Longmuir ......

[dockers_bengals]

I rate him highly but if his knee cant be fixed and he cant play at 100% should he go?In my opinion yes because teams know his problem and will exploit it,also if he can't train how will he last out the season?
any other thoughts

 

[Griffo]

If we had a full list to choose from then he probably would be left to get himself right.

Last year for the melbourne game we got towled up in the ruck division and it looks like melbourne have three good and fit ruckman to choose from.

 

[dockers_bengals]

The post derby game we only had warren as a ruckman,sandi had that mysterious jaw injury and longy was out.The next game sandi teamed with gilmore at subi.which we won.

 

[sumavich]

The post derby game we only had warren as a ruckman,sandi had that mysterious jaw injury and longy was out.The next game sandi teamed with gilmore at subi.which we won.

Sack him, bring in Black, Webster, and leave Gilmore to ruck.
Aslo bring in a youngster for Des.

 

[malpaso]

Drop him after the Melbourne game. Johnson will be back.

Prefer to see Murphy in the side.

 

[wehavethepassion]

He can't train properly. Vossey said that the problem with his knee(Longmuir's condition is silimar to what forced out Voss) was tha the found it difficult on mathc days because he gradually lost fitness and touch because he couldn't train properly and do all the work that was required.

FFC needs to send him for a spell and promote Warnock