Brownlow

[Ferga18]

Hey guys

Dane swan is $26 for the brownlow... worth putting a few bob on i rekon... good value..especially before it gets lower if he contines playin the way he does.

U guys think he is a chance??

 

[jodo27]

No.....

 

[Coin_Toss]

No, he won't win it this year, but perhaps down the track.

 

[dmac]

he's more of a chance than me but I wouldn't slap down any hard earned on him,

 

[FadeAway]

bet ya ablett wont get anywhere near charlie this year....


tarks will win it

 

[prO]

Dane Swan is the sort of player, that while he will get his 25+ disposals and 8 marks a game - he still goes unnoticed, which for the mighty pies - is a great thing. However not so great when it comes to brownlow votes from the umpires.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Wait till end of season and do club multi's. Swan will have to contend with Shaw and Lockyer at the same time at a similar price, so odds won't be too short.

 

[KikidadidaK]

Jimmy Bartel would still be leading at the moment with Kerr pretty close behind. G A Jnr is still chasing i reckon at the moment. As for Swan, I doubt he will figure to greatly because of the evenness of the pies line-up.

 

[game on]

As with the season. I think that a number of players can win this year. The winner may end up having less than 20 votes. It could be a year for someone like Scott West to get the nod.

Very similar year to '93 IMO

 

[ad4eva]

cant see swanny winning it. I dont even think he will win the Copeland. Hes had a fantastic season thus far however.

 

[Chase the Ace]

$6.00 for a place is a fair bet

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Tarkyn Lockyer.

Doesn't win charlies, charlie wins Tarkyn's

 

[DeZi]

Jimmy Bartel would still be leading at the moment with Kerr pretty close behind. G A Jnr is still chasing i reckon at the moment. As for Swan, I doubt he will figure to greatly because of the evenness of the pies line-up.

Kerr has been suspended twice now...only need to get suspended once to be out of contention

Can't see Swan winning it...Tarks has a better chance as Swan doesn't really show it (he goes unnoticed)

 

[KikidadidaK]

Kerr has been suspended twice now...only need to get suspended once to be out of contention

Can't see Swan winning it...Tarks has a better chance as Swan doesn't really show it (he goes unnoticed)

I realise that mate but it doesn't stop them from getting votes!

 

[a.f.k.a.y.o.p.]

Jimmy Bartel would still be leading at the moment with Kerr pretty close behind. G A Jnr is still chasing i reckon at the moment. As for Swan, I doubt he will figure to greatly because of the evenness of the pies line-up.

good point. your whole list is average.........

LOL- just kidding. lots of respect for the Pies and really looking forward to a belter Saturday - Game of the Year IMO.......

 

[DeZi]

I realise that mate but it doesn't stop them from getting votes!

Meh I like Kerr but I think all these suspensions may be influencing the umpires votes...really subconciously they might not be giving the votes out to Kerr that easily (despite his great efforts)

 

[Magnus the Magpie]

Dane Swan is the sort of player, that while he will get his 25+ disposals and 8 marks a game - he still goes unnoticed, which for the mighty pies - is a great thing. However not so great when it comes to brownlow votes from the umpires.

Spot on! Great player for us and having a terrific season. However, not the type that picks up Brownlow votes. Who cares?!

 

[Dxmxgxd]

Pavlich will win the Charlie

 

[turtlemanistic]

Pavlich will win the Charlie

In a team outside the 8?

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Pavlich will win the Charlie

No, he won't.

 

[Barwick17]

Kerr has been suspended twice now...only need to get suspended once to be out of contention

Can't see Swan winning it...Tarks has a better chance as Swan doesn't really show it (he goes unnoticed)

Don't the two negatives cancel eachother out?

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Shoulda got on him when he was $51 IMO

Just like I shoulda got on Tarks at $1001

 

[__DaVE]

yet no one mentions the longshot for charlie.... marty clarke

 

[Ekulman]

swanny polled alright last year with 11 votes when no one really knew who he was.
Might get a few more this year hopefully

 

[PieLebo87]

swanny polled alright last year with 11 votes when no one really knew who he was.
Might get a few more this year hopefully

Very fair point. Will be more noticeable this year, as he has also featured in the Inside Football medal, hes going alright in the Herald Sun award too. I'd actually think about putting some $$$ on him because he will be getting more then the 11 he got last year. Could win it. He is our standout midfielder infront of the opposition.