Blade's Top 50

[Blade of Chronic]

1. Gary Ablett
2. Chris Judd
3. Jimmy Bartel
4. Ben Cousins
5. Matthew Pavlich
6. Lance Franklin
7. Matthew Scarlett
8. Luke Hodge
9. Dean Cox
10. Matthew Richardson
11. Joel Corey
12. Brendan Fevola
13. Sam Mitchell
14. Joel Selwood
15. Nick Riewoldt
16. Jonathan Brown
17. Adam Cooney
18. Dane Swan
19. Nick Dal Santo
20. Daniel Cross
21. Simon Black
22. Chad Cornes
23. Kane Cornes
24. Brent Harvey
25. Peter Burgoyne
26. Alan Didak
27. Nathan Brown
28. Marc Murphy
29. Martin Mattner
30. Jarryd Roughead
31. Andrew Carazzo
32. Scott Thompson
33. Andrew Mackie
34. Steve Johnson
35. Brett Deledio
36. Corey Enright
37. Luke Power
38. Daniel Kerr
39. Leon Davis
40. Scott Pendlebury
41. Bryce Gibbs
42. Brad Sewell
43. Brendan Goddard
44. Sam Fisher
45. Ryan Griffen
46. Lindsay Gilbee
47. Cyril Rioli
48. Heath Scotland
49. Nathan Bock
50. Travis Cloke

Comments and constructive criticism is welcome

Forgive me if I get some of the first names wrong

 

[Hawkers Hero]

Not a bad effort - IMO Bartel, Cousins and Dal Santo too high and Roughead, Didak and Selwood too low.

By the end of this year Selwood will be easily regarded a better player than Bartel (god I hate that midfield )

Cousins is way too high to be 4 right now - see how he goes in the real stuff first

 

[SteeleBeams]

Yeah, cousins is too high at the moment, it is way to early to judge how good he is going to be this season. I think wait a little bit, and maybe if you do another one at the half way stage of the season would be good.

 

[Kirby]

if Corey Enright and Heath Scotland are better than Travis Cloke I'll eat my own head.

 

[The Magician]

if Corey Enright and Heath Scotland are better than Travis Cloke I'll eat my own head.

They both are, I don't understand other Collingwood supporters' fixation with Travis Cloke. He is too slow and has a similar conversion rate to Lance Franklin.

 

[The Magician]

Franklin should be higher, cousins and bartel lower, kerr higher. Other than that, a very good list. well done.

 

[Dylz48]

How does Carazzo get a run

 

[PieBeast]

Not a bad list

Roughead and Sewell should be a lot higher though .
Carazzo and Scotland out . Dale Morris in .

 

[smiddaz123]

if Corey Enright and Heath Scotland are better than Travis Cloke I'll eat my own head.

Enright is.

Scotland is not.

Enright is a VERY under rated footballer.

 

[whattagun07]

All Australian CHB, N.Bock at 49, well below P.Burger, Carazzo and Mattner?

ughh

 

[Optimax]

better then that Rucci bloke from adelaide

 

[whattagun07]

Carazzo and Mattner vs Lade and Anthony

I'd rather have the latter two in my team to be honest.

I don't think much thought was put into this list. Players from the same teams grouped together 5 times seems a bit much.

Cornes Cornes
Johnson Mackie
Gilbee Griffen
Davis Pendlebury
Fisher Goddard

 

[Silvagnis]

How does Carazzo get a run

Paul Chapman owns Carrazzo who is ahead of Steve Johnson.

Can someone arrange a Carrazzo for Johnson trade for me?

I'll chuck Scotland in to get the deal done.

Ben Cousins at four?

A laugh to place Cousins and Corey ahead of Fevola.

 

[Pie Legend]

Boomer Harvey is a bit low IMO