please discuss further

[thanks_juddy]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , pick 5 , bentick fletcher
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 , tambling

wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 fletcher
get : pick 2,3,4 + 19 ray

carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13

melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + tambling + scotland

Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18


please change to what is best
this is suggestion

 

[R.I.P Jack Dyer]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , pick 5 , bentick + 36
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 , tambling

wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 36
get : pick 2,3,4 + 19 ray

carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13

melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + tambling + scotland

Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18


please change to what is best
this is suggestion

waste of time...move on troll

 

[thanks_juddy]

what else then tell me

 

[thanks_juddy]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , pick 5 , bentick fletcher
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 , tambling
wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 fletcher
get : pick 2,3,4 + 19 ray
carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13
melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + tambling + scotland
Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18

is that better

 

[NQTIGER]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , pick 5 , bentick fletcher
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 , tambling
wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 fletcher
get : pick 2,3,4 + 19 ray
carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13
melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + tambling + scotland
Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18





is that better

Why the **** would we need to get involved to improve yor picks idiot!!!!!!

deal with the bluebaggers

 

[Ah Cheung]

Terrible trade.
The tiges are going to give up their first 3 picks and tambling to help compensate the eagles and get judd to carlton?
U work out with the scum.....

 

[DDTiger]

If i was a Carlton and had integrity (OK stop laughing, just pretend)

I would offer 1,3, and Murphy to the WCE

 

[beaver fever]

This has to be the most ******ed and impossible trade I've ever read.

 

[TimeFor11]

Agree that trade is ****ed up. Basically everything we lose is better than what we get. You a dh thanks juddy

 

[Harvey Leadpipe]

This has to be the most ******ed and impossible trade I've ever read.

Agreed. Looks like some youngster has been getting stuck into the chrome spray suring school hols.

Someone delete this and ban the starter of the thread from BF.

 

[rado]

this is the most stupidest thing i have ever seen
plus where the hell does tuck go??

 

[RichosGuns]

We get killed in that situation. We effectivly loose 5 top 25 draft picks + Tuck for 2 kids that havnt showed much and spuds McMahoan and Bentick + 35....

....tell him he's dreaming

 

[diligaf]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , pick 5 , bentick fletcher
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 , tambling

wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 fletcher
get : pick 2,3,4 + 19 ray

carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13

melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + tambling + scotland

Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18


please change to what is best
this is suggestion

No need to discuss.......this is utter crap!

 

[I'm the Juggernaut]

mckinley , mcmahon , bentick, fletcher


who who who and who?

 

[PUNTROADHAMMER]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , pick 5 , bentick fletcher
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 , tambling

wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 fletcher
get : pick 2,3,4 + 19 ray

carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13

melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + tambling + scotland

Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18


please change to what is best
this is suggestion

Either increase or change your medication altogether....

 

[jack_riewoldt_rulz]

Waste of time

 

[jack_riewoldt_rulz]

We Lose 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 , tambling
and get mckinley , mcmahon , pick 5 , bentick fletcher
WASTE OF TIME

 

[Rayzorwire]

Lmao

 

[Bulldog89]

richmond
get : mckinley , mcmahon , pick 5 , bentick fletcher
lose : pick 2 tuck hughes 18 + 19 , tambling

wce
lose : judd morton mckinley spangher 13 fletcher
get : pick 2,3,4 + 19 ray

carlton
lose : pick 3 kennedy bentick scotland
get judd + morton + frawley + sylvia 13

melbourne
lose : pick 4 frawley rivers syliva moloney
get : wb 2nd round + Hughes + tambling + scotland

Bulldogs
lose : pick 5 ray macmahon 2nd round
get : moloney , spangher , kennedy , rivers + 18


please change to what is best
this is suggestion

U ON DRUGS?

 

[Tetley Tigers]

Bottom line - WCE will have to take what they can get from Carlton. What's the next best option? Collingwood? What have they got? Pick 14 and a player.

All this talk about WCE wanting 1,3 and 20 just won't happen.

Carlton will play hardball in the knowledge that they are the only ones at the trade table with anything worthwhile.

If I was Carlton I'd offer pick 3 and a player - take it or lose Judd to the PSD.

 

[Tambo]

It the school hols, lets whack the biggest trade scenario together and see how it works.... lmao

It's painfull having the school hols and trade period at the same time

 

[David3030]

Based on that trade scenario ...everyone wins but us ... we would be the club requiring greatest compensation as we would be giving up the most