Changes for round 3 VS Tigers

[mulehoops]

In: Jetta

Out: Wellingham

 

[WCE Wizard]

In Butler please we miss his composure
down back

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Sam Mitchell out against Richmond as he was sore last week and again after tonights game.

Also makes sense with only a 5 day game break after the richmond game to play sydney.

Redden looked slow out there, dont think we can play Sheed and Redden in the same side, when
we have Mitchell and Priddis in the team.
All 4 are very slow

 

[Matele]

In: Butler, Schofield

Out: Nelson, Wellingham

Also need a fast-ish sorta mid on the bench.

 

[Godfather32]

Our midfield tonight:



There's no way we can keep playing Hutchings, Sheed, Redden, Mitchell and Priddis in the same side, especially against Richmond's midfield.
Wellingham and one of the first three midfielders I named out, Jetta & Watson in.

 

[Lolbert]

Composure and our disposal off half back today was abysmal. Butler in for Nelson and perhaps Jetta in for hutchings

 

[Suma Magic]

In: Butler and Jetta

Out: Nelson and one of Sheed/Redden/Hutch

Really can't remember who performed worst of the latter three.

 

[Carbine Chaos]

Nelson showed some run off half back, I'd definitely be keeping him in.

 

[WCE Wizard]

In: Butler, Schofield

Out: Nelson, Wellingham

Also need a fast-ish sorta mid on the bench.

Yep Wellingham is way to casual needs a swift kick up the backside

 

[bunkyboy]

OUT: Sheed, Giles.

IN: Butler, Jetta.

 

[WCE Wizard]

In: Butler and Jetta

Out: Nelson and one of Sheed/Redden/Hutch

Really can't remember who performed worst of the latter three.

Well SHeed first game back i can left him off, Redden was excellent last week but we need more. Nelson was not the worst player believe me

 

[Yamumluvsbigcox]

Out wellingham
in butler

 

[bunkyboy]

In: Butler, Schofield

Out: Nelson, Wellingham

Also need a fast-ish sorta mid on the bench.

You are dropping two pretty quick players there.

 

[bunkyboy]

I think Nelson should be left in. We really lack line breakers and he is quick. He is also usually a nice kick. Our whole side was under pressure tonight and played rubbish - Nelson was far from the worst.

 

[nameless]

Is everyone drunk in this thread?
Terrible suggestions...

Sheed is one game back from a lay-off, wasn't terrible when he had it, just failed to get it, give him a bloody chance.

Nelson lacked a lot of polish and could be seen to make way, but I'd like us to encourage him to back himself, take some risks and learn from it, he'll get better, we need to keep playing these blokes.

Redden was good last week and although quiet for much of the game, he did give us a lift in the last.

Wellingham was very poor in his disposal tonight and average against North, but he's getting plenty of it and working very hard both ways. He certainly needs to tidy up his disposal but I don't think dropping him is the answer, another poor game and then we can look to replace with Butler/Watson/Schoey.

Mitchell doesn't need a rest.

 

[Suma Magic]

Maybe I didn't watch others that closely, but Nelson seemed to make a lot of mistakes.

 

[lmach]

Out: Redden
In: Jetta

Wouldn't mind if Butler came in but Nelson shouldn't be dropped and Wellingham probably deserves to be dropped but not due to lack of effort or anything. He was very sloppy and gave away two goals but I'd give him a chance to get it together. Mopped up well the times he didn't turn it over.

Not sure how Jetta went in the WAFL but we need some speed and Redden really gave us nothing.

How was Watson's game for EP? Saw he got 30 touches.

 

[wce4premiership]

Butler is a better player than Nelson overall but not as good a runner. He's a better kick, beter decision maker and a better defender though. He can get in the right spots on the rebound and provide an option but will then usually hold up behind the mark for a kick.

Not sure what's wrong with Wellingham, don't want to lose his pace but he almost directly cost us the game.

Loved the Barrass inclusion, think the defence is close to being right with maybe some changes as players get sore/injured but the midfield wasn't quite right today.

 

[Biggie]

Sam Mitchell out against Richmond as he was sore last week and again after tonights game.

How accurate is this RE?

5 day break makes sense but gee we'll miss him.

 

[dinnaz]

Defs need ruck changes

 

[bunkyboy]

We need the whole 22 to lift or we will get done next week against Richmond.

 

[dispute]

No changes

 

[Carbine Chaos]

I really want Jetta's pace and kicking on the wider MCG expanses.

Could justify dropping a number of individuals for him.

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

How accurate is this RE?

5 day break makes sense but gee we'll miss him.

Educated guess Simpson said they would rest him through out the season.
After the Sydney game there is a long break so wouldn't rest him for that game so makes
sense to rest him against Richmond.
I hope he plays as we need him but would be a risk

 

[ROYAL EAGLE]

Butler is a better player than Nelson overall but not as good a runner. He's a better kick, beter decision maker and a better defender though. He can get in the right spots on the rebound and provide an option but will then usually hold up behind the mark for a kick.

Not sure what's wrong with Wellingham, don't want to lose his pace but he almost directly cost us the game.

Loved the Barrass inclusion, think the defence is close to being right with maybe some changes as players get sore/injured but the midfield wasn't quite right today.

Sorry did you watch Butlers kicking today for east perth he lost us the game with his kicking