- Joined
- Mar 28, 2023
- Posts
- 28,195
- Reaction score
- 54,767
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Melbourne Stars
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

BigFooty Tipping Notice Img
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 9
The Golden Ticket - Corporate tickets, functions, Open Air Boxes at the Adelaide Oval, ENGIE, Gabba, MCG, Marvel, Optus & People First Stadiums. Corporate Suites at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
I don’t necessarily think Macrae is a dud and he is criticised a lot on here. Think he’ll have a bright future at West Coast.Unfortunately Macrae didn’t have the inside game of Adams to make up for it.
It takes a team effort to win a flag. Competition for spots. High standards. Youth ready to play when needed. Old dogs only improving and looking more dangerous.“ regulars” Is a loose term and always in a state of flux. This year it’s not the regulars we need but an orderly transition away from over reliance on them
We need Buller not McStay
We need McInnes not Howe
We need to not overly rely on Pendles and Sidey
Etc etc
Definitely need Moore and Jordy to stay fit
And we definitely need to see great moves forward from the young players you mentioned plus one or two others.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
I think you’re underselling him there. He showed at Brisbane that he was capable pushing up the ground in more of a linking role rather than as deep forward where we’ve been using him, and he’s generally a very good set shot too.Nature of the beast. McStay is a really strong contested mark, but not much else. So he's not going to get the easy kicks that balance his output. He has to be clunking them and no one does that every week.
I thought it was one of those jokeA bit squicky for me seeing so many veins popping out of arms; but clearly the strength sessions are working. Excited for the season ahead.
Surely we don’t have all of Houston, Pendlebury and Josh in the backline at the same time?Now I think about and watching some footage from yesterday and then rewatching the freo game, I think the only time we'll see Josh rotate through the middle is if Nick goes to half back. There would need to be some rotations with Pendles down back.
Maybe it's not such short memories but rather a feeling the guy doesn't have the physical resilience to contribute to a full season, along with memories of the poor performances in his final games that led to him being dropped. He is currently injured and on the sidelines which is not inspiring confidence in his body. He has proved he can produce decent football, as in the 2022 final's game for Brisbane where he was thrown early into the first ruck role. Didn't do a lot in the ruck but got over 20 possessions from memory.I think you’re underselling him there. He showed at Brisbane that he was capable pushing up the ground in more of a linking role rather than as deep forward where we’ve been using him, and he’s generally a very good set shot too.
Nobody can deny he had a poor season in 2025 but it feels like there’s a lot of short memories here right now.
Not much to say right now.To all the track watchers.. haven't seen much mentioned about HDM, TJ, Ryan at training.
Any improvements? Or same old, same old?
Perhaps they're hoping HDM can improve/work on his disposal delivery training at hf?Not much to say right now.
Harry playing in a tough position at half forward, which I don't think is gonna help him.
TJ and Ryan has shown some signs, but training hard to stand out when you play in defence.
Probably his cards are marked. Swadling and Prindable gone past him alreadyPossibly. Lets hope so. But moving him around the last 12 months.
Half back. Wing. Mid and now HF.
As if they're going to write a kid off when they have two years left on their contract. they'll be trying to develop him into an AFL player.Probably his cards are marked. Swadling and Prindable gone past him already
Playing his contract out at half forward
He’s had a wretched run in recent years but was considered very physically resilient whilst at Brisbane.Maybe it's not such short memories but rather a feeling the guy doesn't have the physical resilience to contribute to a full season, along with memories of the poor performances in his final games that led to him being dropped. He is currently injured and on the sidelines which is not inspiring confidence in his body. He has proved he can produce decent football, as in the 2022 final's game for Brisbane where he was thrown early into the first ruck role. Didn't do a lot in the ruck but got over 20 possessions from memory.
I have been criticised in the past for my HDM bashing but if he’s been demoted to half-forward, that’s not a good sign. He’s a last choice option for the role. Not known for his goal scoring ability. But he has two more years left on his deal so it’s on him to be ready.Not much to say right now.
Harry playing in a tough position at half forward, which I don't think is gonna help him.
TJ and Ryan has shown some signs, but training hard to stand out when you play in defence.
Clearly he needs to get fit. Clearly he needs to then get his confidences up. Clearly we require him to be in good nick at CHF. Elliot, Schultz, De Goey and Co go half reasonable.Maybe it's not such short memories but rather a feeling the guy doesn't have the physical resilience to contribute to a full season, along with memories of the poor performances in his final games that led to him being dropped. He is currently injured and on the sidelines which is not inspiring confidence in his body. He has proved he can produce decent football, as in the 2022 final's game for Brisbane where he was thrown early into the first ruck role. Didn't do a lot in the ruck but got over 20 possessions from memory.
Tbh, he was in the wrong team to rack up stats in the midfield. Opposed to Cameron, Nick and Josh, he rarely had access to first possession, plus Cameron marking around the ground. Whilst the Daicos boys dominated the black teams midfield.Love the update Sea fog!
Maybe I’m naive but as long as Jordy is fit and healthy throughout this entire preseason, I don’t care if he’s going through match play in 3rd gear.
I would have to agree I’m afraid. Ryan has not progressed much from year 1 at all. Whilst HDM just looks v VFL in physical attributes, running power and skill level. Allan is the other that worries me. Long is just as quick as him in the running drills, which might tell you something. And he just doesn’t appear to have the football nous or mental application to impact. Hope I’m wrong, but all three names wouldnt have helped Derek’s exit interview imo - along with the disaster that was the Finn/ollie/poulter/reef/mcmahon draft.I have been criticised in the past for my HDM bashing but if he’s been demoted to half-forward, that’s not a good sign. He’s a last choice option for the role. Not known for his goal scoring ability. But he has two more years left on his deal so it’s on him to be ready.
I wouldn’t expect TJ to feature much but it’s promising he’s added size. He has some way to develop.
Ryan will likely be delisted at the end of the season. He’d need an exceptional year to earn a new deal. The gold standard in AFL recruiting is you have four years to be a regular (with exceptions to rucks, high draft picks, injuries and off-field conduct).
I don’t necessarily think Macrae is a dud and he is criticised a lot on here. Think he’ll have a bright future at West Coast.
If he’s lucky he can be Lachie Sullivan.Good luck to him at West Coast, he’s got an opportunity to cement himself at AFL level there. It won’t change my analysis of his time at Collingwood though.
We really needed just one of Macrae, Allan or HDM to come on. We’d be in a much better spot if they had. Taking 3 mids in the off season (one their age group) is pretty telling for the latter twoI would have to agree I’m afraid. Ryan has not progressed much from year 1 at all. Whilst HDM just looks v VFL in physical attributes, running power and skill level. Allan is the other that worries me. Long is just as quick as him in the running drills, which might tell you something. And he just doesn’t appear to have the football nous or mental application to impact. Hope I’m wrong, but all three names wouldnt have helped Derek’s exit interview imo - along with the disaster that was the Finn/ollie/poulter/reef/mcmahon draft.
Agreed. We need big men doing things that big men do best. I am Bullish on Buller, as his name insinuates we all should be. My Sydney mate liked him and is disappointed to lose him. He is not a supporter inclined to speak highly of the team's tall forwards, so Buller must have shown something last year.Clearly he needs to get fit. Clearly he needs to then get his confidences up. Clearly we require him to be in good nick at CHF. Elliot, Schultz, De Goey and Co go half reasonable.
Moore and McStay, up and about, make us a lot better. Big mobile blokes, strong overhead, is what we need. Their understudies are still a work in progress.