overrated/underrated?

[dee-molishon]

Just a topic for discussion guys who do u guys think is completely under rated?? and who do u think is completely overrated??
Doesnt have to be with the melbourne list just the afl in general.

Ill start off with some controversy:

I see a lot of geelong and i will tell you someone i have been keeping a very close eye on, now u know i think blake is a dud but most of my geelong supporting mates do too but the biggest and most over rated player by everyone who follows geelong and doesnt follow geelong is JAMES KELLY totally and utterly over rated, i used to think he was good but next time u can have a look at him closely for a game, he is a hang out, misses goals weather it be set shot or on the run, gets alot of easy possies from ablett, bartel and chappy.....hes a one of those players that if he was in a crap team he would do nothing.

Under rated but maybe not overly under rated anymore because of the brownlow is dane swan. My g/f is a collingwood supporter so i have to watch heaps of them unfortunatley and i tell you swan is a ball magnetic. Most of u guys probaley know he gets a heap of stats but i used to think he gets the easy ones only till i watched him this year, he gets clearances and hard ball gets heaps, have a look at the semi against west coast in the 3rd and last quater i think he nearly won every centre clearance himself. I also love brent reilly from adelaide, reminds me of brent moloney but not injured lol

 

[dee-stroyers]

Just a topic for discussion guys who do u guys think is completely under rated?? and who do u think is completely overrated??
Doesnt have to be with the melbourne list just the afl in general.

Ill start off with some controversy:

I see a lot of geelong and i will tell you someone i have been keeping a very close eye on, now u know i think blake is a dud but most of my geelong supporting mates do too but the biggest and most over rated player by everyone who follows geelong and doesnt follow geelong is JAMES KELLY totally and utterly over rated, i used to think he was good but next time u can have a look at him closely for a game, he is a hang out, misses goals weather it be set shot or on the run, gets alot of easy possies from ablett, bartel and chappy.....hes a one of those players that if he was in a crap team he would do nothing.

Under rated but maybe not overly under rated anymore because of the brownlow is dane swan. My g/f is a collingwood supporter so i have to watch heaps of them unfortunatley and i tell you swan is a ball magnetic. Most of u guys probaley know he gets a heap of stats but i used to think he gets the easy ones only till i watched him this year, he gets clearances and hard ball gets heaps, have a look at the semi against west coast in the 3rd and last quater i think he nearly won every centre clearance himself. I also love brent reilly from adelaide, reminds me of brent moloney but not injured lol

I think one from melbourne and the AFL for that matter is Matthew Whelan.Superstar.another one is Nick Maxwell from collingwood.

 

[dee-molishon]

good call dee-stroyer i love the way maxwell plays......can unashamably say i do loike watching collingwood play since i have been with my g/f they play with alot of heart......love harry o'brien and marty clarke too

 

[saj_21]

Just a topic for discussion guys who do u guys think is completely under rated?? and who do u think is completely overrated??
Doesnt have to be with the melbourne list just the afl in general.

Ill start off with some controversy:

I see a lot of geelong and i will tell you someone i have been keeping a very close eye on, now u know i think blake is a dud but most of my geelong supporting mates do too but the biggest and most over rated player by everyone who follows geelong and doesnt follow geelong is JAMES KELLY totally and utterly over rated, i used to think he was good but next time u can have a look at him closely for a game, he is a hang out, misses goals weather it be set shot or on the run, gets alot of easy possies from ablett, bartel and chappy.....hes a one of those players that if he was in a crap team he would do nothing.

Under rated but maybe not overly under rated anymore because of the brownlow is dane swan. My g/f is a collingwood supporter so i have to watch heaps of them unfortunatley and i tell you swan is a ball magnetic. Most of u guys probaley know he gets a heap of stats but i used to think he gets the easy ones only till i watched him this year, he gets clearances and hard ball gets heaps, have a look at the semi against west coast in the 3rd and last quater i think he nearly won every centre clearance himself. I also love brent reilly from adelaide, reminds me of brent moloney but not injured lol

Swan is a gun the borwnlow votes showed that.
Over rated wud be paddy rdyer, does nothin at all. It took the bloke last yr 3 games to get his first touch in afl footy