inandouts RD15

[332docker]

In: Crowley, Duffield, Foster, Murphy

Out: Parker, McManus, M.Carr, Warnock

Emerg: Gilmore, Webster (if he is fit)

I'm sorry but milestones and longevity just don't cut it anymore for me. Start putting the players with the best disposal and fitness/speed. M.Carr just does not have the confidence to spot someone else up and turns it over more often than not. Macca can be good in short burst, but we need people who can be consistant over a whole game. Parker, i think he knows this is his last year with freo, needs to give way to give us a shot. Warnock, unlucky but could probably do with a break after shouldering the load the last few games. Johnson, Murphy and Mundy can pinch hit when Sandi needs a rest..

CC Please start playing these players where they are used to and good at playing:
Backs: Hayden McPharlin Thorton
Half-backs: Johnson Grover Duffield
Centres: Black Crowley Schammer
Half-forwards: Headland Pavlich Tarrant
Forwards: Farmer Murphy Solomon
Followers: Sandilands J.Carr Rover: Bell
Interchange Dodd Mundy Haselby Foster

Dodd is a much better tagger than MCarr and should be thrown back into the middle.

I'm still optimistic if these changes get made. If they continue with the veterans who are passed it then our seasons shot. The time for sentiment is gone!

Cheersandbeers 332 docker

 

[Singo]

In: Crowley, Duffield, Foster, Murphy

Out: Parker, McManus, M.Carr, Warnock

Emerg: Gilmore, Webster (if he is fit)

I'm sorry but milestones and longevity just don't cut it anymore for me. Start putting the players with the best disposal and fitness/speed. M.Carr just does not have the confidence to spot someone else up and turns it over more often than not. Macca can be good in short burst, but we need people who can be consistant over a whole game. Parker, i think he knows this is his last year with freo, needs to give way to give us a shot. Warnock, unlucky but could probably do with a break after shouldering the load the last few games. Johnson, Murphy and Mundy can pinch hit when Sandi needs a rest..

CC Please start playing these players where they are used to and good at playing:
Backs: Hayden McPharlin Thorton
Half-backs: Johnson Grover Duffield
Centres: Black Crowley Schammer
Half-forwards: Headland Pavlich Tarrant
Forwards: Farmer Murphy Solomon
Followers: Sandilands J.Carr Rover: Bell
Interchange Dodd Mundy Haselby Foster

Dodd is a much better tagger than MCarr and should be thrown back into the middle.

I'm still optimistic if these changes get made. If they continue with the veterans who are passed it then our seasons shot. The time for sentiment is gone!

Cheersandbeers 332 docker

Is farmer going to be fit to play this weekend?? The injury didnt look to good when he did it

 

[332docker]

Is farmer going to be fit to play this weekend?? The injury didnt look to good when he did it

Singo


I hope so we looked a lot better when he was out there! Lets hope the medico's can sort him out!

cheersandbeers 332docker

 

[DOCKER MAN]

I woud like to see Ibo in the side again (28 possesions for easts and BOG) and Foster in the side, Duffield, Crowley, Murphy all deserve spots somewhere in the side. M Carr and S Parker both need to be dropped, anyone else dropped may be a little bit unlucky. Mundy may be due for a week in the WAFL i'm sure he would wake up and return to form with a dominant performance.

 

[Clay Davis]

M Carr needs to be taken out and shot. He is USELESS.

 

[chook2734]

I can't believe the number of people who want to drop players in the senior team for 'not performing' only to replace them with players who aren't even performing at a lower level.

Webster hasn't even played for 3 or 4 weeks - why on earth would he be in the 25? Warnock should not be out of the team unless he is injured or fatigued - if you want to see the young guys get a go, maybe a good start would be to keep letting those who are already playing keep playing.

Duff is average at best - his disposal is appalling and his decision making isn't far behind Gilmore's in being the worst at the club. Murphy showed again on Saturday why he hasn't been playing this year - it's not so easy to kick a bag when he hasn't got Jeffrey delivering it to him on a platter.

Idoesn't sound like Crowley is setting the world on fire down at Subi - why reward him with a spot if the reason he was dropped was to make him realise he needs to earn his place?

I'd be surprised to see anymore than one or two changes this week, unless they are forced on us by injury (we seem to be having an extraordinary run of luck with the MRP at the moment - at least 3 weeks now where no one has even been cited )

 

[Clay Davis]

That's why we're shit Chook. Poor recruiting and poor player management. Quit making excuses.

 

[Brumbies]

Murphy showed again on Saturday why he hasn't been playing this year - it's not so easy to kick a bag when he hasn't got Jeffrey delivering it to him on a platter.

So put him in the side where The Wizz is playing plus he deservers it after his past form gets a game and then dropped which wasnt his fault CC just needs to keep him at FF.

 

[masai]

Chook you are on the same wavelength as me.

Don't reward players with senior selection till they deserve it. On Saturday I watched Duffield and Murphy play ................... pathetic is an under statement.

Macca is in some peoples gunsights, he is still doing a job.

We all know Big Carr has incriminating photo's of the coaching staff ..........

