Newton

[KTLK]

Can anyone please tell me how many VFL games have Netwon played so far this season. Also, how many goals kicked so far?

Thank you for your help

 

[master bate]

10 matches for 28 goals.

 

[melbournemartin]

Domination.

 

[KTLK]

10 matches for 28 goals.

Thanks Master Bate

Comparing to Miller - 15 AFL matches and 17 goals

 

[StingaArmstrong]

Thanks Master Bate

Comparing to Miller - 15 AFL matches and 17 goals

Newton's a Full Forward, Miller's a lead up Centre Half Forward, the goal difference is to be expected.

 

[Supermercado]

And some of the sides in the VFL are very, VERY ordinary. Compare that to the AFL where we are very, VERY ordinary.

 

[old_clint]

What we're doing here is comparing a Dutch Cream to a Sebago.

 

[Punchy Demons]

Newton - is the worst player on an AFL list.

 

[Dez!]

Newton - is the worst player on an AFL list.

I'd prefer Newton over Miller.

 

[Punchy Demons]

I'd prefer Newton over Miller.

Why is that? Is it based on Newton being younger than Miller?

Miller has at least shown he is capable of playing quality football. Although he doesn't do it regularly I would take him every day of the week.

The only thing Newton has ever done, was take a great mark that won mark of the year. Newton is a dud and is very very lazy! Lets cut our losses and get rid of him. It is worth paying out his contract just to free up a spot on our list to a player who may amount to something, because Newton never will!

 

[RandB]

If comparing Newton to Miller, the only way I could put it would be to say that at 26, Miller is at least a remote chance of a trade to another club (possibly Sydney). At 22 Newton hardly seems tradable at all. We wouldn't get much for Miller but still...

 

[Dez!]

Why is that? Is it based on Newton being younger than Miller?

Miller has at least shown he is capable of playing quality football. Although he doesn't do it regularly I would take him every day of the week.

The only thing Newton has ever done, was take a great mark that won mark of the year. Newton is a dud and is very very lazy! Lets cut our losses and get rid of him. It is worth paying out his contract just to free up a spot on our list to a player who may amount to something, because Newton never will!

You obviously haven't watched Newton this year at all, he is anything but lazy. In fact his defensive pressure inside our attacking 50 would be close to the best in the team, his marking has improved and if somebody can help fix his kicking (which can be excellent at times, just needs help to do it consistently) he would be more than a handy addition to our forward line.

Miller on the other hand has had how many years to prove his worth? Every year he has failed to do make any sort impact. Even last year in his supposed "break-out" year he wasn't much more than serviceable, trading Miller should be a top priority for us this pre-season.

 

[KTLK]

I'd prefer Newton over Miller.

Agree Dez. I would give Newton more opportunities.

Miller had his opportunities and has failed. Plus Netwon is younger than Miller.

 

[Supermercado]

Newton - is the worst player on an AFL list.

Is Tony Notte still at West Coast?

 

[FlagIn5Years]

Can anyone please tell me how many VFL games have Netwon played so far this season. Also, how many goals kicked so far?

Thank you for your help

Whatever number he plays, he should play more.

 

[Wonaeamirri33]

Newton - is the worst player on an AFL list.

What about Tom Hawkins... surely he is more impressively dire than Newton could ever be!

Is Tony Notte still at West Coast?

Yes. Tony the Toothpick is STILL there, amazingly enough...