Hypothetical: Who would go?

[mikeythemoocow]

Say that something had happened and we had to lose one of out top two players, Judd or Fev. Who would go?

 

[Will_Hayward]

Joke topic?

 

[mikeythemoocow]

not a joke topic. Heaps of hot air blowing around and such, not much truth to anything till April and results start showing up in the W's and L's. Just thought what would be the state of play if we had to lose one of our best two players?

 

[zillmere]

Do you mean who would the club get rid of or who would you personally get rid of?

Pretty pointles poll since the club is currently in the process of giving fev the punt.

Judd could kill a bus load of grannies & still be the most loved man at Carlton.

 

[mikeythemoocow]

Do you mean who would the club get rid of or who would you personally get rid of?

If you had to move one player on who would carlton keep in the quest to get their next flag?

 

[Will_Hayward]

Who do you think the club should get rid of?
not who do you prefer/favorite, or such,
long term who is best for the club to keep?

Ooooh, so it WAS a joke topic.

Judd is younger, a better player, a better leader.

 

[Jeremias]

The answer may well be revealed during the next week........

 

[Wokko]

Ooooh, so it WAS a joke topic.

Judd is younger, a better player, a better leader.

Not the last one. A better figurehead maybe. One of the best players ever, but not a leader's toenail.

 

[Blu_Outlaw]

Say that something had happened and we had to lose one of out top two players, Judd or Fev. Who would go?

Good ? but I dont think many ppl will reply.

Strange thing is I get the impression from reading posts on bigfooty and talking with friends most Carlton supporters would say Juddy stays.

The strange part is opposition supporters think Fev is our most influential player.

As for loving Juddy, I will start loving him when he shows that he loves Carlton.

 

[pgm87]

Judd or Fev??? is the pope a catholic??

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Not the last one. A better figurehead maybe. One of the best players ever, but not a leader's toenail.

So you think Fev's a better leader than Judd? Interesting.

People take Judd's quiet demeanour as a lack of leadership. Let's face it, that's all they have to go on because they are not inside the club.

I have heard he spends time with his midfielders individually to help them with their game. I have heard Murphy especially looks up to him greatly. I have heard he sets the example in terms of preparation and professionalism. I have heard he participates in leadership group meetings (anybody in those meetings by any chance?). There is a hell of a lot more to leadership than an ability to dress down your teammates in front of a 70k crowd. Just because you don't see his neck veins bulging, that doesn't mean he has nothing to say. This all started when the Eagles fans felt that Cousins was still the leader and helped lift the cup on the GF dias, and it has snowballed from there.

Judd might not be extroverted but does anybody really know what sort of leader he is, if they are not in his team?

 

[CUG81]

judd wipes his ass with fevs face!

none are leaving boys! judd will put another 20 plus stabs onto fevs chest next season.

 

[bluespur]

judd wipes his ass with fevs face!

none are leaving boys! judd will put another 20 plus stabs onto fevs chest next season.

Fev is gone has played his last game for the Blues ,better get used to it

 

[raymagoo]

IF THEY WERE sorry capitals, both 25 id take the chin! more demand for a gun forward then super gun mid

 

[Carlton_Blues]

Fev is gone has played his last game for the Blues ,better get used to it

Really? And pray tell which club has shown any real interest in him? Not one.

He'll remain a Blues boy wait and see.

 

[Kades_Dad]

Say that something had happened and we had to lose one of out top two players, Judd or Fev. Who would go?

That is assuming that Fev is actually in our top 2...

 

[Bomba Sheldon]

There is dayight between Judd & Fev, I have no problems with Carlton's stance on Fev if they believed it was warranted - its about time they got a bit of backbone in their decision making.

 

[blue gunslinger]

Unfair question really
Who is more important on game day - Fev is our fwd focus but we do have to get the ball down there to him: draw
Who is more imortant to the team and club off the field - Judd easy
Who would I choose if we HAD to get rid of one due to the current problem - Fev did the crime so does the time
Has Judd been tarnished by Seagalgate and the Fev trouble - I think so
Can we do without one - yes and no
Can we do without both - yes but NO
Can we keep both - I hope so