Damon White for 5th rounder?

[Portmanteau]

Going on how Choco ******edly rates him, you may be on a winner here. May have to throw in Ian Perrie but...

 

[Stiffy_18]

I seriously don't understand what Damon White has to do to keep his spot. I just don't understand why he seems to be on the outer.

He would walk into a lot of AFL sides.

 

[Blue Red and Gold]

DONE!

 

[macca23]

I went to the Port games v Richmond and West Coast.

Damon White was very impressive in both of these, yet has been dropped immediately on each occasion.

Adelaide should have a crack at getting him if Choco doesn't want him. He looks a very likely forward who can take a contested mark, who should be playing AFL footy each week.

 

[theorangeapple]

you would think he would come back to WA and play with the shockers or eagles. both would be willing to take him. is he contracted for next year?

 

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by theorangeapple
you would think he would come back to WA and play with the shockers or eagles. both would be willing to take him. is he contracted for next year?

No.

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

White for Perrie + 5th rounder -> Sign up immediately!

Can't understand why White is getting a poor deal. Must of let down Choco's tyres or something...

 

[jc67]

My guess is that if wants to play finals this year he will resign.
I doubt port will let him go and his selections (or lack of em) has more to do with list managment and manipulation than just his form

 

[PAfolwr]

If you offered a tagger, Choco would trade him in a second.
Names?

  First four games
                K  M  H.B  D  HO  T  G  P
Jonathan Brown  0  0   0   0   0  1  0  0
                8  7   5  13   4  1  0  0   
                1  0   0   1   1  0  0  0      
                8  4   4  12   6  0  0  0

Warren Tredrea  2  0   2   4   0  1  0  0
                0  0   0   0   0  0  0  0         
                4  3   4   8   1  1  2  0         
                5  3   4   9   1  1  3  0          
                3  0   3   6   2  0  1  3
(5 for Tredrea as not sure about gametime in round1 1998) 

Damon White     5   4   1  6   0  0  1  0     
                7   4   2  9   0  0  3  0             
                6   6   2  8   1  0  1  2        
                5   2   2  7   0  1  2  0

 

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by PAfolwr
If you offered a tagger, Choco would trade him in a second.
Names?

  First four games
                K  M  H.B  D  HO  T  G  P
Jonathan Brown  0  0   0   0   0  1  0  0
                8  7   5  13   4  1  0  0   
                1  0   0   1   1  0  0  0      
                8  4   4  12   6  0  0  0

Warren Tredrea  2  0   2   4   0  1  0  0
                0  0   0   0   0  0  0  0         
                4  3   4   8   1  1  2  0         
                5  3   4   9   1  1  3  0          
                3  0   3   6   2  0  1  3
(5 for Tredrea as not sure about gametime in round1 1998) 

Damon White     5   4   1  6   0  0  1  0     
                7   4   2  9   0  0  3  0             
                6   6   2  8   1  0  1  2        
                5   2   2  7   0  1  2  0

Robert Shirley

 

[PAfolwr]

Originally posted by Stiffy_18
Robert Shirley

How would you rate him compared to Cochrane?

 

[PAfolwr]

Originally posted by PAfolwr
How would you rate him compared to Cochrane?

Unfortunately that was a serious question.
White got dropped for Cochrane.
Shirley and Cochrane both taggers.
Both have done occasional jobs in past. Judd and Hird come to mind.
Unfortunately we play finals to win 1-0, so we need more taggers. The more the better.
How has is form been this year compared to Cochrane? I have watched SFA non Port games so far this year.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by PAfolwr
How would you rate him compared to Cochrane?

He is more of an inside player than the Roach. Roach is more versatile in that he can take the on bigger midfielders ala Pavlich.

 

[PAfolwr]

Originally posted by Stiffy_18
He is more of an inside player than the Roach. Roach is more versatile in that he can take the on bigger midfielders ala Pavlich.

Sorry Stiffy, my sarcasm tonight is a bit too subtle. Still in shock.

Time for Port to lose a game so that we get a kick up the backside before the finals I think, and that obviously includes the coaching staff. But if we do lose it will be (totally and wholly) the players fault.

 

[Stiffy_18]

Originally posted by PAfolwr
Sorry Stiffy, my sarcasm tonight is a bit too subtle. Still in shock.

Time for Port to lose a game so that we get a kick up the backside before the finals I think, and that obviously includes the coaching staff. But if we do lose it will be (totally and wholly) the players fault.

We want White anyway

 

[Portia]

Originally posted by PAfolwr
But if we do lose it will be (totally and wholly) the players fault.

The upside is that Choco has already dropped White so can't do it again!

 

[PAfolwr]

Originally posted by Stiffy_18
We want White anyway

Not funny.