Remove this Banner Ad

Confirmations

  • Thread starter Thread starter Itze
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Itze

Rookie
Joined
Jun 16, 2003
Posts
29
Reaction score
0
Other Teams
Richmond
Well, what did yesterdays performance really confirm for everyone in here? I'll give you my thoughts:

* Richardson will never be a leader, not a captain, not a vice captain, or a deputy vice captain. The two 50m penalties he gave away were disgraceful. He is still the heart & soul of Tigerland and with better delivery of the ball and a better forward structure to support him he will still be of tremendous value to the team. But insofar as leadership goes, he would be better off without the tag of captain, VC or DVC.
* Houlihan is the absolute worst. That kick in the last qtr was Adam at his absolute best. See you later son!!!
* Bowden - we all know the story there. TRADE PLEASE!!!
* Tivendale - I've said it from day 1, this kid is rapidly turning into another Bowden. Another left footer, outside player, can't man up, pathetic defensive skills, and for a bloke who apparently has "sublime" foot skills he jointly cost us the game yesterday. I say give him one more year to pull his finger out of his arse.
* Fiora - the same as Tivendale. One more year young fella.
* D. Kellaway - great service to the club, but the current game of AFL football has left him behind. Delist or Retire - his choice!!!
* His brother Andy, only fault is that he is very dumb sometimes. Often cannons into the back of his opposition player needlessly costing us goals. Definitely needs to smarten up, but overall good.
* Frawley tactics - if there was one moment of yesterday's game that Richmond had a chance of winning it was with Schultz in the forward line. His second efforts were something I've not seen in our forward line for some time. Bloody fantastic. He single-handedly brought life into the forward line, and just when Richmond were within arms reach of a win, our superstar tactican extarordinaire of a senior coach "Spud the dud" takes off Schultz and brings the man of the hour "Houlihan" on who then proceeds to deliver "that kick" (refer above) and with that any real hope of winning. Judging by the way Schultz ran from the field he was not injured. So full marks go to Danny for that one. Sorry spud, but you are not the right man to lead this club. A good person you may be, but any learned person will tell you that a coach's job is to motivate his players, to flick that switch inside their heads, to make them more than they are. In this area, you have failed.

I know I've missed out on some players here, but I'll leave that to someone else.
 
Disagree with you on Tivendale ... he's been great, though I would like to see him get closer to goal on more occasions.

Playing him so far back up the ground reduces the scoreboard damage he could inflict.
 
Tivendale

Yes I like Tivendale as well, agree with ghost, he could kick alot of goals this fella, not utalized well enough in my opinion.
 
Tivendale

At last, someone who agrees with me on Tivendale. He is so frustrating because we know what he is capable of, but he rarely produces it. Infuriating turnover rate also.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Tivva

Don't get me wrong, I generally like the kid, but I think he needs an authoritative figure to set him straight with regards to the defensive side of his game. I also think that out of the centre he does not really like to get his hands dirty (i.e. He will wait for the ball to come to him at a centre bounce rather than actually go to where the ball is). Hence my statement that he is an outside player and is turning into another Bowden.

Remember, a lot of supporters were singing the praises of Joel about 5 years ago after a much improved season, but he didn't take the next step. In fact he moved backwards whilst the physical nature of the game passed him by. Here's hoping Tivva does not follow suit.
 
Tivva is a dime a dozen receiver, who just happened to have a very good year at contract renewal time!
His type will never take us to the next level and if a suitable trade can be made, the club should not hesitate for 1 minute.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom