Nathan Brown

[sleek the elite]

Hi all,
As a Bulldogs supporter I have heard the rumors that Browny is a good chance of going to Collingwood. As pies supporters would you be satisfied? What key position players would you be willing to trade?

 

[Nic]

Ben Kinnear's all yours.

Seriously, we're not all that loaded up with KPP's as it is, besides a few youngsters. I seriously don't know what we could give up that would satisfy the dogs and not totally pss off the Pies supporters. Molloy (+ something, obviously)?

 

[Murray]

Brown is going to Essendon but we will give you Ben Kinnear for nothing.

 

[statman]

Brown will go to the Bombers and Nich Stevens is comming to Colingwood, if Brown comes to Collingwood we will give you Molloy and Davis or Didak, and a sraft pick maybee even Rocca, i heard that he is not happy with his current contract

 

[MarkT]

I would love to get Brown but we just don't have what the Dogs need. We have a few assorted hacks like Kinnear and Freborne and players like Scitland who make up a list of secondary midfielders who struggle with our midfield depth to get decent gametime. About the only player the Dogs would look at would be Molloy and his trade value has dived again. I'd hapily give up Molloy, Kinnear, McKee Scotland and Freeborne for Brown but I couldn't see the Dogs taking the deal.

Once again we saw what not having a ruckman does against quality oposition. If we trade quality players for midfielders and flankers again and we don't get a ruckman have to seriously question the intellegence and sanity of the match committee. We have a good list but the ruck flaw is so obvious that battlers like Caro and Sheehan could see it.

 

[statman]

If he truly wants to leave then they have no choice but to accept what ever they can get for him!