Over 27 year old best 22 VS Under 27 year old best 22

[Blue and Silver]

This idea emerged in the Best 22 over 30 thread and I decided to run with it.

Basically the question is do more experienced bodies play better than younger ones?

What I have tried to do is work off of two seasons worth of form and construct these sides around complimentary attributes (ie: not loading the forward line with power forwards)

Over 27

B: Graham Johncock (27), Matthew Scarlett (30), Corey Enright (28)
HB: Simon Goodwin (33), Brian Lake (27), Sam Fisher (27)
C: Adam Goodes (30), Joel Corey (28), Chance Batemen (28)
HF: Paul Chapman (28), Nick Reidwoldt (27) Jonathon Brown (28)
F: Brent Harvey (31) Brendan Fevola (29) Alan Didak (27)
R: Dean Cox (28) Simon Black (30) Lenny Hayes (30)
I/C: Aaron Sandilands (27), Matthew Pavlich (28), Ryan O'Keefe(29), Matthew Boyd (27)

Under 27

B:Nick Maxwell (26) Daniel Merrett (25) Sam Gilbert (23)
HB: Luke Hodge (25) Nathan Bock (26) Josh Drummond (26)
C: Jimmy Bartel (26) Joel Selwood (21) Dane Swan (25)
HF: Shaun Higgins (22), Lance Franklin (23) Brendan Goddard (24)
F:Cyril Rioli (20) Jarryd Roughead (23) Mark Le Cras (24)
R: Hamish McIntosh (26) Chris Judd (26) Gary Ablett (26)
I/C: Mitch Clark (22) Marc Murphy (22) Jobe Watson (25) Andrew Mackie (25)

 

[al ain pie]

[YOUTUBE]CGEnKh0ocb0[/YOUTUBE]

 

[hellfire]

Over 27s would win.

 

[The Zebra]

Winners in red.


F:Cyril Rioli (20) Jarryd Roughead (23) Mark Le Cras (24)
B: Graham Johncock (27), Matthew Scarlett (30), Corey Enright (28)

HF: Shaun Higgins (22), Lance Franklin (23) Brendan Goddard (24)
HB: Simon Goodwin (33), Brian Lake (27), Sam Fisher (27)

C: Jimmy Bartel (26) Joel Selwood (21) Dane Swan (25)
C: Adam Goodes (30), Joel Corey (28), Chance Batemen (28)

HB: Luke Hodge (25) Nathan Bock (26) Josh Drummond (26)
HF: Paul Chapman (28), Nick Reidwoldt (27) Jonathon Brown (28)

B:Nick Maxwell (26) Daniel Merrett (25) Sam Gilbert (23)
F: Brent Harvey (31) Brendan Fevola (29) Alan Didak (27)

R: Hamish McIntosh (26) Chris Judd (26) Gary Ablett (26)
R: Dean Cox (28) Simon Black (30) Lenny Hayes (30)


I/C: Mitch Clark (22) Marc Murphy (22) Jobe Watson (25) Andrew Mackie (25)
I/C: Aaron Sandilands (27), Matthew Pavlich (28), Ryan O'Keefe(29), Matthew Boyd (27)




9-13

Bench kills the under 27 team.

I don't think Johncock, Bateman, Maxwell, Murphy, Watson or Mackie should be in the team

 

[peternorth]

if player turns 27 this year which team is he in?

 

[madhawkboy]

Sam Mitchell?