Positives

[jerry springer]

4 points

Rus looked good

Pendles has a bit of aggro about him that I like

Bryan played well in spots

Medders 2 good games in a week

Guy had his shirt ripped so we saw his masculine body

did I say 4 points?

 

[jerry springer]

and chuck in no injuries and we have an extra day off on Sydney for next week,lets hope brisbane runs them ragged tommorow night

 

[DJ Black @ White Blood]

4 points

Rus looked good

Pendles has a bit of aggro about him that I like

Bryan played well in spots

Medders 2 good games in a week

Guy had his shirt ripped so we saw his masculine body

did I say 4 points?

Negatives

Pendles made a mistake first for the year, ran too far

Jumpers are oviously not strong enough

I missed Tooveys skill and ball handeling

Every Karate kick deserves a goal

Why does neon play a blinda of 10 minutes then goes missing

 

[jbuch9]

burns and medhurst played well

 

[jerry springer]

Negatives

-ray chamberlain,i have never got into the whole "ray' shit until tonight, he was terrible.

the commentaters.gee they hate us.

 

[Ron]

Bryan actually looked like a ruckman, i was shocked.
Medders is becoming important for us i reckon.
Rusling a quiet return for the most part, but an important one.

Most importantly we play a team next week which i reckon we could beat if we played Toovey by himself in the middle.

 

[Pie Fight]

Negatives

-ray chamberlain,i have never got into the whole "ray' shit until tonight, he was terrible.

the commentaters.gee they hate us.

If all Collingwood supporters get togethter and sign a peteion that Ray Chamberlain never umpires a Collingwood game again, will that gain any weight. I'm hoping it will like the Comic Book Guy during his teenage years.

 

[sloth6]

Positives - First Half.

They were bloody tough!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and had a cracki

Second Half - Never seen so many soft, insipid efforts EVER!

 

[Bloben]

A game of two halves.

Firstly... what an effort from some of our most patronised players, Medurst, Bryan and Richards... well played from all accounts.

However... why couldn't the pies take the game away from Melbourne on the 50 + occasions which was presented to the players... why just mess around with it so much. I thought that the pies would come into this game with a different mental attitude and use tonight to make a statement. At quarter time I was confident I was right... later we seemded to let the others catch up

 

[mdc]

Negatives

Pendles made a mistake first for the year, ran too far

Jumpers are oviously not strong enough

I missed Tooveys skill and ball handeling

Every Karate kick deserves a goal

Why does neon play a blinda of 10 minutes then goes missing

A couple of those cracked me up. Love your work

 

[twoforjoy]

wakes back in
medders finding a bit of touch
rocca's efforts at the ball looked better
rus looked good
we tried a slightly different structure
leons burst (lets face it he is a burst player no more no less!)
we got some flow back in our game
richards and bryan were not flogged
josh got a rest

most of all WE WON!

 

[bradrowe#32]

Happy with Rus coming back in. He just adds a little bit of something we don't have. He had some good moments, so hopefully he can build.

Good to see Pendles back in there. The boy has a bit of prick in him!

Bryan and Richards didn't disgrace themselves either.

Medhurst was good.

Heater and Harry O got a bit of form back.

 

[Frederlick]

The positives were that it took Melbourne 2 1/2 quarters to work out what was a simple but effective game plan, bomb it long to the big men and then watch the little men clean up, Medhurst played his part to perfection, and Rusling even chipped in with a goal. Thank God they actually changed the game plan to suit the oppo for once, now if they could only do that against Footscray as well.

Leon Davis has the worst delivery of a midfielder in the Magpies team and should be hit with a cattle prod if he ever goes any further up field than inside 50. Have watched his diabolical delivery in the centre corridor for the last 3 weeks, stick to kicking goals Leon.

 

[Rocket23]

Negatives

Pendles made a mistake first for the year, ran too far

Jumpers are oviously not strong enough

I missed Tooveys skill and ball handeling

Every Karate kick deserves a goal

Why does neon play a blinda of 10 minutes then goes missing

gold

 

[Medstar]

I cant think of to many positives as we really should of won by about 10 goals.

 

[Pie eyed]

I though our much maligned second and third rucks played very well tonight.

Medders was imrpessive without being outstanding.

Lean pulled another one out of his bottom.

Maxwell played a solid defensive game.

Clement seems to have regained his match fitness.

Pendles is back...and played well.

Both the Shaws attacked the ball well, backed their judgement and ran the ball.

O'Brien was solid.

Bryan played fairly well and is starting to get his feet...did not look a bit behind the pace as he has earlier...was right up with the big boys.

Burnsie was Burnsie.

Rocca did not score but was very effective at breaking up the packs and allowing Rusling some space.

Johnson played well out of the centre but will probably get 4 weeks.\

Got 4 points.



Next week a great champion of the game may be avauilable for selection....I hopes
Negatives.

Ray Chamberlain reportedly got out of the ground safely again.