 

[masai]

So put him in the side where The Wizz is playing plus he deservers it after his past form gets a game and then dropped which wasnt his fault CC just needs to keep him at FF.

Do you want these kids to think they have gold passes to senior selection ?, they must play in the WAFL like their life depends on it. Murphy showed a lack of morale fibre on Saturday, up against a very good team he had the stage to show his wares, but he couldn't be bothered.

Down the road Cookie is busting his gut probably knowing the curtain may have been drawn on his AFL career, I know who deserves a recall most next week ................ it aint Murph.

 

[Purple Passion]

I can't believe the number of people who want to drop players in the senior team for 'not performing' only to replace them with players who aren't even performing at a lower level.

Webster hasn't even played for 3 or 4 weeks - why on earth would he be in the 25? Warnock should not be out of the team unless he is injured or fatigued - if you want to see the young guys get a go, maybe a good start would be to keep letting those who are already playing keep playing.

Duff is average at best - his disposal is appalling and his decision making isn't far behind Gilmore's in being the worst at the club. Murphy showed again on Saturday why he hasn't been playing this year - it's not so easy to kick a bag when he hasn't got Jeffrey delivering it to him on a platter.

Idoesn't sound like Crowley is setting the world on fire down at Subi - why reward him with a spot if the reason he was dropped was to make him realise he needs to earn his place?

I'd be surprised to see anymore than one or two changes this week, unless they are forced on us by injury (we seem to be having an extraordinary run of luck with the MRP at the moment - at least 3 weeks now where no one has even been cited )

Yet i remember CC saying they rated him in the top 3 kicks at the club last season what a liar i have yet to see the best of Duffman i hope one of the guys does a Drew Petrie and takes it up a notch

 

[chook2734]

Do you want these kids to think they have gold passes to senior selection ?, they must play in the WAFL like their life depends on it. Murphy showed a lack of morale fibre on Saturday, up against a very good team he had the stage to show his wares, but he couldn't be bothered.

Down the road Cookie is busting his gut probably knowing the curtain may have been drawn on his AFL career, I know who deserves a recall most next week ................ it aint Murph.

Exactly masai - everyone wants to drop the players who are perceived to have these gold passes, only to hand the gold pass straight onto the next guy. No wonder we've been on the same merry-go-round for 13 years.

 

[Scham]

There is no better WAFL form atm than Fosters, he has to be rewarded sooner than later.

The ironic thing is that while teams are playing youth and having success, CC has gone the other way and not getting success, but in an all out effort to get a win this week, CC will again rely on experience. Talk about stubborn!

 

[pistol17]

There is no better WAFL form atm than Fosters, he has to be rewarded sooner than later.

The ironic thing is that while teams are playing youth and having success, CC has gone the other way and not getting success, but in an all out effort to get a win this week, CC will again rely on experience. Talk about stubborn!

On the money Scham. I dont know what else Foster would have to do to get a gig. Brings him own footy sometimes.

 

[Bradesmaen]

He'd have to rename himself to Nathan Buckley, then he might get a gig.

 

[FREO81]

Changes for round 15

In: Murphy, Foster, Crowley, Webster, Gilmore Duffield
Out: Dodd, Thornton, McMannus, Parker, M.Carr Mundy

Hayden Mcpharlin Grover
Solomon Johnson Black
Schammer Foster Crowley
Webster Pavlich Tarrent
Famer Murphy Headland
Sandilands Bell J.Carr

Hasleby Gilmore Warnok Duffield
Emg Mundy Dodd M.Carr

If raining Freo should drop Sandiland so his groin doesnt flare up and put in a running midfielder or defensive midfielder. ie Mundy, M.Carr.
Freo has to drop Dodd his confiednce to mark an release the ball is poor.
Duffield better option.
Thornton should even be in the AFL his judgment to dispose the ball is useless and plus he his just to skinny and get out muscled in every contest, he only has speed. Gilmore better option and more flexible. Mcmannus has courage and thats all that (why we got Solomon), he needs pace and good decision making. Crowley better option and he is a tag better than anyone in the team.
Parker to old and past his used by date. Solomon to take his spot down back and run off the backline. Johnson Grover Mcpharlin and Hayden doing a better job and understand each other better without Parker.
Murphy should be in every week because every club in the competition knows his talent. He knows when to lead and how to kick goals. He takes one of the best defenders and the pressure off Pavlich and Tarrent who should be at Centre half foward together creating a double marking option every time the ball goes foward.
Mundy i feel is slacking off a bit a should return to the WAFL with M.Carr for a wake up call. Webster in can do the same job as both men.
Foster should be in. Its a long time over due. Freo needs another fast, young, in and under running midfielder

 

[dont bowl there]

Dodd has been one of our best players all year, you are a complete fool if you want him dropped.

