Hamish McIntosh?

[Bobby_]

With what you saw of McIntosh in season 2014, will he be good enough to hold his spot in Geelong's starting eighteen with a possible Stanley/Blicavs combination or Simpson/Vardy/Clark rucking combination?

 

[Jaeger]

If he can't hold his spot ahead of that group he should give it away.

 

[Engimal]

McIntosh is good enough, his body just won't hold up. I think he'll be Geelong's preferred ruck if he's fit.

 

[timtamWB]

He'll be the number one ruck if he's fit. Rotating with Vardy (if he's fit) in the forward line and Blicavs is so versatile that he can fit into the team as well.

But what happens to Dawson Simpson? He showed a lot of good signs. Of course assuming these guys are all uninjured.

Geelong needs to get some luck with their rucks.

 

[Donkey Chop]

I wish there was an option that doesn't have "overrated" but I do think he's done.
Don't think he was ever overrated. I know I always saw him as an average ruck who could take a grab but kicked like a ruckman.
Never heard any North supporters say he was a star or anything. I don't get it?
Did Geelong supporters think they were getting Brad Ottens?

 

[TazHawk15]

He can be their number 1 ruckman but that is no big deal as they have the weakest ruck stocks in the AFL.

 

[Heaps of fun]

From what I've seen of Dawson Simpson you'd play Hamish with his feet cut off over him.