AFL Clubs Mt Rushmore players

[RonnieRaven]

Adelaide
Modra Riccutio McLeod Betts

Brisbane
Voss Black Brown Aker

Carlton
Williams Silvagni Doull Jesalenko

Collingwood
Coventry Buckley older Moore Pendlebury

Essendon
Hird Coleman Madden Lloyd

Fremantle
Fyfe Pav McPharlin Sandilands

Geelong
Ablett Ablett Farmer Scarlett

Gold Coast
Miller Ablett Swallow Lynch

GWS
Cameron Greene Coniglio Kelly

Hawthorn
Matthews Franklin Hodge Hudson

Melbourne
Barassi Gawn Flower Petracca

Kangaroos
Carey Grieg Cable Boomer

Port Adelaide
Tredae Wanganeen Francou Gray

Richmond
Bartlett Dyer Martin Richardson

Sydney
Goodes Kelly Lockett Franklin

St Kilda
Reiwoldt Harvey Stewart Baldock

West Coast
Cousins Matera Judd Cox

Dogs
Whiten Bont Johnson Hawkins

Op says they have to be retire so swap Fyfe for Mundy and who have the anchors sorted

 

[Michaels]

Missed a trick with Bradley
He’s on the wing with Robert Harvey in my AFL era team.
Diesel and Bradley are locks for me.
In my time you could throw a blanket on McKay ratts stixs fev kouta Cripps sos
My uncle took me to state trainings multiple occasions bradles another level.
If the afl wasn’t the vfl he would be recognised as the games record holder that he truly deserves
Bradley one of the most underrated players of all time!

Bradley was very very close, I had him line ball with Williams!

jet of a player.

 

[Michaels]

It is a bit silly doing it based on time watching IMO. Just acknowledge that there will be a recency bias if you are tossing up Joel Selwood v Reg Hickey v Bobby Davis etc. The Richmond Mt Rushmore is going to have like Jack Riewoldt or Trent Cotchin instead of Jack Dyer lol....

Just a different take on how it is usually done.

Wanted to base it on what I had seen, not what I had read or heard stories about.

 

[Michaels]

Next up is Collingwood!

This one was tricky as well with so many good players through the 90s and 00's!

Now I want to state, I am aware that Pendlebury isn't in this, he is a current player so doesn't fit my criteria.

 

[eth-dog]

Adelaide
Modra Riccutio McLeod Betts

Brisbane
Voss Black Brown Aker

Carlton
Williams Silvagni Doull Jesalenko

Collingwood
Coventry Buckley older Moore Pendlebury

Essendon
Hird Coleman Madden Lloyd

Fremantle
Fyfe Pav McPharlin Sandilands

Geelong
Ablett Ablett Farmer Scarlett

Gold Coast
Miller Ablett Swallow Lynch

GWS
Cameron Greene Coniglio Kelly

Hawthorn
Matthews Franklin Hodge Hudson

Melbourne
Barassi Gawn Flower Petracca

Kangaroos
Carey Grieg Cable Boomer

Port Adelaide
Tredae Wanganeen Francou Gray

Richmond
Bartlett Dyer Martin Richardson

Sydney
Goodes Kelly Lockett Franklin

St Kilda
Reiwoldt Harvey Stewart Baldock

West Coast
Cousins Matera Judd Cox

Dogs
Whiten Bont Johnson Hawkins

You've missed our greatest player ever in Reynolds. Missed Skilton for Sydney.

Reynolds, Coleman, Hird and either Lloyd or Hutchison

 

[RedmanWasHere]

Melbourne Uni:

Bert Hartkopf.
Roy Park.
Bert Hurrey.
Bruce Sloss.

Possibly the hardest to think of.

 

[RedmanWasHere]

Fitzroy:

Roos.
K. Murray.

2 automatic starters.

Perhaps Ruthven and Curtin finish it.

 

[kirbatron]

seen them live or TV footage ok?

 

[eth-dog]

Fitzroy:

Roos.
K. Murray.

2 automatic starters.

Perhaps Ruthven and Curtin finish it.

Bunton?

 

[RedmanWasHere]

Bunton?

SHITS!

Forgot Bunton SR.

 

[eth-dog]

SHITS!

Forgot Bunton SR.

That's like forgetting Stewart for St Kilda, Reynolds for us, Skilton for Swans or Coventry for Collingwood

 

[RedmanWasHere]

That's like forgetting Stewart for St Kilda, Reynolds for us, Skilton for Swans or Coventry for Collingwood

Yep.

Massive massive blunder on my part.

 

[Michaels]

seen them live or TV footage ok?

tv footage is ok!

 

[Michaels]

Alright today Essendon's Mt Rushmore video launched!

As always the criteria is:
-Past player
-Must be someone I had seen play, so this does exclude some past greats.

I'm Happy / comfortable with 3 of my selections, the 4th I think will be up for debate!