How do you rate them?

[TimeFor11]

In terms of position how would you rate Richmond's options?

KP Backmen: Bowden>Thursfield>Polak>McGuane>Rance>Schulz>Hughes
Small Backmen: Newman>King>Raines>Jackson
HBF: Deledio>Newman>McMahon>Raines>Connors>Tivendale>JON>Hyde>Casserly>Moore>White
Wingman: Deledio>Tambling>Morton>Tivendale>Raines>Connors>Cotchin>Edwards>Pettifer>Meyer>JON>Hyde>Casserly>Collins
Midfield:Foley>Coughlan>Tuck>Johnson>Brown>Deledio>Tambling>Newman>Polo>Raines>Cotchin
Ruckman:Simmonds>Pattison>Graham>Polak>Putt
HFFettifer>Deledio>Tambling>Morton>Edwards>Meyer>Hyde
Small Forward:Brown>Tambling>Edwards>Cotchin
KP Forward:Richardson>Simmonds>Polak>Riewoldt>Schulz>Hughes>Pattison>Putt

I think this illustrates that we have a well balanced list going into 08' season, every team will posses more HBF than any other position and we are the same.

Thats my view do you guys think there are any shockers in there or on the most part agree?

 

[Madtiger2006]

I think we are getting a fair bit of depth now. It would be good to be able to bring in a Hyde in case we have a few injuries up forward

 

[tugga]

I think we are getting a fair bit of depth now. It would be good to be able to bring in a Hyde in case we have a few injuries up forward

LMAO at Madtiger. I go away for a month and Hyde is still your love child. You got it right when you said we are starting to get depth. But you lost me when you said to bring in Hyde.
The depth is getting there. Two years ago we wouldn't have dreamt of delisting Krakouer because those lining up to replace him weren't even there to be in line. Now we're culling the weak and replacing them with the strong.
Still a ways to go people. Our next finals appearance won't be a fleeting one like 95 and 01. Our next finals appearance will be the first of a few years of continued finals appearances.
We'll know we've finally turned the corner when we go to games expecting to win rather than hoping and starting the season expecting to make the finals rather than hoping. We will view other clubs as filth that need to be brushed aside just as those clubs viewed us for so long.
It's still a few years away, but it's happening.

 

[Madtiger2006]

LMAO at Madtiger. I go away for a month and Hyde is still your love child. You got it right when you said we are starting to get depth. But you lost me when you said to bring in Hyde.
The depth is getting there. Two years ago we wouldn't have dreamt of delisting Krakouer because those lining up to replace him weren't even there to be in line. Now we're culling the weak and replacing them with the strong.
Still a ways to go people. Our next finals appearance won't be a fleeting one like 95 and 01. Our next finals appearance will be the first of a few years of continued finals appearances.
We'll know we've finally turned the corner when we go to games expecting to win rather than hoping and starting the season expecting to make the finals rather than hoping. We will view other clubs as filth that need to be brushed aside just as those clubs viewed us for so long.
It's still a few years away, but it's happening.

If Hyde get's fitter he'll be a gun at half forward. I think he still has alot to offer

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Hyde was the first to understand Terry,s game plan of run & carry.A few have caught on since however in the scheme of things Hyde is still up there even though his confidence took a huge hit in the clash with Mcguire.

 

[sante]

In terms of position how would you rate Richmond's options?

