Are u a moron?
-
Guest - BigFooty Tipping 2026 - Get on! - $500 first prize - Weekly Prizes - Click to Join
PLUS Your club board comp is now up!
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Opening Round
The Golden Ticket - Official AFL on-seller of MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Judd
- Thread starter smooking39
- Start date
- Tagged users None
🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.
Are u a moron?
are you Stephen Milne?
Spartan
Brownlow Medallist
Not sure why most discussions on the Carlton board appear to deteriorate into off topic slanging matches, however I'd like to make a comment on the original post. 
Judd has never been your typical leader. He leads by example but rarely with passion. That was clearly evident from his time at West Coast. When he decided to leave some said it was because he was not passionate about being at West Coast. I disagree, I think thats his style and it was evident from his 'leadership' last night. I personally think a Captain should be more passionate and 'aggressive' in his style of leadership, especially in footy. Cuz, despite his mountain of off field troubles, was the second best Captain we've had behind Woosha and one of the best Eagles of all time. These guys bled blue and gold for the team.
I believe Stevens would have been a better choice for Captain with Judd as a deputy. However I think the Judd appointment was both a management/marketing decision as well as a football one.
As for Judd not being at his best, give the guy a break he's coming off an injury or a pre-season. Come the middle of the season we will know. I noticed that he got alot of the ball but he just wasn't as damaging on his runs and a couple of times got out run by Foley and King. Hopefully just cob webs but a couple of teeny weeny worrying signs. Also without Cox hand feeding him and Cuz and Kerr running alongside him its going to be a little harder for him.
Judd has never been your typical leader. He leads by example but rarely with passion. That was clearly evident from his time at West Coast. When he decided to leave some said it was because he was not passionate about being at West Coast. I disagree, I think thats his style and it was evident from his 'leadership' last night. I personally think a Captain should be more passionate and 'aggressive' in his style of leadership, especially in footy. Cuz, despite his mountain of off field troubles, was the second best Captain we've had behind Woosha and one of the best Eagles of all time. These guys bled blue and gold for the team.
I believe Stevens would have been a better choice for Captain with Judd as a deputy. However I think the Judd appointment was both a management/marketing decision as well as a football one.
As for Judd not being at his best, give the guy a break he's coming off an injury or a pre-season. Come the middle of the season we will know. I noticed that he got alot of the ball but he just wasn't as damaging on his runs and a couple of times got out run by Foley and King. Hopefully just cob webs but a couple of teeny weeny worrying signs. Also without Cox hand feeding him and Cuz and Kerr running alongside him its going to be a little harder for him.