Speculation Jed Walter

[The Kings Ransom]

Jed Walter and Calsher Dear almost identical stats from their first 3 years
Both very talented and athletic.
Both out of contract end of year.

One pick 3
One pick 56



Would the asing price be similar for them both if they wanted to leave?

 

[Chip Scab1]

Back to Jed?

2028 R1 for Jed + 2026 R2.

Lock it in, Larry.

Jed Walter and Calsher Dear almost identical stats from their first 3 years
Both very talented and athletic.
Both out of contract end of year.

One pick 3
One pick 56



Would the asing price be similar for them both if they wanted to leave?

Cant expect much more than a 2027 R2.

You might get a 13-20 this year if someone falls in love.

 

[marcmurphy3]

I think it's getting to a point with Jed where it would be a real risk chasing him.

You'd have to offer 5+ years at >800k plus trade good picks. Some of the deals being put out in the media are even higher.

He's in his 3rd year and shown few signs he'll be a star. And he needs to become that to justify the above. Yes, he was a good junior but highly drafted key forwards have a long history of being hit and miss.

Im not saying he wont make or be a good player but right now the risk/reward of trading for him is looking iffy.

 

[Chip Scab1]

I think it's getting to a point with Jed where it would be a real risk chasing him.

You'd have to offer 5+ years at >800k plus trade good picks. Some of the deals being put out in the media are even higher.

He's in his 3rd year and shown few signs he'll be a star. And he needs to become that to justify the above. Yes, he was a good junior but highly drafted key forwards have a long history of being hit and miss.

Im not saying he wont make or be a good player but right now the risk/reward of trading for him is looking iffy.

Yep, I'd imagine his Live Price would be a 2027R2.

 

[txbyhull]

Yep, I'd imagine his Live Price would be a 2027R2.

Having a laugh

 

[Tugga27]

Yep, I'd imagine his Live Price would be a 2027R2.

You gave pick 25 for Caleb Daniel.

What did you end up paying for Matt Whitlock?

 

[Chip Scab1]

You gave pick 25 for Caleb Daniel.

 

[Jirik13]

Likely another Jed's audition this Fri as Read aggravated PCL injury. Looking forward to it.

Unless Dimma decides to go with 2 rucks.

 

[Jirik13]

Haha, 2 first rounders for Jed.

Trade talk: Walter "refusing to sign a two-year contract"

“I'd expect some of those Victorian clubs to really knock hard.”

www.sen.com.au

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

Likely another Jed's audition this Fri as Read aggravated PCL injury. Looking forward to it.

Unless Dimma decides to go with 2 rucks.

Why? Surely you go with Knobel over Walter given ones in form and the other isnt?

 

[Jirik13]

Why? Surely you go with Knobel over Walter given ones in form and the other isnt?

You take it easy, haha. According to article, Eagles are interested in Jed. Better to start liking him.

Meanwhile, what is going on with Shanahan, my favourite?

 

[GoEaglesGoSGIO]

You take it easy, haha. According to article, Eagles are interested in Jed. Better to start liking him.

Id take Knobel for sure though as far as the other end of the spectrum goes. Was wanting him from well before you got him

 

[Jirik13]

Id take Knobel for sure though as far as the other end of the spectrum goes. Was wanting him from well before you got him

Knobel sure benefits from the new ruck rule but he looks too soft in contest to my liking but he is developing.

 

[NOBBYS]

Watched Knobel a couple of times in the VFL and he is miles from being AFL material.

 

[Go Woods]

Haha, 2 first rounders for Jed.

Trade talk: Walter "refusing to sign a two-year contract"

“I'd expect some of those Victorian clubs to really knock hard.”

www.sen.com.au

Really like him but your coach prefers King & JUH ahead of Walter.

 

[sunsofanarchy]

Haha, 2 first rounders for Jed.

Trade talk: Walter "refusing to sign a two-year contract"

“I'd expect some of those Victorian clubs to really knock hard.”

www.sen.com.au

We will really want a player though, won't we?

 

[txbyhull]

We will really want a player though, won't we?

I struggle to see how you could accomodate other players of quality coming back when your cap is soon to be bulging?

 

[sunsofanarchy]

I struggle to see how you could accomodate other players of quality coming back when your cap is soon to be bulging?

Yep, it's tough, we'd probably try and consolidate picks to take a high level of talent on low wage. But I could see walter, humprey and rogers go, now humphrey is on a low wage so thats a huge reason why we want to keep him but there would be some expected cap space available. An experienced forward pocket or wing would be nice

 

[bombersim]

I think it's getting to a point with Jed where it would be a real risk chasing him.

You'd have to offer 5+ years at >800k plus trade good picks. Some of the deals being put out in the media are even higher.

He's in his 3rd year and shown few signs he'll be a star. And he needs to become that to justify the above. Yes, he was a good junior but highly drafted key forwards have a long history of being hit and miss.

Im not saying he wont make or be a good player but right now the risk/reward of trading for him is looking iffy.

Completely agree. From the outside looking in, it doesn’t seem as though he’s made any real progress, and I’d say his greatest weakness was his lack of footy smarts - seems to really struggle to find the football and have an impact on the game.
Also, in the game against Essendon his kicking for goal was completely diabolical - like barely hit his foot type stuff.

Could be a bust like Jack Lukosious, but in the same way may get a fat contract and cost a first round pick (probably more), like Jack.

 

[THE_GUN]

Yep, I'd imagine his Live Price would be a 2027R2.

LOl Big Nose Brady paid #19 for CCJ
he will hand deliver your 1st rounder before you blink

 

[Chip Scab1]

LOl Big Nose Brady paid #19 for CCJ
he will hand deliver your 1st rounder before you blink

Can't. F/S crap. We'll potentially need another one if Harris' great form continues.

I'd happily do a 2028 R1 if we can't use that on Weitering or Wilson.

 

[txbyhull]

Can't. F/S crap. We'll potentially need another one if Harris' great form continues.

I'd happily do a 2028 R1 if we can't use that on Weitering or Wilson.

Sam Harris? He is not first round material right now dude what on earth

 

[Chip Scab1]

Sam Harris? He is not first round material right now dude what on earth

Not even close, there's an if/maybe. Had 21 + 3 on the weekend. IF he maintains this FORM and IF McCartney picks us, we might need two R1 selections. If, might, maybe, perhaps, conceivably.

 

[The 747]

Well at these prices I hope the Cats are in the hunt.

We had a big lumbering kid who couldn't find his way for the first three years and he turned out alright.

 

[txbyhull]

Struggling to see where he goes at the moment. Saints possibly? Melbourne if they don't get Humphrey?