Mick Malthouse

[pies2005]

Since Malthouse has been at the club we have lost a nuber of players who have gone on to play good footy at other clubs. I talk of
Mal Michael
Heath Scotland
Sav Rocca
Paul Williams
Andrew Shauble
Nick Davis

Now I know some of them wnated to leave, but we got nothing for them. We gave away a daft choice as well as Mal to get Molloy and that pic was Jarred Brennan. I just want o know your thought on whether you think Malthouse is still as good as everyone thinkshe is?

 

[richie_cole#13]

You idiot!!! Brennan was draft pick 3 and the last time we finished that low we got Didak with pick three. I think you'll find the trade involved Michael and a pick in the second or third rounds for Molloy. Not bloody pick 3. For williams we on traded the pick(s) we got to freo and got holland and clement. For scotland we got a young ruckman in the draft and we delisted sav rocca as Tarrant was coming through and sav was only kicking 30 to 40 goals a year.

 

[hotpie]

Michael's the only obvious mistake. On the Williams trade we ended up with Holland and Clement so we are ahead on that. Schaubles overrated, Sav's been just ok at North, Davis has done nothing at Sydney.

Scotland we gave away for almost nothing, but we were keeping him for Port in the Stevens trade.

 

[pies2005]

Sorry guys...not Brennan, it was Richard Hadley. Sorry my mistake

 

[Stan.]

We have certainly lost a few good players and got bugger all in return.