Player X vs Player Y vs Player Z

Remove this Banner Ad

2006_Eagles said:
Oliver could literally be anything and is cheaper. Menzel coming off 4 knees, surely he'll be managed at times this year.

Graham has the form and continuity and actually went at about 1ppm last year. Libba probably won't come into his own until about mid year.
Click to expand...

Cheers pal i was leaning towards that !
 

Log in to remove this ad.

CrozaN said:
+1

Lonergan and Sheridan are well ahead of Seedsman IMO.
Click to expand...

Why well ahead?

Seedsman has a huge ceiling when he gets his s**t together (130 last year) and laid 7 tackles on the weekend. Looks like he'll own a wing at Adelaide and continuity is a great thing.

Sheridan has only tonned once in his career.

Leaning towards JLo and Seedo at this stage.
 
2006_Eagles said:
Why well ahead?

Seedsman has a huge ceiling when he gets his s**t together (130 last year) and laid 7 tackles on the weekend. Looks like he'll own a wing at Adelaide and continuity is a great thing.

Sheridan has only tonned once in his career.

Leaning towards JLo and Seedo at this stage.
Click to expand...

Seedsman too many unkowns, will be a rollercoaster IMO. Should average around 75-80.

Sheridan had a big finish to the year last year and looks set to have taken over Duffields role and is linking up alot in the midfield this pre-season too. Can see him averaging 80-85.

Lonergan is set to take over Swallow's role in the midfield and even though he has only had limited game time this NAB his ppm is HUGE! Can see him averaging 80-90 while in Swallow's role.
 
CrozaN said:
Seedsman too many unkowns, will be a rollercoaster IMO. Should average around 75-80.

Sheridan had a big finish to the year last year and looks set to have taken over Duffields role and is linking up alot in the midfield this pre-season too. Can see him averaging 80-85.

Lonergan is set to take over Swallow's role in the midfield and even though he has only had limited game time this NAB his ppm is HUGE! Can see him averaging 80-90 while in Swallow's role.
Click to expand...

Fair enough points, what are the Seedsman unknowns you're talking about tho?
 
Seedsman has a previous average of 79 (82 non sub affected) and will be playing half back/wing for a team that loves to spread the ball around the half back line. He'll be racking up plus 6's galore. In my team. Lonergan and Sheridan have never averaged above mid 60's.

I can see the appeal of Lonergan since he'll be moving into a midfield role, but I think he'd be better suited to Supercoach than Dream Team, he doesn't have much of an outside game. Sheridan I don't get the hype at all. He's just an average player who had a decent NAB cup.
 
Schulzenfest said:
Seedsman has a previous average of 79 (82 non sub affected) and will be playing half back/wing for a team that loves to spread the ball around the half back line. He'll be racking up plus 6's galore. In my team. Lonergan and Sheridan have never averaged above mid 60's.

I can see the appeal of Lonergan since he'll be moving into a midfield role, but I think he'd be better suited to Supercoach than Dream Team, he doesn't have much of an outside game. Sheridan I don't get the hype at all. He's just an average player who had a decent NAB cup.
Click to expand...

Sherro had a very good finish to 2015 and is 22yo now - best footy ahead of him. Not just NAB hype.

Agree about Seedsman, disagree with JLo - scoring at 1.33ppm this pre season indicating he'll be a fine DT player.
 
Last edited:
Howard Moon said:
neither are ideal though hey....

how bout currie v grimley v cox v michel for r3
Click to expand...

Well i like menzel ive had him for ages just cant fit him now bkos i need more $ and r3 ruck ive gone with the cheapest player on there to save some $ aswell never gonna use the player anyway
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Monty OR Dusty (changed to monty atm im worried now with this stuff with dusts dad maybe some suspensions coming his way maybe or may be distracted ?)

Steven OR Jesus (i have steven now at least i have faith in his body but on the other hand gaj is a DT god)
 
Slippers said:
Monty OR Dusty (changed to monty atm im worried now with this stuff with dusts dad maybe some suspensions coming his way maybe or may be distracted ?)

Steven OR Jesus (i have steven now at least i have faith in his body but on the other hand gaj is a DT god)
Click to expand...

Dusty

GAJ
 
Howe v Weitering (now Hill is out for 6 weeks)
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top