 

[Belnakor]

Changes for round 15

In: Murphy, Foster, Crowley, Webster, Gilmore Duffield
Out: Dodd, Thornton, McMannus, Parker, M.Carr Mundy

Hayden Mcpharlin Grover
Solomon Johnson Black
Schammer Foster Crowley
Webster Pavlich Tarrent
Famer Murphy Headland
Sandilands Bell J.Carr

Hasleby Gilmore Warnok Duffield
Emg Mundy Dodd M.Carr

If raining Freo should drop Sandiland so his groin doesnt flare up and put in a running midfielder or defensive midfielder. ie Mundy, M.Carr.
Freo has to drop Dodd his confiednce to mark an release the ball is poor.
Duffield better option.
Thornton should even be in the AFL his judgment to dispose the ball is useless and plus he his just to skinny and get out muscled in every contest, he only has speed. Gilmore better option and more flexible. Mcmannus has courage and thats all that (why we got Solomon), he needs pace and good decision making. Crowley better option and he is a tag better than anyone in the team.
Parker to old and past his used by date. Solomon to take his spot down back and run off the backline. Johnson Grover Mcpharlin and Hayden doing a better job and understand each other better without Parker.
Murphy should be in every week because every club in the competition knows his talent. He knows when to lead and how to kick goals. He takes one of the best defenders and the pressure off Pavlich and Tarrent who should be at Centre half foward together creating a double marking option every time the ball goes foward.
Mundy i feel is slacking off a bit a should return to the WAFL with M.Carr for a wake up call. Webster in can do the same job as both men.
Foster should be in. Its a long time over due. Freo needs another fast, young, in and under running midfielder

You say Dodd is a poor kick and then suggest Duffield? Duffield couldn't hit the side of a barn with a handful of wheat at the moment.
Solomon down back would be a disaster, Solly works better as the hunter.
Murphy doesn't deserve a spot until he can show he can get a kick without Jeffrey giving him silver service.
Foster should bin, agreed.
Thorton is a ball carier and a defensive forward, while his form hasn't been brilliant, he has been having a red hot go which is more than you can say for guys like MCarr.
Mundy needs to go because he has been pulling out of contests all year. I think he has a place in the side, but he needs to learn to shepherd and do the 1%ers first.
I will tear my hair out if MCarr gets another game. He was just awful on the weekend.

 

[Kenny_01]

I want to see:

n: Foster, Crowley, Ibbotson, Duffield
Out: McManus, Parker, M.Carr, Mundy (2 week stint in WAFL)

Get some run/youth through the middle. If two of the above 4 look promising, good signs for next season.

 

[pistol17]

You say Dodd is a poor kick and then suggest Duffield? Duffield couldn't hit the side of a barn with a handful of wheat at the moment.
Solomon down back would be a disaster, Solly works better as the hunter.
Murphy doesn't deserve a spot until he can show he can get a kick without Jeffrey giving him silver service.
Foster should bin, agreed.
Thorton is a ball carier and a defensive forward, while his form hasn't been brilliant, he has been having a red hot go which is more than you can say for guys like MCarr.
Mundy needs to go because he has been pulling out of contests all year. I think he has a place in the side, but he needs to learn to shepherd and do the 1%ers first.
I will tear my hair out if MCarr gets another game. He was just awful on the weekend.

Solomon plays his best footy in defence, did you miss his career with Essendon?

 

[pistol17]

I want to see:

n: Foster, Crowley, Ibbotson, Duffield
Out: McManus, Parker, M.Carr, Mundy (2 week stint in WAFL)

Get some run/youth through the middle. If two of the above 4 look promising, good signs for next season.

Id like to see Walker come back instead of Crowley. Walker smashed Subiaco's midfield which includes Crowley. If we are rewarding WAFL form then Walker must come in after 37 Possessions and 4 goals. Jimmy is showing how much he wants another gig in the purple jumper.

 

[foxy_dal]

does anyone know if andrew browne has started playing wafl yet since injuring his hammy?

 

[Belnakor]

Solomon plays his best footy in defence, did you miss his career with Essendon?

He was shithouse last year in defense. Thats why he was traded for a 3 round pick, not a 1 first round pick.

 

[Belnakor]

Id like to see Walker come back instead of Crowley. Walker smashed Subiaco's midfield which includes Crowley. If we are rewarding WAFL form then Walker must come in after 37 Possessions and 4 goals. Jimmy is showing how much he wants another gig in the purple jumper.

Walker does look promising, but i think Walker is beginning to get into the troy longmuir / brendon fewster range of players. He'll tear it up in the WAFL, but goto AFL level and go missing. I think Jimmy deserves one last shot, put him in the midfield and let him have a go. If he doesn't go well for 2 weeks hes gone and he'll be delisted. I think thats just where Jimmy is right now.

 

[pistol17]

Walker does look promising, but i think Walker is beginning to get into the troy longmuir / brendon fewster range of players. He'll tear it up in the WAFL, but goto AFL level and go missing. I think Jimmy deserves one last shot, put him in the midfield and let him have a go. If he doesn't go well for 2 weeks hes gone and he'll be delisted. I think thats just where Jimmy is right now.

Yea your right he is on his last chance, id like to see him played in the same position he dominates in the WAFL. Attacking midfielder, give him a go, we havent got much to lose at the moment