How Wrong Does this Look?

[TradeDraft]

That Just Looks Wrong

 

[blaze036]

The WCE shirt actually suits dicky i reckon...

Good luck to them, no longer of use to us but they get another chance.

I dont think dick will play many more AFL games in his career sadly, Jmac could easily play 5-6 years of average-good footy for port and will help them become competitive on field

 

[76woodenspooners]

That Just Looks Wrong

Yeah, you're right, it's very strange to see a picture of Dicky without his shoulder strapped.

 

[Copeland]

Remember when Josh Mahoney ended up at Port

 

[Ed D]

Looks like McCarthy already has a black eye. Welcome to Port Adelaide! I wonder if a team mate did that?

 

[Markfs]

i feel sorry for anyone joining Port. Its a bit like someone being forced to live in a place that looks like Planet of the Apes..

 

[soreplums]

I reckon J-Mac will have a very good year for Port. Not a match winner, but definitely a player who will have a consistent year and will be an important player for them. I even think that he will score well for DT!

 

[Ed D]

I reckon J-Mac will have a very good year for Port. Not a match winner, but definitely a player who will have a consistent year and will be an important player for them. I even think that he will score well for DT!

I agree with you there. He showed that he was capable at AFL level, just not to the standard that would get him a regular game with the Pies, plus he was never given his preferred role simply because there were better players ahead of him in the midfield.

I wouldn't be surprised if he had a similar impact to what Rodan had in his first year at Port.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

McCarthy looks amazing in any jumper that isn't Black and White.

Dicky?

 

[vjknight]

I reckon J-Mac will have a very good year for Port. Not a match winner, but definitely a player who will have a consistent year and will be an important player for them. I even think that he will score well for DT!

but not SC, right ??

 

[Hawkas1988]

Hey Guys, sorry to intrude on your board, I just want to say i was sad to see Brad Dick get delisted at the end of last year, as I always liked him when he played for you boys. He just seemed to really enjoy playing and always had a big smile on his face. It's good to see him get another chance but it seems like he isn't the same player he use to be.

I'm just interested to hear from some of you Collingwood fans on what ultimately went wrong. I know he got injured when he was in good form a couple of years back, did he constantly get injuries? Or was he just showing poor form after recovering from the injuries?

Also, do you reckon if he never got injured in the first place, would he have kicked on as a player and kept his place in your side?

Appreciate anyone's responses

 

[blaze036]

Hey Guys, sorry to intrude on your board, I just want to say i was sad to see Brad Dick get delisted at the end of last year, as I always liked him when he played for you boys. He just seemed to really enjoy playing and always had a big smile on his face. It's good to see him get another chance but it seems like he isn't the same player he use to be.

I'm just interested to hear from some of you Collingwood fans on what ultimately went wrong. I know he got injured when he was in good form a couple of years back, did he constantly get injuries? Or was he just showing poor form after recovering from the injuries?

Also, do you reckon if he never got injured in the first place, would he have kicked on as a player and kept his place in your side?

Appreciate anyone's responses

A couple of shoulder reco's then a couple of knee recos were the last straw. Had huge talent, but very injury prone and too skinny.

If not for injuries, he for sure would of been a good forward and played 150 games. I doubt he'll play many more afl games howerver sadly.

 

[Ed D]

A couple of shoulder reco's then a couple of knee recos were the last straw. Had huge talent, but very injury prone and too skinny.

If not for injuries, he for sure would of been a good forward and played 150 games. I doubt he'll play many more afl games howerver sadly.

The club also gave him the option to be rookied but he instead chose to go back to WA.

He couldn't get his body right and he now has mental issues to overcome as last year he pretty much refused to tackle because of his shoulder.

 

[Hawkas1988]

Thanks for the responses, it is sad to see, he is still quite young, just a shame injuries have taken their toll.

 

[speedytiger]

I wish them all the best. They didn't leave for money or any sinister reasons, both seem popular and likeable. I reserve the right to change my mind if they tear us up!

 

[Prestigerrycomo]

No hate or grudge against Dicky, was sad he could never get regularly on the park for us. His joy of a goal was infectious to watch. I wish him all the best (bar against Collingwood )

 

[Dawesome Dock]

Could McCarthey potentially be the next Heath Scotland.. can't remember Scotland too well but always thought he was a plodder for us and has turned it on big time for the blues. Imagine if he did that to us!

 

[Chief Ten Beers]

This also looks wrong.

 

[Ed D]

Could McCarthey potentially be the next Heath Scotland.. can't remember Scotland too well but always thought he was a plodder for us and has turned it on big time for the blues. Imagine if he did that to us!

I'm not sure he'd reach Scotland's standards but it wouldn't surprise me if he had a solid career at Port.

 

[blaze036]

This star-nosed mole....






also looks wrong.