Garrick Ibbotson

[Roy boys]

I dont want to critiscise selection before a game has started & i may be even be wrong thinking it but surely this boy should be getting a game i think he a very good talent.

 

[newlander77]

I will be very shocked if he doesn't. I'd pick him over Schammer.

 

[Dyslexic Emo]

I dont want to critiscise selection before a game has started & i may be even be wrong thinking it but surely this boy should be getting a game i think he a very good talent.

No one cares what you think unlisted

 

[Kenny_01]

Agreed. Can not believe we have selected McManus before him.

 

[Reveler]

Agreed. Can not believe we have selected McManus before him.

I don't mind McManus as much as M.Carr

 

[wehavethepassion]

Harvey has been too cautious.

 

[ting tong]

any chance of some 11th hour mind games..? Macca gets the sniffles... MCarr slams his thumb in his hotel room door and hey presto! in come Ibbo and Palmer?

 

[newlander77]

Unfortunately the late change is more likely to be Hayden.

 

[Freo Shark]

It might just be that they are ALL on their "last chance" and they're playing for their spots next week?

Macca and Matt Carr are probably due a last chance?

 

[YelloMit]

I think he just wants to get the first win in the season NOW. He probably thinks the experience of Macca and M Carr will get them over the line.

I have a feeling next week at Subiaco (we are playing at Subi next week right?), he'll play Palmer and Ibbotson.

 

[hoogs]

I'd rather play them both back at the WAFL to remind them of just how good they are. Then let them loose in the AFL once they're confidence is skyhigh.

 

[Kram]

I think he just wants to get the first win in the season NOW. He probably thinks the experience of Macca and M Carr will get them over the line.

I have a feeling next week at Subiaco (we are playing at Subi next week right?), he'll play Palmer and Ibbotson.

Agree with this, no rush to play Palmer, he'll get his chance.

 

[ting tong]

yeah thats probably fair.. no rush.

watch for Carr and Macca to have a blinder now and leave me with egg all over my face

 

[Clay Davis]

yeah thats probably fair.. no rush.

watch for Carr and Macca to have a blinder now and leave me with egg all over my face

Unlikely.

How long has Matt Carr had to prove himself?

 

[Reveler]

with a strong back and forward line showing some faith in our new young midfielders can't be a bad idea.

 

[pinkus maximus]

should have played today

may not have made a difference to the result but he could not have been worse than Carr

this is his third year on the list. you cant hide him from these occasions anymore

 

[Lach72]

should have played today

may not have made a difference to the result but he could not have been worse than Carr

this is his third year on the list. you cant hide him from these occasions anymore

Exactly.
I would rather get creamed playing Ibbotson and Palmer than McManus (atyhough he was good) and Matt Carr