Pick 2 Update...

[richskee]

Sounds good but Adelaide wouldn't go for it, as much as they'd love Trengove they'd love to keep Tippett even more.

I mean if they agreed to it though, I'd definitely support it.

Yeah know what you mean, but if the rumours are true about GC this could be AFC's last chance to get what they want.

We should make a play for him IMO.

 

[00Stinger]

Also forgot Aaron Black, there's a lot more safer options in KPF's than Butcher that we could get at pick 18.

Panos, Talia, Carlisle, Griffiths, Black and Fitzpatrick.

We are pretty much guaranteed one of them, any one of the first 5 will do me and only select Fitzpatrick if the other 5 are gone.

Fitzpatrick no, no, no.
He does nothing, he is only rated because he is an athletic tall man.
I would rather look at trading pick 18 and 34 for a KPF who has been in the system for a few years

 

[Andy_Mac]

it's been said before hundreds of times on this forum before. Tippet is worth more than just pick 2

You'd almost have to say P1 & P18 for Tippett and their 2nd round... He is very F*ing good. If in doubt refer his almost match winning goal from the weekend.

 

[Dez!]

Fitzpatrick no, no, no.
He does nothing, he is only rated because he is an athletic tall man.
I would rather look at trading pick 18 and 34 for a KPF who has been in the system for a few years

He's not as utterly useless as you make him out to be but he is the biggest risk out of the six potential KPF's we can get. He could potentially be the best out of those potential KPF's and I think we should select him if the others have been selected.

Those picks won't hold much water in this draft which is why I'd prefer we stay out of trade week.

 

[00Stinger]

He's not as utterly useless as you make him out to be but he is the biggest risk out of the six potential KPF's we can get. He could potentially be the best out of those potential KPF's and I think we should select him if the others have been selected.

Those picks won't hold much water in this draft which is why I'd prefer we stay out of trade week.

I've seen him play 3 times now and everytime he have looked less than average

 

[Batemania]

I'd happily trade pick 2 for Tippett, that way Adelaide would get there boy Trengove and we would get a gun forward.

thoughts?

Would never happen. More likely get S. Burgouyne for pick 34 and d. bell lmao

I would say melb will go for talls with remaining draft picks after 1-2 similar to the draft we we drafter 3 talls Bate, Dunn(was a tall) and Newton.

 

[Demon 16]

Griffiths was the one I forgot, so it's almost certain we will have a KPF available for us at pick 18.

I think we'll only be interested if Butcher, Talia, Panos or Carlisle are around - Griffiths and Fitzpatrick arent good enough to go ahead of the midfielders that will be left - even considering our positional needs. If you throw ruckman Vardy in as well, I would be surprised if 1 of them doesnt fall through. But if 1 of these 5 doesnt make it to us, we'll take another midfielder for sure.

This is where Butcher should be drafted at Pick 2

Ok he had an average carnival and injuries excuses etc.. but you cant have an average 12 months and expect to go at 2 - expecially with elite guns like Morabito, Martin and Trengove around. Im tipping he slides right down to pick 7 or later.