KP Backmen: Bowden>Thursfield>Polak>McGuane>Rance>Schulz>Hughes
Small Backmen: Newman>King>Raines>Jackson
HBF: Deledio>Newman>McMahon>Raines>Connors>Tivendale>JON>Hyde>Casserly>Moore>White
Wingman: Deledio>Tambling>Morton>Tivendale>Raines>Connors>Cotchin>Edwards>Pettifer>Meyer>JON>Hyde>Casserly>Collins
Midfield:Foley>Coughlan>Tuck>Johnson>Brown>Deledio>Tambling>Newman>Polo>Raines>Cotchin
Ruckman:Simmonds>Pattison>Graham>Polak>Putt
HFFettifer>Deledio>Tambling>Morton>Edwards>Meyer>Hyde
Small Forward:Brown>Tambling>Edwards>Cotchin
KP Forward:Richardson>Simmonds>Polak>Riewoldt>Schulz>Hughes>Pattison>Putt

Rance isn't ahead of Schulz.
Deledio isn't a HBFer anymore. McMahon will be our best. JON/Connors aren't better than Hyde.
Tivva is our best wingman at the moment.
Riewdolt isn't better than Schulz and Patto.

 

[emperor]

In terms of position how would you rate Richmond's options?

KP Backmen: Bowden>Thursfield>Polak>McGuane>Rance>Schulz>Hughes
Small Backmen: Newman>King>Raines>Jackson
HBF: Deledio>Newman>McMahon>Raines>Connors>Tivendale>JON>Hyde>Casserly>Moore>White
Wingman: Deledio>Tambling>Morton>Tivendale>Raines>Connors>Cotchin>Edwards>Pettifer>Meyer>JON>Hyde>Casserly>Collins
Midfield:Foley>Coughlan>Tuck>Johnson>Brown>Deledio>Tambling>Newman>Polo>Raines>Cotchin
Ruckman:Simmonds>Pattison>Graham>Polak>Putt
HFFettifer>Deledio>Tambling>Morton>Edwards>Meyer>Hyde
Small Forward:Brown>Tambling>Edwards>Cotchin
KP Forward:Richardson>Simmonds>Polak>Riewoldt>Schulz>Hughes>Pattison>Putt

I think this illustrates that we have a well balanced list going into 08' season, every team will posses more HBF than any other position and we are the same.

Thats my view do you guys think there are any shockers in there or on the most part agree?

I need a codebreaker to decipher that post

 

[RichosGuns]

The way I see it for the current RFC list is:

Premier superstar players:
Nathan Brown

Upper Echelon players (fit into every best teams 22):
Troy Simmonds (If he can comeback from injury)
Mark Coughlan (if he can comeback from injury
Mathew Richardson
Nathan Foley (at this stage - still developing)
Joel Bowden

Good players (fit into most teams best 22):
Kayne Pettifer
Brett Deledio (at this stage - still developing)
Chris Newman
Jordan McMohan

From here there is probably a group of Graham Polaks and Shane Tucks who are better then average players, but after that I feel that all our other players fit into the ran of the mill or worse(Tivendale, Hyde, etc.) or the developing (Polo, Conners, Pattison etc.)

 

[LuKe2428]

In terms of position how would you rate Richmond's options?

KP Backmen: Bowden>Thursfield>Polak>McGuane>Rance>Schulz>Hughes
Small Backmen: Newman>King>Raines>Jackson
HBF: Deledio>Newman>McMahon>Raines>Connors>Tivendale>JON>Hyde>Casserly>Moore>White
Wingman: Deledio>Tambling>Morton>Tivendale>Raines>Connors>Cotchin>Edwards>Pettifer>Meyer>JON>Hyde>Casserly>Collins
Midfield:Foley>Coughlan>Tuck>Johnson>Brown>Deledio>Tambling>Newman>Polo>Raines>Cotchin
Ruckman:Simmonds>Pattison>Graham>Polak>Putt
HFFettifer>Deledio>Tambling>Morton>Edwards>Meyer>Hyde
Small Forward:Brown>Tambling>Edwards>Cotchin
KP Forward:Richardson>Simmonds>Polak>Riewoldt>Schulz>Hughes>Pattison>Putt

I think this illustrates that we have a well balanced list going into 08' season, every team will posses more HBF than any other position and we are the same.

Thats my view do you guys think there are any shockers in there or on the most part agree?

C.H.BENCH johnson>>>>>>>>>hyde collins meyer