

 

[shaun1800]

Ablett/Embley vs StevieJ/Fyfe?

Ablett and Embley all day.

J.Selwood and D.Thomas and Broughton with $12,500 to spare or Swan, Josh Kennedy and B. Waters with 88k to spare.

 

[cotter101]

Ablett and Embley all day.

J.Selwood and D.Thomas and Broughton with $12,500 to spare or Swan, Josh Kennedy and B. Waters with 88k to spare.

Selwood, Thomas and Broughton.

 

[FlowersByIrene]

Ablett and Embley all day.

J.Selwood and D.Thomas and Broughton with $12,500 to spare or Swan, Josh Kennedy and B. Waters with 88k to spare.

Selwood burned me with his mediocrity last season
Which Kennedy?? Eagle Kennedy?
I'd go Swan J.K and Waters

 

[toxic]

Selwood burned me with his mediocrity last season
Which Kennedy?? Eagle Kennedy?
I'd go Swan J.K and Waters

Selwood mediocrity??? ummm pretty sure he was top 6 in the mids or thereabouts, didnt he average 117ish?

 

[Zim^zuM]

Ablett/B. Goodes or Murphy/Bock?

 

[Super Hans]

Ablett/B. Goodes or Murphy/Bock?

Ablett/Goodes.

Grimes vs De Boer?

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Ablett/Goodes.

Grimes vs De Boer?

Grimes

 

[Jordie_tackles]

Ablett and Embley all day.

J.Selwood and D.Thomas and Broughton with $12,500 to spare or Swan, Josh Kennedy and B. Waters with 88k to spare.

Swan, kennedy Waters imo

Or even better, change Kennedy to a Sylvia type with that 88K

ok cant afford sylvia so i dunno i just dont think you can count on Broughton and Daisy

 

[toxic]

Mumford v Goldstein?

 

[Grizballs]

Mumford v Goldstein?

Goldstein imo,
Better value for money. I Also think Mummy is too injury prone.

 

[toxic]

Goldstein imo,
Better value for money. I Also think Mummy is too injury prone.

cheers, bloody rucks are already annoying me

 

[LennyIsGod]

NicNat or Buddy ?

 

[Jordie_tackles]

NicNat or Buddy ?

depends who your other ruck is (DPP) Buddy is the vetter player though

 

[muttonchops]

Ablett/Embley vs StevieJ/Fyfe?

Ok lets assume averages.
Ablett 140
Embley 80
TOTAL - 220

Johnson 95
Fyfe 110
TOTAL - 205

All assumptions but thats how i do it.

 

[Super Hans]

Ok lets assume averages.
Ablett 140
Embley 80
TOTAL - 220

Johnson 95
Fyfe 110
TOTAL - 205

All assumptions but thats how i do it.

Need to start with Ablett, will make you pay if you don't.

M.Murphy vs Kennedy?