Harts gone

[Bluebear]

Never really though about the injuries, just thought the 23 would suit Hendo nicely.

Anything official from the club yet or are they just waiting to announce everyone at the same time?

I suspect they will wait until players get back from holidays over the next week or so. Often the will announce a few if not all together.

They may also be waiting on Stevens decision to see how many they need to let go...........one might be saved by the combination of Stevens and Fev going unexpectedly.

 

[RooDog]

Shame.. Had a thumping kick on him..

Who was the bloke from Richmond he closed line behind play and got 2 weeks for? Opening game in 2008 if memory serves...

Was at the game.. He should have got about 6 weeks.. Was a peach..

All the best big fella...

was Cam Howat.

 

[TheKITC]

It's official.

Prove it....

I haven't seen any official* de-listings for Carlton as yet.

*of·fi·cial (

-f

sh

l) adj.
1. sanctioned by, recognized by, or derived from authority
2. verified officially; confirmed
3. made or communicated by virtue of authority; as, an official statement or report.

I don't like to sound nit picky, but as likely as it may be, official it isn't.

 

[jonoman89]

His facebook says he's sacked. I trust he wouldn't say he's out of a job unless he really was...

 

[Jeremias]

Prove it....

I haven't seen any official* de-listings for Carlton as yet.

*of·fi·cial (

-f

sh

l) adj.
1. sanctioned by, recognized by, or derived from authority
2. verified officially; confirmed
3. made or communicated by virtue of authority; as, an official statement or report.

I don't like to sound nit picky, but as likely as it may be, official it isn't.

Ever heard the saying "straight from the horse's mouth"?

 

[TheKITC]

Ever heard the saying "straight from the horse's mouth"?

Funnily enough I have, in conjuction with reading it countless times on BF along with 'my very reliable source says' and 'I have it on good authority' and how do you reckon most of those have turned out?

Catch my drift?

As I said, it might be nit picky, but claiming something is official just because you or anyone else believes/hears it does not make it so, regardless of your reputation or total posts on BF. It's official when it's official.

 

[Jeremias]

Funnily enough I have, in conjuction with reading it countless times on BF along with 'my very reliable source says' and 'I have it on good authority' and how do you reckon most of those have turned out?

Catch my drift?

As I said, it might be nit picky, but claiming something is official just because you or anyone else believes/hears it does not make it so, regardless of your reputation or total posts on BF. It's official when it's official.

Keep holding on to hope if you must.

He's gone. I like him but a fact is a fact and Adam Hartlett is no longer a player for the Carlton Football Club.

 

[TheKITC]

Keep holding on to hope if you must.

He's gone. I like him but a fact is a fact and Adam Hartlett is no longer a player for the Carlton Football Club.

I give up...

The bolded part is nothing but speculation at this stage, but you're apparently not going to see it that way.

A fact is something that can be proven. I can prove that he still is a Carlton listed player as of right now, can you prove otherwise?

Didn't think so.

 

[Jeremias]

I give up...

The bolded part is nothing but speculation at this stage, but you're apparently not going to see it that way.

A fact is something that can be proven. I can prove that he still is a Carlton listed player as of right now, can you prove otherwise?

Didn't think so.

I can.

But I suppose that you'll need a press release or media conference before you can label the news 'official', so there's not much point me continuing on with this.

 

[TheKITC]

I can.

But I suppose that you'll need a press release or media conference before you can label the news 'official', so there's not much point me continuing on with this.

I'm not claiming that Harts is not in trouble from being delisted, I think he is a good chance to get the chop, but that's just an opinion, as is yours. My issue here is that you've claimed that any such de-listing is 'official' and 'a fact' and wrongly so.

So don't bother posting pics with the attempt to discredit me or be mildly humerous at my expense. You either have factual and official proof or you don't. You can't claim that it's official and factual on one hand, then say 'oh well if I need actual proof then there is no point me continuing'.

Even you can surely see the contradiction and stupidity in that can't you?

 

[Koutafidamedis]

TheKITC you are correct. Even though there is a good chance it is true. Hearsay does not equal official.

 

[DIG]

I'm not claiming that Harts is not in trouble from being delisted, I think he is a good chance to get the chop, but that's just an opinion, as is yours. My issue here is that you've claimed that any such de-listing is 'official' and 'a fact' and wrongly so.

So don't bother posting pics with the attempt to discredit me or be mildly humerous at my expense. You either have factual and official proof or you don't. You can't claim that it's official and factual on one hand, then say 'oh well if I need actual proof then there is no point me continuing'.

Even you can surely see the contradiction and stupidity in that can't you?

To quote Adam's facebook page:

"Adam Hartlett is officially unemployed... ouch!"

Is that "hearsay", an "opinion"? No, it's fact.

So if he wasn't "officially" given the arse, why would he say "I am officially unemployed"?

Or do we need a press release before we believe him.

 

[blueblood25]

Ouch... Gotta love FB

 

[Mister Carlton]

Poor kid.

 

[celtic_pride]

Poor kid.

Actually no, a poor kid is someone like Darcy Freeman.

Hartlett is healthy young man whose pro football club was cut short by injuries, you can say he's unlucky, but by no means does he deserve pity/sympathy ...

Get your priorities right man.

 

[40yearBLUE]

Truth be told, Hartlett was a very costly 'draft' blunder, considering the players taken after him in the draft.

Pat Garner (taken 2 picks after Harts) has been delisted by the Lions today, maybe we could right that mistake we made and scoop him up? Nnlikely he will last until our pick now that the word is out.

 

[The Toad]

Actually no, a poor kid is someone like Darcy Freeman.

Hartlett is healthy young man whose pro football club was cut short by injuries, you can say he's unlucky, but by no means does he deserve pity/sympathy ...

Get your priorities right man.