Next Weeks Changes

[Stafford678]

Hopefully

In; Schulz, Hartigan,Hyde,Hilton,
Out- Tivendale, Graham, Knobel/Stafford, chaffey/jackson

Bit harsh on jacko but id like to think hilts would get another crack in that forward pocket role, Schulz to replace graham , and drop one of the ruckman eiether knobel (terrible disposal) or Staff (looked slow) but i think we could work better with Simmonds or Staff play a kick behind play and around the ground, they are decent kicks and can take a grab. Hyde in for Tivendale and Hartigan for chaff or jackson

Play newman on a wing, hartigan back pocket, Bowden up forward, Lids across the half back line

My Team
B:Hartigan, Gaspar,A.Kellerway
HB: Chaffey, Hall,Deledio
C:Newman,Cogs, Hyde
HF: Pettifer, Richo,Bowden
F: Krak, Simmonds, Schulz,
R: Stafford, Tuck, Johnson
Int: Campbell,Hilton,Raines,Meyer

 

[jackson_rules]

Hopefully

In; Schulz, Hartigan,Hyde,Hilton,
Out- Tivendale, Graham, Knobel/Stafford, chaffey/jackson

Bit harsh on jacko but id like to think hilts would get another crack in that forward pocket role, Schulz to replace graham , and drop one of the ruckman eiether knobel (terrible disposal) or Staff (looked slow) but i think we could work better with Simmonds or Staff play a kick behind play and around the ground, they are decent kicks and can take a grab. Hyde in for Tivendale and Hartigan for chaff or jackson

Play newman on a wing, hartigan back pocket, Bowden up forward, Lids across the half back line

My Team
B:Hartigan, Gaspar,A.Kellerway
HB: Chaffey, Hall,Deledio
C:Newman,Cogs, Hyde
HF: Pettifer, Richo,Bowden
F: Krak, Simmonds, Schulz,
R: Stafford, Tuck, Johnson
Int: Campbell,Hilton,Raines,Meyer

meyer needs to play in coburg, how has it been since he has had a majority of gametime at least with deledio he plays most of the game

 

[Stafford678]

anyway i just think that since the start of the season our triangle has crumbled, i wouldnt mind seeing simmonds ruck more and when he doesnt play the traditional full forward role and have richo out at 50, richo seems to kick more goals when he is futher out from goal..

I think what has killed us a lot this year, has been our inability to have a ruckman play in the hole in the defensive 50.. it cuts of that space for the leads of players like gehrig and thompson..and newman and bowden seem to have struggled down back this season

 

[Grechy]

At the moment Danny Meyer is way to thin to play, he needs to seriously spend some time eating and spending quality time in the gym, once he gains some muscle he will be able to display his talents a lot easier.

Tivendale manages to find the ball but has a complete lack of confidence, he kicked a goal which suprised me somewhat even though it was ******** easy. His turnovers are criminal and he can't kick for goal anymore.

Morrison needs a go and Hilton should be given another FP role.

 

[Bojangles17]

At the moment Danny Meyer is way to thin to play, he needs to seriously spend some time eating and spending quality time in the gym, once he gains some muscle he will be able to display his talents a lot easier.

.

agreed , meyer is really playing ahead of his time , with his size, is really unlikely to have an impact...certain that Hyde will come in to repalce him with some confidence in 27 possie hitout

 

[froars]

Out- Tivendale, Graham, Knobel/Stafford, chaffey/jackson

Do me a favour and have another look at Chaffey's game.
Simmonds is a waste of space at the moment and I would be giving him a kick up the arse as well as Tivendale. His kicking at goal is up there with Richo's and he's not doing much else. Jackson needs another run in the seconds. Stafford nothing - might have been better if Hilton played afterall.

 

[Stafford678]

What was our biggest mistake this year, Trading for simmonds or drafting Knobel

 

[Stafford678]

Do me a favour and have another look at Chaffey's game.
Simmonds is a waste of space at the moment and I would be giving him a kick up the arse as well as Tivendale. His kicking at goal is up there with Richo's and he's not doing much else. Jackson needs another run in the seconds. Stafford nothing - might have been better if Hilton played afterall.

i listened on the radio and saw most of the 3rd qtr but from what i saw chaffey was tagging brent harvey who i think had 30 possesions?
i dont mind chaff i just think he is being played ouf of position

 

[TigerFan]

Hopefully

In; Schulz, Hartigan,Hyde,Hilton,
Out- Tivendale, Graham, Knobel/Stafford, chaffey/jackson

Bit harsh on jacko but id like to think hilts would get another crack in that forward pocket role, Schulz to replace graham , and drop one of the ruckman eiether knobel (terrible disposal) or Staff (looked slow) but i think we could work better with Simmonds or Staff play a kick behind play and around the ground, they are decent kicks and can take a grab. Hyde in for Tivendale and Hartigan for chaff or jackson

Play newman on a wing, hartigan back pocket, Bowden up forward, Lids across the half back line

My Team
B:Hartigan, Gaspar,A.Kellerway
HB: Chaffey, Hall,Deledio
C:Newman,Cogs, Hyde
HF: Pettifer, Richo,Bowden
F: Krak, Simmonds, Schulz,
R: Stafford, Tuck, Johnson
Int: Campbell,Hilton,Raines,Meyer

I was convinced Stafford was the key in 2005, his ankle injury was rotten luck and may have finished his career.

Graham has no role in the side against Adelaide, but I highly rate Knobel as a tap ruckman. Tivendale needs to be dropped to Coburg for 2 weeks, not matter how well he does in the first week - simply so he can go out, get some kicks and play some good footy, and therefore get some confidence back.

I'm not on the Jackson bandwagon yet, I just don't see what his role is in the side at this stage, while Chaffey just seems to have lost his way.


as far as the ins are concerned, I would like to see Hyde stay at Coburg until the headgear comes off, and maybe one more game after that, just to get his confidence back. Hilton needs one more chance before we give up on him (and delist him?), Schulz needs to find his role in the team, but he might be a welcome inclusion.

as for Hartigan, he is a walk up start as far as I am concerned.

despite all this, I can't see us beating the Crows.

 

[froars]

from what i saw chaffey was tagging brent harvey who i think had 30 possesions?

If he was tagging him, he failed miserably. But the rest of his game was spot on. He hit targets and nearly every disposal was effective. After watching some of the others fumble and ******** fart around, i was pleased with his efforts.

 

[Stafford678]

the headgear was off for hide on the weekend

if you thought stafford was the key for us this year then you where a bit deluded, was allways going to be injury prone but i think hes spent 70 percent game on the pine, 20 up forward and 10 in the ruck. he kicked a few goals against the saints.. He was good to have in the sqaure when we had the triangle working but if he doesnt mark hes no good at recovering to slow around goals.. hes better off as the ruckman who eiether fills the hole in the backline and then when he needs a rest put him in the pocket

simple if you think about things, simmonds and stafford aint to bad at rucking obviusly not as good as the tap downs but i dunno it just annoys the hell out of me that we get a good build up and going through the center or the wing and then just to have knobel drop a simple mark or cough up a handball to the opisition. Stafford and Simmonds have decent skills and wouldnt cough up the ball by as stuipid mistakes as knobel does

 

[Stafford678]

If he was tagging him, he failed miserably. But the rest of his game was spot on. He hit targets and nearly every disposal was effective. After watching some of the others fumble and ******** fart around, i was pleased with his efforts.

i agree with you about chaffeys disposal, he doesnt turn it over as much as people are led to believe.. but he just cant go with the good midfielders, i would have thought he could have been probably the better match up for Corey Jones or Leigh Harding

 

[sante]

IN: Hartigan, Hyde, Pattison/Schulz
OUT: Knobel, Tivendale, Graham