Dane Swan AA??

[Swanny36]

Is Dane Swan going to get an AA jumper this year?

 

[hellfire]

No.

Midfield is too deep.

Ablett, Bartel, Harvey, Black, Cooney, Corey and Mitchell are ahead of him for selection. Might get a gig in the 40.

 

[alberto_cat]

good year, but he wouldn't be top 10 in the midfield IMO, he'd be between 12-20...

so i don't think he will make it, same with about 20 others who could be considered "unlucky" after the AA has been done

 

[Faz 2000]

Not this year, no.

 

[dontaskfev]

if he improved his disgrceful ground kicking he might have been half a chance

 

[jonesy86]

Should definitely be in the 40-man squad but not quite in the AA team. If there was an AA 1st XXII and a 2nd XXII named he would definitely be in the 2nd XXII.

 

[Soul_Pie]

Not this year. Has had a stellar season, but there are aspects of his game which he needs to clean up a bit. Certainly has the capacity to be All Australian.

 

[Claude Balls]

Not unless he can displace one of Bartel, Ablett, Harvey, Cooney, Corey, Mitchell etc...

I'll be surprised if he makes the 40 man squad.

 

[magpie_militia]

No, not for mine.

He has had a great year, but is still lacking in certain areas.

 

[Magpie Mick]

Not unless he can displace one of Bartel, Ablett, Harvey, Cooney, Corey, Mitchell etc...

I'll be surprised if he makes the 40 man squad.

Yeah and that is despite the fact that he rips the Geelong midfield to threads every time we play the cats!!!

 

[Claude Balls]

Yeah and that is despite the fact that he rips the Geelong midfield to threads every time we play the cats!!!

Does he? Every time? Wow, better put him in then! That would be at least one awesome game, EACH year!

 

[Dee Snider]

Not unless he can displace one of Bartel, Ablett, Harvey, Cooney, Corey, Mitchell etc...

I'll be surprised if he makes the 40 man squad.

Swanny is a gun..but unfortunatley he is no Ablett, Harvey or Bartel.