Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Jaidyn Stephenson

  • Thread starter Thread starter Scottie65
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

He had his chance and he blew it.
 
Scottie65 said:
Would you take back a fresh minded jaidyn Stephenson
Click to expand...
Sorry Scottie, I know he’s a family friend of yours, but I don’t want him anywhere near our club anymore.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Scottie65 said:
Would you take back a fresh minded jaidyn Stephenson
Click to expand...
I’d take him into the VFL program, a solid 6-12 months proving he has a new and improved attitude then we can talk…

Kid has talent, attitude/application was always the problem. At 26 though it’s probably last chance saloon and he’d need to be ready and willing for a VFL stint. If not, instant pass.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

For all the people saying they wouldn’t want him anywhere near the club etc, it’s a short sighted perspective.

look at someone like [PLAYERCARD]Tyson Stengle[/PLAYERCARD]. Stepho doesn’t have near the same rap sheet. If he can prove commitment through a strong 12 months in the VFL the talent is and has always been there… Just needs to prove commitment.

Only way to do that is playing cold weekends on mud fields without the AFL paycheck. Otherwise just feels like a final cash grab IMO.
 
Let's be honest, he played some incredible footy in his first two seasons. He looked like he could be anything. But his career was derailed by a combination of his own youthful foolishness, a lack of professionalism, and a clear culture clash with Bucks, who was the paragon of professionalism and didn't suffer anyone who didn't fully commit to the high standards he demanded (and rightfully so).

It was 110% the right move to trade him out. (I won't just him on his career after that point, because I don't think Gary Ablett Snr could have done much in that Kangaroos forwardline.)

That being said... if I could choose any coach and culture to rehabilitate a talented but troubled young man and get them playing their best footy again, it would be Fly and the Collingwood coaching staff.

Would I take a flyer on a rookie list spot? From a purely talent to cost perspective, I think I maybe would. Former first round rising star winners rarely come cheap, or in this case, completely free.

Would the playing group, most of whom played alongside him, be open to bringing him back? I have my doubts. He seems to have burnt a fair bit of trust there, and this squad value culture and connectedness above all else.

Would Jaidyn himself be willing to fully commit to the professional standards required of an AFL footballer in 2026? I'd say, Scottie65, you're probably in a better position to answer that than anyone else on here.
 
Play him in the VFL, look at the mid season, he’s never going to walk into any team.

I’m actually a “No” but he’s talented and don’t like seeing it wasted
 
lenny20 said:
Let's be honest, he played some incredible footy in his first two seasons. He looked like he could be anything. But his career was derailed by a combination of his own youthful foolishness, a lack of professionalism, and a clear culture clash with Bucks, who was the paragon of professionalism and didn't suffer anyone who didn't fully commit to the high standards he demanded (and rightfully so).

It was 110% the right move to trade him out. (I won't just him on his career after that point, because I don't think Gary Ablett Snr could have done much in that Kangaroos forwardline.)

That being said... if I could choose any coach and culture to rehabilitate a talented but troubled young man and get them playing their best footy again, it would be Fly and the Collingwood coaching staff.

Would I take a flyer on a rookie list spot? From a purely talent to cost perspective, I think I maybe would. Former first round rising star winners rarely come cheap, or in this case, completely free.

Would the playing group, most of whom played alongside him, be open to bringing him back? I have my doubts. He seems to have burnt a fair bit of trust there, and this squad value culture and connectedness above all else.

Would Jaidyn himself be willing to fully commit to the professional standards required of an AFL footballer in 2026? I'd say, Scottie65, you're probably in a better position to answer that than anyone else on here.
Click to expand...
Or would the family club be willing to welcome back the prodigal son, if he can prove he's changed his ways?
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom