Gehrig / Milne

[HoldenMCaulfield]

well, Gehrig may not be the best for these conditions and Milne did manage to score two ...

... but was this possibly the last time we saw either of them play for St Kilda ?

Gehrig did not even try and capitulated in the first quarter !

I don't see any reason for either to be picked next week !

what do you think ?

in contrast - Harvey is great, isn't he ?

 

[Larry Donahue]

Good points. However they will play again. Milne seems to save himself for the Cats. Problem is neither of them perform when it really counts. I'd love to see the Saints win games like tonight and they should given the talent on paper. But it seems the only one that wants it bad enough is Harvey...

 

[weet-bix kid]

Just got back from the port game and st kilda lacked mainly structure/common sense. Milne and Gehrig as all the other forwards where victim to a team playing dry football on a wet sorry bloody wet night.

Why stuff round on a wing, chip short passes, offer no leads (except to a dead pocket!) and finally and overuse the ball on a wet day.

Looks like another long year!

 

[weet-bix kid]

Must admit though, harvey is immortal. What a champ!

 

[chapmanmagic35]

Good points. However they will play again. Milne seems to save himself for the Cats. Problem is neither of them perform when it really counts. I'd love to see the Saints win games like tonight and they should given the talent on paper. But it seems the only one that wants it bad enough is Harvey...

Milne never kicks goals against Geelong

 

[mick ryan]

Dont despair fans you'll probably have that mental and physical crock Gardiner playing shortly then you'll really see a DUD!

 

[oporto]

Milne did manage to score two ...

One of those was in junk time. He was unsighted for most of the game. Surjan owned him.