AFL Evolution player ratings discussion thread

[EagleCanival]

Please keep it in here as opposed to the AFL Evolution discussion thread.

 

[JT_the_Man]

Mate, unless you are doing your own ratings you shouldn't be starting a thread for GOTHELIONS16, it's his decision.

 

[scaryness]

90+ players:
Patrick Dangerfield
Nathan Fyfe
Gary Ablett
Josh P Kennedy
Lance Franklin
Scott Pendlebury
Sam Mitchell
Alex Rance
Marcus Bontempelli
Dan Hannebery
Eddie Betts
Joel Selwood

That's it.

 

[FearTheBeard13]

90+ players:
Patrick Dangerfield
Nathan Fyfe
Gary Ablett
Josh P Kennedy
Lance Franklin
Scott Pendlebury
Sam Mitchell
Alex Rance
Marcus Bontempelli
Dan Hannebery
Eddie Betts
Joel Selwood

That's it.

Rory Sloane, Luke Parker, Dustin Martin and Heath Shaw should all be considered in that conversation too.

 

[SugarShane]

Sam Jacobs is at least a 93.

 

[mike123]

I hope they make if you have a higher speed stat then the player chasing you, you won't get run down.

Also contested ball winning needs to be overhauled otherwise slow contested ball winners will struggle. In live one Pendlebury barely gets a touch despite a 90+ rating.

90+ players:
Patrick Dangerfield
Nathan Fyfe
Luke Parker
Gary Ablett
Josh P Kennedy
Lance Franklin
Scott Pendlebury
Josh J Kennedy
Sam Mitchell
Todd Goldstein
Alex Rance
Marcus Bontempelli
Cyril Rioli
Eddie Betts
Joel Selwood
Nic Naitanui
Robbie Gray
Dustin Martin
Heath Shaw
Max Gawn
Shaun Burgoyne
Jeremy McGovern
Chad Wingard
Tom J Lynch
Tom Mcdonald
Dane Rampe

 

[bradburygold]

Based on the last thread 89+ is about all australian level, if we use that as a guide

 

[scaryness]

Based on the last thread 89+ is about all australian level, if we use that as a guide

I would argue 85+ would be All-Australian level. But that may be because I absolutely hate how Madden is rated for example where half the league is 90+.

 

[EagleCanival]

Mate, unless you are doing your own ratings you shouldn't be starting a thread for GOTHELIONS16, it's his decision.

I wish he would, if someone does we can close this thread but a lot of people were complaining about the other thread being filled with ratings rather than other discussion about the game, so I thought we could just put them in another thread.

 

[FearTheBeard13]

I would argue 85+ would be All-Australian level. But that may be because I absolutely hate how Madden is rated for example where half the league is 90+.

Very fair point, NBA 2K is another one but opposite theory, a lot of the All-Star-caliber players are rated far too low.

 

[bradburygold]

I would argue 85+ would be All-Australian level. But that may be because I absolutely hate how Madden is rated for example where half the league is 90+.

Madden is very position specific tho and ratings change dramatically. So if a kicker plays as good as is physically possible for a kicker why shouldnt he go up to 99 but then drop if his performance changes. Would love to here GOTHELIONS take

 

[Johnnnnnn]

Patrick Dangerfeild- 92
Nat fyfe- 89 or low 90
Luke parker- 91
Gary abblet- 90
Josh P Kennedy- 89
Lance franklin- 92
Scott pendlebury- 89 or now 90
Josh j Kennedy- 91
Sam mitchell- 88
Told goldstein- 91
Alex rance- high 91
Marcus bontempelli- 90
Cyril rioli- 87
Eddy betts- 91
Joel selwood- high 90
Nic naitanui- 88
Robbie gray- 89
Dustin martin- 90
Heath shaw- high 89
Max gawn- 91
Shaun bergoyne- 86
Jeremy mcGovern- high 87
Chad wingard- 87
Tom J Lynch- 86
Tom Mcdonald- 86
Dane rampe- 88
Dyson Heppell- low 89
Steele sidebottom- 88
Dayne beams- 86
Jordan lewis- 86
Dayne zorko- 86
Dan hannelbury- 86
Luke dahlhaus- 84
Matthew boyd-88 or low 89
Adam trelor- 87 low 88
Ollie wines- 84 low 85
Brodie grundy- 85 or low 86
Daniel tahlia- 86 low 87
Tarrantfrom north melbourne- 84 low 85
Patrick cripps- 87 low 88
Rory Sloane- 88 low 89
Nick rievolt- 86 low 87
Jack gunston- 85 low 86
Thats the main players that i can think of

 

[Johnnnnnn]

Patrick Dangerfeild should be the best player in the game

 

[FearTheBeard13]

Patrick Dangerfeild should be the best player in the game

Yeah 100% agreed, and in my opinion Fyfe and Buddy rounding out the top 3.

 

[Grockadoc]

Yeah 100% agreed, and in my opinion Fyfe and Buddy rounding out the top 3.

