Cooney or Enright????

[the_berger]

tough decision this


Cooney


this is supposed to be cooneys year and hopefully it will be if i decide to pick him and hopefully it wont be if i dont decide to pick him

cooney would be 3rd in line to get tagged behind cross and west so thats no concern but im worried that if both or either one gets injured he could be be tagged every week


Enright

enright had a pretty good year last year and is 4th in line to be tagged behind ablett,bartel and corey so something tragic would have to happen for him to be tagged so im kind of favouring him at the moment problem is if i pick him i have to downgrade another player for it to happen


so

who would be better???????

 

[Walesy]

I've definitely got Cooney pencilled in to step up again this year.

Mainly though because of the step down Westie took last year... The boys 33(34?) and it's gotta be time to hand the reigns over soon...

 

[SJ]

tough decision this


Cooney


this is supposed to be cooneys year and hopefully it will be if i decide to pick him and hopefully it wont be if i dont decide to pick him

cooney would be 3rd in line to get tagged behind cross and west so thats no concern but im worried that if both or either one gets injured he could be be tagged every week


Enright

enright had a pretty good year last year and is 4th in line to be tagged behind ablett,bartel and corey so something tragic would have to happen for him to be tagged so im kind of favouring him at the moment problem is if i pick him i have to downgrade another player for it to happen


so

who would be better???????

For starters, Enright will never be tagged. He plays off the half-back line with a few rotations through the midfield, but will never be the go-to man for other clubs.

 

[ANGEL DARK]

I wouldnt have any of them.They both arnt capable of giving big scores and will probably only average around 80.Get Priddis for around the same price as i can see him averaging around 100 this year and is a far better option

 

[Schmick]

tough decision this


Cooney


this is supposed to be cooneys year and hopefully it will be if i decide to pick him and hopefully it wont be if i dont decide to pick him

cooney would be 3rd in line to get tagged behind cross and west so thats no concern but im worried that if both or either one gets injured he could be be tagged every week


Enright

enright had a pretty good year last year and is 4th in line to be tagged behind ablett,bartel and corey so something tragic would have to happen for him to be tagged so im kind of favouring him at the moment problem is if i pick him i have to downgrade another player for it to happen


so

who would be better???????

3rd in line? Doubt it.

He's the most damaging player out of those 3 and get's just as much as the ball as the other 2 so I can't see how he wouldn't get the no1 tag this year when he'll probably be even better than last year.

 

[SJ]

You think Enright will get priority over Ablett and Bartel? You're kidding yourself. A lot of the time he won't get tagged ahead of Corey either.

Pretty sure he was talking about Cooney.

 

[DanA]

Cooney is a gun but looks like he is just a touch off full fitness in terms of work rate although this time last year he was walking laps.

Enright won't get any better than last year in my opinion and he is about 8th inline for a tag behind; Ablett, Bartel, Corey, Chapman, Selwood, Wojcinski and Stokes.

Stanton is another at that price that needs to be considered.

 

[IhateMondays]

Cooney is a better choice, as I really liked his end to last season.

Enright is in a premiership team. He won't get better

 

[the_berger]

doesnt matter i decided on cross

thx for all your help none the less

 

[flip211]

I wouldn't go for either. Cooney is inconsistent, though when his on, he scores very big. Enright won't justify that price I wouldn't have thought. He won't dominate with other players like Ablett, Bartel and Corey.

Stanton would be worth a look for the same price, really consistent baller winner who rarely misses a game. Or perhaps Chris Knights. Certainly knows how to get it, however his dispoal is pretty poor which would lead to a fair few clangers.

In that price range, I would personally get Priddis as he will most likely be their number 2 midfielder behind Kerr, instead of number 4 or 5 behind Judd and Cousins (even though Cousins hardly played a game). Chad Fletcher, provided his fit and injury free will also have a great year. Or even further down the order, Brent Reilly should do well because he will be handed more midfield responsiblity.