New Supercoach player, please evaluate

[kool kangas]

Again rather then start a thread I'll just post my team here.

Goddard
Fisher
Shaw
Cornes
Walker
Adcock
Malceski
Suban
Gallman


Judd
Selwood
Gibbs
Boak
Swallow
Rich
Beams
Robinson

Cox
Ottens
Vickery
Currie

Pavlich
Deledio
Brennan
Davey
Higgins
Yarran
Walker
Gumbleton
Brown

With 19,800 left can I have some thoughts?

Not too bad but l'd get rid of Swallow , l cant see him being in the starting line up of 22 every week ,so l'd replace him with Fosdike (Swans ) and you'll save 30,000 to used elsewhere.

 

[Big Nasty]

Thanks again BN, made quite a few changes here's the new team

Fisher, Cornes, Mackie, Birchall, McPhee, Malceski, Petterd (Suban, O'Keefe)

Cooney, Judd, Hartlett, Selwood Kerr, Rich (Davenport, Zaharakis)

Cox McIntosh (Currie, Sellar)

Pavlich, Didak, Deledio, Gianceracusa, Davey, Higgins, Ziebell (Ballantyne, Gumbleton)

I've spent less on the guns and i've gone for a better allround team and then upgrade to to the big guns later on, do these types of teams generally do well?

I know I was big raps for Hartlett, but when you look at Ports Midfield it is gonna be hard for him to get games this year.

Maybe trade him for Ziebiell, and in your forwardline put in Yarran instead of Ziebell.

I think your team looks great.

 

[PAFCsince1870]

Not too bad but l'd get rid of Swallow , l cant see him being in the starting line up of 22 every week ,so l'd replace him with Fosdike (Swans ) and you'll save 30,000 to used elsewhere.

You mean the Fosdike that's retired?

Nice advice

 

[PAFCsince1870]

On the browse. Thanks mate.

UPDATE: Kerr and Mackay out. Tambling (never thought I'd do that) and Hasleby in. Much better IMO.

Kerr and Mackay is infinitely better than Tambling and Hasleby.

What are you thinking?

 

[Signd Sealed Saint]

Fisher, Cornes, Mackie, Birchall, McPhee, Malceski, S.Hill (Suban, O'Keefe)

Cooney, Judd, Masten, Selwood, Van Berlo, Rich (Ziebell, Zaharakis)

Cox McIntosh (Currie, Sellar)

Pavlich, Didak, Deledio, Gianceracusa, Headland, Higgins, Yarran (Ballantyne, Gumbleton)

Steven Hill in, do you rkn he'll get a lot of games? Headland in, He'll score well but injury prone, Masten and Van Berlo in, Kerr out because he's gonna get suspended, do you think it's a decent choice? Thanks BN

 

[s1bbald]

Kerr and Mackay is infinitely better than Tambling and Hasleby.

What are you thinking?

Harsh, I like it. Back to the drawing board.

 

[Athomas]

Fisher, Cornes, Mackie, Birchall, McPhee, Malceski, S.Hill (Suban, O'Keefe)

Cooney, Judd, Masten, Selwood, Van Berlo, Rich (Ziebell, Zaharakis)

Cox McIntosh (Currie, Sellar)

Pavlich, Didak, Deledio, Gianceracusa, Headland, Higgins, Yarran (Ballantyne, Gumbleton)

Steven Hill in, do you rkn he'll get a lot of games? Headland in, He'll score well but injury prone, Masten and Van Berlo in, Kerr out because he's gonna get suspended, do you think it's a decent choice? Thanks BN

Hill won't get too many games imo.
Headland is risky as, but I guess he is cheap.
Masten should improve, more of a DTer though.
Van Berlo i'm looking at if Reilly doesn't play for some reason.

And yeh Kerr is too risky and will cop the number 1 tag most games.