Colin Sylvia

[NQTIGER]

Well every other player including fev has been mentioned why not Sylvia....high draft pick, could be that Chris Judd type player for us.....

Thoughts?

 

[Toadvine]

No way, He is lazy and not a leader. He will never be a Judd like player for anyone.

 

[TOOs_Finest]

At 25yo, a new beginning at another club might be what he needs to get the most out of himself. But as Toady said, I don't see him as a leader type, and certainly not "Judd like".

I see him as damaged goods. Would take him for peanuts*, but not willing to pay much more than that.

A 3rd draft pick who I don't think has been even close to AA selection or winning a b&f at a club with about the same level of performance as us in the same period. Puts Deledio's efforts into some perspective IMO.

* probably a 3rd rounder, but I also realise that wouldn't likely happen

 

[TimeFor11]

I would go for him for comp pick

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

I think this year has shown that only Judd is a 'Judd' like player.

He'll be the first footballer in history to walk home with a Brownlow and an Oscar in the same year.

 

[Bird Man]

Well every other player including fev has been mentioned why not Sylvia....high draft pick, could be that Chris Judd type player for us.....

Thoughts?

mmmm dont think he is much of a leader type

Even though Geelong are doing quite well dosent meen we cant snag a real good player of them with our Money and new facilities... but would have be a very Good player..

Just because there going well dosent meen they won't come to us for a new start a