Remove this Banner Ad

Ins and Outs

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

P

Perty4

Club Legend
Veteran
Dec 29, 2002
1,966
227
No where you'd find
AFL Club
Gold Coast
In Betheras , Presti, Scotland.
Outs none yet

COLLINGWOOD
B: Johnson, Wakelin, Clement
HB: Shaw, J.Cloke, Burns
C: Lonie, Buckley, Williams
HF: Davis, Rocca, O’Bree
F: Tarrant, Molloy, Holland
FOLL: Fraser, Licuria, Woewodin
I/C (from): Betheras, Cole, Lokan, McKee, Didak, Prestigiacomo, Scotland
IN: Betheras, Prestigiacomo, Scotland
OUT: -
 
Originally posted by Perty4
I/C (from): Betheras, Cole, Lokan, McKee, Didak, Prestigiacomo, Scotland
Click to expand...

Geez, what four do you think would get the nod there?
Having a hard time deciding.

I'd go: Didak, Prestigiacoma (if fit obviously), Scotland, McKee

I know Dids has been out of touch but he is the type of player that will proabably pick-up again and kick 3 or 4 vital goals. If he fails to make an impact again though, back to Willy he goes.

Bit reluctant to say McKee. But if Fraser flops, we are in trouble.

Scotland DESERVES another crack for God's sake.

If Presti doesn't come up, give Cole or 'Rockin Lokan the nod.

Would love to give RUPE a game but...well yeah.
 
Yay, Scoots, yay!!

I'd like to see Joshy spend a fair bit of the time in the ruck on Monday too, regardless of whether Stunner plays.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

I'd go for Didak, Cole, Scotland & Presti.

McKee is a dud. Even in the games where he gets a bit of the ball, he still costs us in the ruck. Rocca hasn't been doing much at CHF, so he can earn his bucks with stints in the ruck.

It's time to get real with Lokan. Yes, he has been OK, but is he really better than Scotland, just because he has some dash? Same goes for Shaw.

Cole has dash and whilst he isn't a defender, I'd rather persist with a guy who looks like breaking through pretty soon and has a massive potential upside!

Don't worry about Didak. He'll be fine.

We have to make our move right now. We need to be at the very least 11 wins after the next 8 rounds, with the four remaining matches including Brisbane (home), Adelaide (home), Sydney (Away) and Essendon. Hopefully we will be in good enough form to knock two or more of those sides off, but we cannot bank on it.
 
Was exactly what I was about to say Figgy, whilst Lokan has definately been better than expected and has added some much needed dash he's still not a better footballer than Scoots - and has been playing as a midfielder (Scoots position) lately to boot. You have to question MM's philosophy when he isnt putting our best players on the park each week. 'Team balance' is over-rated.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Ins and Outs

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top