Oppo Camp James Aish (Traded to Freo 2019)

[TradeDraft]

1. Because he's been poor

2. I dont think its possible to under-rate a player who's yet to achieve anything yet.

He was Poor start of the Season but lot better since coming back from the VFL

1. Didn't call him a hack

2. His kicking is only average from what I've seen, 15-30m dinky passes aren't a sign of elite footskills

How that equals you claiming that I think he's the worst player on the list is beyond me.

You did not call him a Hack but comes accross in yout Posts

He has Kicked some Lovely Kicks that go about 30-40 Meters to Cloke last few weeks.

He is in quite a Bit of Scoring Involvments

 

[Chief Ten Beers]

Aish will be fine. He is a bit cautious, but considering his small frame I don't blame him. Can't question his courage though because he goes when it's his turn. He isn't a Heeney who is AFL made straight away but he'll be a fine player over the next few years for the Pies after a few preseason and years in the gym. His skills are A+

 

[TradeDraft]

See him lot happier out there then early in the year. Smiles when he is out there now

 

[Bay Pie]

Clearly finding his niche on where he sits in the team. Expectations will increase next year, but at this early point in his time with us, nothing to be concerned about at all.

Decision making remains very good.

Gee, the BF expectations on players under the age of 22 has become quite absurd.

 

[Baltimore Jack]

Clearly finding his niche on where he sits in the team. Expectations will increase next year, but at this early point in his time with us, nothing to be concerned about at all.

Decision making remains very good.

Gee, the BF expectations on players under the age of 22 has become quite absurd.

I blame Gen Y

 

[Maggie5]

Almost a lost year at Brisbane, first time actually being coached and still only just played his 40th (eight with us). Expect big improvement from here.

Seems to have very clean skills and good decision making and getting better with every game I think he will be very handy long term.

 

[HFF]

It's all about development for him. he is still only 20yrs old.

 

[MarkT2]

He's still young but at this stage I've nothing that would make him stand apart. He could well develop into a handy player but I can't see him being a player that will worry teams in pre planning.

 

[TradeDraft]

He's still young but at this stage I've nothing that would make him stand apart. He could well develop into a handy player but I can't see him being a player that will worry teams in pre planning.

His Descion Making and Ball Use sets him apart

 

[MarkT2]

His Descion Making and Ball Use sets him apart

Apart from the crap players but not the good players. I'd rank that side of his game as goodish in a side well below average on that score.

 

[Old Spice]

His decision making is timid and as such his lauded skills are not obvious. With that low a possession tally he needs to offer some comparative advantage like damaging disposal, aerial ability, agility or foot speed. His decision making needs to be more bold (not handing off a problem) and we'll see if the skills are there.

 

[pablo disco bar]

Gee he doesn't do much tbh

 

[ksardog]

As ive said before, very vanilla. Nothing outstanding about him.

 

[TradeDraft]

His decision making is timid and as such his lauded skills are not obvious. With that low a possession tally he needs to offer some comparative advantage like damaging disposal, aerial ability, agility or foot speed. His decision making needs to be more bold (not handing off a problem) and we'll see if the skills are there.

Well vs GWS he had 5 Scoring Involvements and 6 Tackles. Lot of his Kicks are to Advantage.

He has not Handballed Off as Much as he did early in the Season

 

[Baltimore Jack]

He's still young but at this stage I've nothing that would make him stand apart. He could well develop into a handy player but I can't see him being a player that will worry teams in pre planning.

Watch his hands the next time he plays Mark, he is deadly with a handpass

 

[Old Spice]

Well vs GWS he had 5 Scoring Involvements and 6 Tackles. Lot of his Kicks are to Advantage.

He has not Handballed Off as Much as he did early in the Season

I'll watch again tomorrow but felt very much to me like MIA and dragging the chain.

 

[TradeDraft]

I'll watch again tomorrow but felt very much to me like MIA and dragging the chain.

Well with 11 Touches he needs to do more but He makes a Impact when he does.

Caff was the 1 dragging the Chain

 

[Old Spice]

Well with 11 Touches he needs to do more but He makes a Impact when he does.

Caff was the 1 dragging the Chain

Caff was a negating forward, his role was to shut down Shaw which he did.

 

[ksardog]

Well with 11 Touches he needs to do more but He makes a Impact when he does.

Caff was the 1 dragging the Chain

Mccaffer was far more important to the win than Aish ever was.

Negated GWS's primary rebounder, was actually good to see him back playing that defensive forward role like he use to.

 

[JollyBallsUp]

Mccaffer was far more important to the win than Aish ever was.

Negated GWS's primary rebounder, was actually good to see him back playing that defensive forward role like he use to.

To be honest that is the only role what the team requires him to play. Greenwood is a far better player on the ball than McCaffer ever was.

 

[TradeDraft]

Caff was a negating forward, his role was to shut down Shaw which he did.

Shaw still had 20 Touches so was not Quite Taken out of the Game

 

[Vicky Park]

Didn't step up in the way he did against Carlton, and still seems a bit tentative. But I put that down to confidence, maturity and experience, all of which will improve.

I think he will become, for us, the player I expected Broomy to be. Can we have both in the team? Neither looks like being a great accumulator.

 

[Apex36]

Didn't step up in the way he did against Carlton, and still seems a bit tentative. But I put that down to confidence, maturity and experience, all of which will improve.

I think he will become, for us, the player I expected Broomy to be. Can we have both in the team? Neither looks like being a great accumulator.

You might be surprised with Broomy if he gets his chance through the middle in the seniors. Has been known to rack up the disposals with the best of them playing in ball in the VFL.

 

[FIGJAM]

I reckon he played well. Doesn't panic. Draws a player then creatively hit our blokes in space.

Wouldn't worry about the possession count. That'll lift over time. His ball usage is unteachable though.

 

[DAWESOME!!]

Thought the things he did were good. And saw a couple of possessions that were anything but tentative.