Remove this Banner Ad

Preview Changes & Pre-match Discussion - BIG FREEZE 7 - Round 13 vs. Melbourne, SCG Mon 14/06 @ 3:20pm

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jun 8, 2008
22,338
37,599
Victoria
AFL Club
Collingwood
Outside of a one point loss to the hands of the Crows at the Adelaide Oval, the Melbourne Demons could not have started this season much better than what they have.

It took some convincing, but the football public has seemingly come to terms with the fact that Melbourne, unusually, just aren't that bad of a side anymore. So much so, in fact, that they are currently in the conversation for flag favourites. That's right, the Melbourne Demons, amongst the flag favourites!

Alright, so I've let them have their moment. Enough of that.

Remember 2017? Collingwood started the season 2-6 and Buckley's future was all-but-gone. Another bad season, sliding down the ladder, history repeating. Although the Pies' season slowly but surely gained some momentum in the latter half of the year, it was Melbourne that simply needed to beat the 13th-placed Magpies to gain their first finals berth since 2006. The Pies went on to win by 16 points and ex-Demon Lynden Dunn belted his chest towards the Magpies faithful on the other side of the fence. Melbourne had spectacularly missed the finals.

And how is that relevant? Melbourne were on the up and full of enthusiasm, but their hopes and dreams were slapped squarely in the face by the hand that was reality. Collingwood had pulled a high-class performance out of their absolute backside.

So whilst we might not have much hope next weekend, these are the types of games we win.



LAST TIME THEY MET:

Round 12, 2020: Melbourne 16.4 (100) def. Collingwood 6.8 (44) at the Gabba in front of a crowd of 5,338.



KEY MATCH UPS:

Roughead will again have his hands full, likely facing off against the meat-eating-machine, Tom McDonald.

Moore should take Weideman or the resting ruck.

Bayley Fritsch has been Melbourne's best forward and will be a very tough match-up. I suspect this will be another case of Quaynor playing on him, rebounding well, conceding 3+ goals, all whilst Maynard would be better suited.

I would personally play Maynard on Fritsch, Quaynor on Pickett and Noble on Spargo.



CHANGES:

Assuming Grundy doesn't get up...

IN: Mccreery, Mayne, Macrae as sub
OUT: Madgen, Sier (inj), C Brown
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

OUT: Sier (inj.) - Madgen - Brown Thomas
IN: McCreery - Mayne - Keane

FB: Keane - Roughead - Maynard
HB: Quaynor - Moore - Murphy
C: Poulter - Daicos - Noble
HF: Sidebottom - Cameron - Mihocek
FF: McCreery - De Goey - Elliott
FOLL: Lynch - Pendlebury - Crisp
INT: Mayne - Rantall - Bianco - Brown
 
That not Huge with how Little we have Kicked

Not in Best Form and has looked to hurt his Finger
I agree that his form isn't too flash, but I'd prefer he play his way into form with Elliott back and McCreery returning. Plus, unsure if Johnson is ready
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Out: Sier (inj) Madgen, Lynch,
In: Keane, McCreery, Cox (if available)

Just think putting Lynch up against Gawn we might see him disintegrate before our very eyes.

Want to give Rantall a second in a row, I'm not a huge fan of one and done for the youngsters unless they are awful (op cit, Henry).

I don't feel a need to put Mayne in there, but I am sure he will be, probably instead of Murphy or Rantall.
 
Last edited:
Out: Thomas, Madgen, Sier (inj)
In: Johnson, Mayne, MCCreery,
Might as well have another look at Lynch and Rantall.
Lynch v Gawn🤔🤷
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

In: Cox, Keane, Mayne, McCreery
Out: Lynch, Madgen, Sier, Brown

JT and Rantall saved by the win, with one of them being the medical sub.
 
OUT: Sier (inj.) - Madgen - Brown Thomas
IN: McCreery - Mayne - Keane

FB: Keane - Roughead - Maynard
HB: Quaynor - Moore - Murphy
C: Poulter - Daicos - Noble
HF: Sidebottom - Cameron - Mihocek
FF: McCreery - De Goey - Elliott
FOLL: Lynch - Pendlebury - Crisp
INT: Mayne - Rantall - Bianco - Brown
You’ve got no clue. Thomas was good tonight, and also stringed together some solid games prior to injury. Brown had a great game.

Cameron was poor and should be dropped for Cox. Just to show that even with Grundy injured you have to turn up and perform.

Rantall is justnot up to the standard at the minute, it’s a shame he can’t develop more in the VFL at the. moment. He gets dropped for McCreery.

One of Madgen/Noble dropped for Mayne. I suspect Madgen, he brings very little.
 
You’ve got no clue. Thomas was good tonight, and also stringed together some solid games prior to injury. Brown had a great game.

Cameron was poor and should be dropped for Cox. Just to show that even with Grundy injured you have to turn up and perform.

Rantall is justnot up to the standard at the minute, it’s a shame he can’t develop more in the VFL at the. moment. He gets dropped for McCreery.

One of Madgen/Noble dropped for Mayne. I suspect Madgen, he brings very little.

I'm usually pretty tolerant of Thomas but the mark he squibbed in the middle of the ground that cost a goal was absolutely not good enough. The kick wasn't perfect but you cant show that unwillingness to fight for the ball like that, especially for a senior player. He's been pretty good lately but I was really disappointed in that effort.

And who actually thought he was going to nail that set shot late? If Beau is fit it's a straight swap there, but i doubt we'll make too many changes other than forced ones after a win.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top