porter

[gingerthedog]

i think we should go for porter. he was fantastic at carlton and hasnt got many opportunities at nth what do u think

 

[Presti_is_god]

No,

There are better ruckmen out there to aim for like Cox or Charman.

In my opinion we would be fools to get a quick fix like Porter who would not be a consistently good ruckman for us when Cox or Charman would.

And with the retirement of Spider Burton i'm sure he will get more oppurtunites at the Roos.

 

[Joel]

To put it simply, NO!

 

[Nic]

Huh. Not likely. Maybe three or four years ago (or the start of his career - which could have happened).

 

[guess_who]

Umm let me put it this way, while I respect everyone's opinion, NO

 

[rychenroller]

Rather play Leon in the ruck than Porter.