Ins & Outs V Port

[JP83]

Im assuming Hyde will be missing for you guys and am i right in saying that he would be a bigger loss than most people think?
Pickett is back for us and will make a huge difference, mentally as much as anything.
Whats the story with Kane Johnson?
If i were you guys id be playing Tambling this week. We are a bit slow at the moment with players out and underdone through the midfield.
From our point of view if we can win 40% of the ball in the midfield id be confident, as our forward line is extremely efficient and our defence is solid.
I know you guys have 3 big forwards, but its the small to medium sized guys that have worried us.
Should be a good game.

 

[Balthazaar]

Apparently Miller was on the radio last night talking about how they'd be looking to bring some speed into the side against your lot.

 

[Captain Blood]

Krak
Chaffey
Raines
Hyde (unfortunately)

All need a rest.

In
Tambling
Meyer
Roach
Johnson (if fit)

Where are Gilmour an Archibald at in their progress?

 

[silence ofthe Robert]

Captain, why would you replace Raines who has showed a bit in the seniors with Roach who has showed next to nothing in the 2s.

I'm tipping only Tambling in for Hyde, but would be happy to see Johno and Meyer in for Chaffey and Krak.

 

[nut]

gilmour maybe a chance. I wouldn't be dropping Raines. Let him develope in the ones

 

[jackson_rules]

Krak
Chaffey
Raines
Hyde (unfortunately)

All need a rest.

In
Tambling
Meyer
Roach
Johnson (if fit)

Where are Gilmour an Archibald at in their progress?

mate gilmour i would be picking b4 meyer he has showed alot more at coburg and would run out an AFL match alot easier then meyer or tambling

 

[silence ofthe Robert]

Gilmour has showed little except for two games against Box Hill in the last year and a bit. Not bagging him because he is very young and I was happy to see him finally have a good one on Monday. I think he needs to learn the game a bit and string many good games together before being considered. Meyer also probably needs more time but I saw him at Coburg a couple of weeks ago and he is all class and has all the attributes, good in the air, good on the ground , moves well and has terrific disposal. At this stage Meyer is in a different class to Gilmore. I see absolutely no reason to rush Gilmore in especially as he is behind the queue in relation to Meyer.

And re Gilmour before Tambling - you must be on drugs!

 

[telsor]

SotR, you say Gilmour shouldn't be in because he's only had 1 good game for coburg...Meyer and Tambling haven't had any good games for Coburg yet and last I heard 1>0 .

 

[silence ofthe Robert]

SotR, you say Gilmour shouldn't be in because he's only had 1 good game for coburg...Meyer and Tambling haven't had any good games for Coburg yet and last I heard 1>0 .

You heard wrong. Tambling was good on Monday and also in the Wizz Fizz. Meyer has been beating his opponent each week learning the caper off half back in previous games. By the way Deledio hasn't played a good game for Coburg either. Maybe we should drop him for Gilmour or Morrison.

 

[Stafford678]

Out
Hyde
Chaffey
Krak(prob wont happen tho)

In: Tambling, Meyer,Pattison/Johnson

Its at the dome, we should try stretch their defence, with cornes missing they have thurstans in the backline and hopefully we could isolate him with stafford.

We gotta rearly double team tredrea like the saints did too our talls.

 

[oxx]

In - Tambing

Out - Hyde.

 

[kretchy]

I'd bring Tambling in for Hyde and although unlikely to happen wouldn't mind Moore in for Graham.

 

[richcogs]

Can someone with a membership please go to this link:
http://210.50.4.102/rfc/

And go down to the Flood report click on it, type in your membership number and your surname and then click enter and you'll see a report by the Coburg Coach, David Flood on each of the individual performances of the Coburg players on the weekend, tambling, meyer, gilmour, ect...........

Then can u copy and paste it on this thread.
Thanks

 

[Fishfinger]

richocogs - that's in "Eye of The Tiger".
It is not allowed to be copied to message boards. Being able to read it is a privilege of being a current member.

Pickett returns from suspension for PA this week.

 

[richcogs]

Does it say anything about meyer or pato?

 

[Tigerbob]

I'd bring Tambling in for Hyde and although unlikely to happen wouldn't mind Moore in for Graham.

What has Graham done wrong??

I think he has been bloody fantastic for us, a lot more solid than AK and his skills have been top notch! From what ive seen of Moore he has a bit to go, and there is no need to rush him in with Graham doing an outstanding job!!!

 

[metallichris]

Get a membership richcogs... besides they havent updated it yet anyway.

 

[richcogs]

I've had a membership for 6 years, since I was 9. But bloody had to move up to Albury/Wodonga. Middle of know where. So it'd be pretty useless.

 

[sante]

Im assuming Hyde will be missing for you guys and am i right in saying that he would be a bigger loss than most people think?
Pickett is back for us and will make a huge difference, mentally as much as anything.
Whats the story with Kane Johnson?
If i were you guys id be playing Tambling this week. We are a bit slow at the moment with players out and underdone through the midfield.
From our point of view if we can win 40% of the ball in the midfield id be confident, as our forward line is extremely efficient and our defence is solid.
I know you guys have 3 big forwards, but its the small to medium sized guys that have worried us.
Should be a good game.

Hyde is huge loss and without Johnson our midfield has only got Cogs and Tuck

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

IN:Gilmour and Meyer
OUT:Hyde and Krakour.
Id give Tambo another week for 2 reasons.
1/:More or less the same reason he wasnt picked last week.The message it would give other cubs for all the wrong reasons.
2/:His game was ok but still needs probally one more game under his belt.

 

[roo_stew]

I've had a membership for 6 years, since I was 9. But bloody had to move up to Albury/Wodonga. Middle of know where. So it'd be pretty useless.

Membership is never useless...its what helps make us stronger. I dont get to go much either but I hope my membership bucks do some good somewhere for the Tiges cos I am a member for the "club" not for me. I accept that is a concept that is valued less these days sadly.

 

[Krakustar]

OUt Hyde (inj) Chaffey (ret)
In Gilmour Pattison

 

[evo]

Out
Hyde
Chaffey
Krak(prob wont happen tho)

In: Tambling, Meyer,Pattison/Johnson
.

Good call.Pattison was great against Box Hill.

Krak needs to be dropped.Chaffey needs to be delisted.

Gilmour also deserves consideration soon too.His disposal is improving,played well against Box Hill.