Josh Caddy stomping

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

Only a fine for misconduct.

What a joke really, was far worse than what Sicily did and he got a week and was graded as "serious" misconduct.
 
That the triangle choke he put on Howe is only worth a fine is astonishing. Makes you wonder what a Richmond player has to do to be suspended
 
Boxhead_31 said:
That the triangle choke he put on Howe is only worth a fine is astonishing. Makes you wonder what a Richmond player has to do to be suspended
Click to expand...
Amazingly wasn't even called a free kick, game was still tight at that point, ball was in Hawks 50, umpire just tells them to get up?

If you watch the whole vision, Cotchin tackles Howe to ground without the ball, then you have his hand is stomped on, then he has legs intentionally wrapped around his head, not a single free kick and I have heard multiple radio personalities say that the game was well umpired and that the decisions were sensible.

Disgrace
 
Last edited:
Tex9798 said:
Amazingly wasn't even called a free kick, game was still tight at that point, ball was in Hawks 50, umpire just tells them to get up?

Amazingly if you watch the whole vision, Cotchin tackles Howe to ground without the ball, then you have his hand is stomped on, then he has legs intentionally wrapped around his head, not a single free kick and I have heard multiple radio personalities say that the game was well umpired and that the decisions were sensible.

Disgrace
Click to expand...

Howe got hard done by many times that game. Nearly had his head taken off by Martin (accidental) soccering a ball off and not called kicking in danger.
 
SSSSSS said:
Howe got hard done by many times that game. Nearly had his head taken off by Martin (accidental) soccering a ball off and not called kicking in danger.
Click to expand...

Yep, one kicking in danger was called last night to the Tigers and it was a soft toe poke, twice Hawks players had their hands kicked or the ball kicked out of their hands and no whistle.

Anyway, hows this from the AFL website:

"The headlock, also in the second term, was sparked by the Hawk dragging Caddy down."

Then proceeds to show video where Caddy is all over him and Howe is in the submissive position, yeah, Howe started it!
 
TW Sherrin said:
I watched the whole game and a lot of Richmond games this year. last night wasn't an isolated incident. They have been playing that way all year. I especially dislike their penchant for pushing unsuspecting players into marking contests or packs on the ground. It's dangerous.

If Barry Hall had a Hawthorn players head pinned between his knees what do you think would be today's discussion?
Click to expand...
Then stop watching.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Didn't look deliberate to me. Caddy dragging him off Cotchin, not looking down, and moved his foot away immediately.

If tiny things like this worry some people, they need to start watching a different sport
 
This thread =:'(:'(:'(:drunk::drunk::drunk::'(:'(:'(..........Me after reading = :think::rolleyes::D

Really Id expect no less from Geelong and Adelaide supporters.....sooking is second nature, but the rest of you guys....I'm embarrassed for you.
 
HairyO said:
Sicily got a week despite causing no damage.

I wonder how many Richmond fans called him a dog... plenty of Geelong ones did despite Enright doing the same thing.
Click to expand...
Yeah but just look at Sicly's head.....he should get 2 just for being born.........(just kidding, he's a good player)
 
blckcaviar said:
Didn't look deliberate to me. Caddy dragging him off Cotchin, not looking down, and moved his foot away immediately.

If tiny things like this worry some people, they need to start watching a different sport
Click to expand...

You are delusional, 100% intentional, looked like he was trying to squash a bug and not just move his foot, he didn't move it straight away either barely lifted his foot a good second later at which point Howe whips his hand out.

This needed the same penalty as Sicily and he gets away with nothing. Absolute disgrace from Michael Christian, how can you show two pieces of vision that show the same thing and one is straight to the tribunal and the other is a slap on the wrist just because it's finals?

Could have easily broken bones in his hands at which point he gets 2-3 weeks.
 
Tex9798 said:
You are delusional, 100% intentional, looked like he was trying to squash a bug and not just move his foot, he didn't move it straight away either barely lifted his foot a good second later at which point Howe whips his hand out.

This needed the same penalty as Sicily and he gets away with nothing. Absolute disgrace from Michael Christian, how can you show two pieces of vision that show the same thing and one is straight to the tribunal and the other is a slap on the wrist just because it's finals?

Could have easily broken bones in his hands at which point he gets 2-3 weeks.
Click to expand...
Valid questions. Until Michael gets back to you with his answer, try not to dwell, have a Bex and a lie down. Bloody Tigers. Stole your cup, broke your team and ate the last Tim Tam.
 
Thought he was Toby Greene for a minute but didn’t have the flexibility to get his foot to head height


Poor bloke - gotta warm up those hammies
 
Tex9798 said:
You are delusional, 100% intentional, looked like he was trying to squash a bug and not just move his foot, he didn't move it straight away either barely lifted his foot a good second later at which point Howe whips his hand out.
Click to expand...

In slow motion maybe. In real time he steps to keep balance, then picks his foot up straight away. I personally think Adelaide supporters need to stop commenting on anything Richmond related on here, it seems like some of you cannot be objective about them
 
TW Sherrin said:
I watched the whole game and a lot of Richmond games this year. last night wasn't an isolated incident. They have been playing that way all year. I especially dislike their penchant for pushing unsuspecting players into marking contests or packs on the ground. It's dangerous.

If Barry Hall had a Hawthorn players head pinned between his knees what do you think would be today's discussion?
Click to expand...

If Barry made one of his jokes at the same time he'd get 20 weeks.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

MisterMarcus
Josh Rachele on Jack Buckley
Replies
8
Views
661
incaciawin
incaciawin

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top