Competitions Ching: Eagles d Doggies

[Kermit]

Post your 5-4-3-2-1 here and your Pups 3-2-1 too. Pups were:
Daniel
Cordy
Smith
Schache
Dunkley
Richards
Naughton
Lynch
Gowers.

Vote away!

 

[VL3OJ]

5. McLean
4. Morris
3. Dunkley
2. Crozier
1. Schache

3. Dunkley
2. Schache
1. Richards

 

[dogwatch]

Very difficult to find a BoG today

I'll go:
5. Hunter - just kept running and presenting
4. McLean - tried hard
3. Wallis - tried hard
2. Dunkley - tried hard
1. Crozier - tried hard

Roughy tried hard and wasn't far away from a vote.

Special mention to Honeychurch who - no matter what you think of his skills - tries as hard as anybody every time he crosses the white line. No way was he going to make my best 5 today though, even if he'd played a full 4 quarters. Hope he's OK and the boys get around him.

Pups
3. Dunkley
2. Gowers
1. Daniel (despite some howlers)

I feel dirty giving votes today but credit where it's due. Think I'll go have a shower.

 

[Yojimbo]

5- NO SOUP FOR YOU !
4- NO SOUP FOR YOU !
3- L. Hunter
2- M. Wallis
1- J. Johannisen

3- NO SOUP FOR YOU !
2- NO SOUP FOR YOU !
1- J. Schache

Note- I should get a point for sitting through that and not breaking anything.

 

[go you pups]

5. Roughead (was horrendous up forward early, but second half he really dug in and lead the way)
4. Wallis
3. Dunkley
2. Schache (would've been more dangerous had he had better delivery, showing good signs still, he Roughead and maybe Cordy the only talls who did anything)
1. McLean (was woeful early but improved as the game wore on and dug in)

 

[Hard Ball Get]

5. Wallis
4. Roughead
3. McLean
2. Dunkley
1. Hunter

3. Dunkley
2. Shache
1. Lynch

 

[TMoney22]

5 - Wallis
4 - Hunter
3 - Crozier
2 - McLean
1 - Schache

3 - Schache
2 - Dunkley
1 - Lynch

 

[StringyDog]

5. Wallis
4. Crozier
3. JJ
2. Hunter
1. Dunkley

3. Dunkley
2. Schache
1. Daniel

 

[Walsh Bay]

5 Crozier
4 Dunkley
3 McLean
2 Wallis
1 Hunter

3 Dunkley
2 Schache
1 Cordy

 

[_M_16_]

5. McLean
4. Crozier
3. Dunkley
2. Wallis
1. Schache

3. Dunkley
2. Schache
1. Richards

 

[Snarls Barkley]

5. Wallis
4. Hunter
3. Dunkley
2. Crozier
1. Johannisen

3. Dunkley
2. Schache
1. Daniel

Wasn’t easy giving votes. Not a lot of winners yesterday. Did I miss something with McLean? Thought his ball use was uncharacteristically poor.

 

[Leviticus]

Well, another shattering loss where we handballed more than we kicked. We just don't learn. How come we got the first 2 goals? (A: kicked it long). So my votes go to blokes who kicked the ball more than they handballed it.

5. Crozier (20 kicks, 9 h/b, well done)
4. Hunter (17 kicks, 11 h/b)
3. McLean (14, 10)
2. Cordy (10, 4)
1. Schache (7, 4)

apologies go to Trengove (5, 2) and Daniel (12,11 - at least he was on the right side of the ledger).

3. Cordy
2. Shache
1. Daniel

 

[DognBones]

Only 11 contributors to the Ching thus far this week; proof that it is getting harder and harder each week. My unconvincing stab this week is:
5 Hunter
4 McLean
3 Dunkley
2 Crozier
1 No 5th Placegetter

3 Dunkley
2 Schache
1 No 3rd Dividend

 

[Kermit]

Rd18 Ching vs Eagles (12 voters)

5 - Wallis: 33 votes (4 BOG's)
3.5 - Hunter: 29 votes (2 BOG's)
3.5 - McLean: 29 votes (2 BOG's)
2 - Crozier: 28 votes (2 BOG's)
1 - Dunkley: 24 votes.

Others:
Roughead: 9 votes (1 BOG)
Schache: 6 votes
Johannisen: 5 votes
Morris: 4 votes
Cordy: 2 votes

Pups: (11 voters)

3 - Dunkley: 26 votes (8 BPOG's)
2 - Schache: 20 votes (1 BPOG)
0.5 - Cordy: 4 votes (1 BPOG)
0.5 - Daniel: 4 votes

Others:
Lynch: 2 votes
Richards: 2 votes
Gowers: 2 votes.

Thanks for playing

 

[dogwatch]

Leaderboard updated for Rd 18.
McLean only 1.5 behind Macrae now. Hunter level with Bont in third place and Wallis has moved up from 20-somethingth to equal fifth after two BoG performances.
Dunkley pushing toward the lead of the Pups. Only 2 votes behind Williams who might not play again this year, and level with Richards.