IMO, the top 5 rated players in the game should be:

Dangerfield
Buddy
Rance
Fyfe
Gawn/Goldstein

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

Looks like i've been moved to this thread instead of AFL Evolution. So far i have rated Adelaide through to Melbourne + Richmond as well. LOL
Before i get into north melbourne i will post a recap of whats been done so far.

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

AFL Evolution Player Ratings

What players need changing?

Adelaide

Eddie Betts – 91

Rory Sloane- 89

Taylor Walker- 88

Daniel Talia- 86

Brodie Smith- 85

Sam Jacobs- 85

Josh Jenkins- 84

Scott Thompson- 84

Rory Laird- 82

Richard Douglas- 82

Brad Crouch- 80

Tom Lynch- 80

Rory Atkins- 79

Paul Seedsman- 78

Matt Crouch- 76

Charlie Cameron- 76

Luke Brown- 76

David Mackay- 74

Kyle Hartigan- 74

Jake Lever- 73

Kyle Cheney- 73

Cam Ellis-Yolman- 72

Andy Otten- 72

Curtly Hampton- 72

Wayne Milera- 71

Mitch McGovern- 70

Troy Menzel- 70

Sam Shaw- 69

Riley Knight- 68

Dean Gore- 68

Tom Doedee- 67

Harry Dear- 66

Reily O'Brien- 66

Jake Kelly- 64

Harrison Wigg- 63

Jordan Gallucci- 63

Myles Poholke- 61

Ben Davis- 61

Ben Jarman- 61

Elliot Himmelberg- 60

Jonathon Beech- 60

Hugh Greenwood- 60

Alex Keath- 60

Paul Hunter- 58

 

[GOTHELIONS16]

i won't post the next team until the first one has been referred to.

 

[JT_the_Man]

AFL Evolution Player Ratings

What players need changing?

Adelaide

Eddie Betts – 91

Rory Sloane- 90

Taylor Walker- 88

Daniel Talia- 86

Brodie Smith- 85

Sam Jacobs- 85

Josh Jenkins- 84

Scott Thompson- 84

Rory Laird- 82

Richard Douglas- 82

Brad Crouch- 80

Tom Lynch- 80

Rory Atkins- 79

Charlie Cameron- 78

Paul Seedsman- 78

Matt Crouch- 76

Luke Brown- 76

David Mackay- 74

Kyle Hartigan- 74

Jake Lever- 73

Kyle Cheney- 73

Cam Ellis-Yolman- 72

Andy Otten- 72

Curtly Hampton- 72

Wayne Milera- 71

Mitch McGovern- 70

Troy Menzel- 70

Sam Shaw- 69

Riley Knight- 68

Dean Gore- 68

Tom Doedee- 67

Harry Dear- 67

Harrison Wigg- 66

Jordan Gallucci- 66

Myles Poholke- 64

Ben Davis- 63

Ben Jarman- 62

Elliot Himmelberg- 61

Sam Jacobs should be a 93 overall imo.

 

[bradburygold]

Sam Jacobs should be a 93 overall imo.

If the best player is a ~92, then no.

 

[bradburygold]

Patrick Dangerfeild- 92
Nat fyfe- 89 or low 90
Luke parker- 91
Gary abblet- 90
Josh P Kennedy- 89
Lance franklin- 92
Scott pendlebury- 89 or now 90
Josh j Kennedy- 91
Sam mitchell- 88
Told goldstein- 91
Alex rance- high 91
Marcus bontempelli- 90
Cyril rioli- 87
Eddy betts- 91
Joel selwood- high 90
Nic naitanui- 88
Robbie gray- 89
Dustin martin- 90
Heath shaw- high 89
Max gawn- 91
Shaun bergoyne- 86
Jeremy mcGovern- high 87
Chad wingard- 87
Tom J Lynch- 86
Tom Mcdonald- 86
Dane rampe- 88
Dyson Heppell- low 89
Steele sidebottom- 88
Dayne beams- 86
Jordan lewis- 86
Dayne zorko- 86
Dan hannelbury- 86
Luke dahlhaus- 84
Matthew boyd-88 or low 89
Adam trelor- 87 low 88
Ollie wines- 84 low 85
Brodie grundy- 85 or low 86
Daniel tahlia- 86 low 87
Tarrantfrom north melbourne- 84 low 85
Patrick cripps- 87 low 88
Rory Sloane- 88 low 89
Nick rievolt- 86 low 87
Jack gunston- 85 low 86
Thats the main players that i can think of

Stopped reading when betts 4 points higher than rioli

Unless the points scale reverses for finals games

 

[JT_the_Man]

If the best player is a ~92, then no.

It's a joke.

I think highest player should be about 94, but only 2-3 players over 92.

 

[scaryness]

I just remember Brent Macaffer being rated an 87 in AFL Live 2. If that type of rating standard holds up I will be very disappointed.

 

[bradburygold]

It's a joke.

I think highest player should be about 94, but only 2-3 players over 92.

Hard to tell jokes on this thing
Luke parker 91 guy didnt watch gf

 

[JT_the_Man]

Hard to tell jokes on this thing
Luke parker 91 guy didnt watch gf

Yeah.

Only brought it up because GOTHELIONS said that he was doing these ratings to avoid ratings such as Sam Jacobs being a 93 in the last game.