Preview Changes and pre match discussion vs Adelaide

[Flawed Genius]

Hardeman for Mcdonald

 

[archereleven]

I'd like to say bring in a young kpd, but they all play forward in the vfl or ruck in the 1s apparently.

Rawling couldn't build a shopping list.

 

[MrWeasel]

Hardeman is an upgrade on LMAC and seems ready to come in. Could Harvey come in and play Daniel's role with more speed, penetration and height?

 

[Chadwiko]

"Preview"?

Is this the changes thread?

 

[JGreezy]

Id like to see Hardeman and Harvey in for Lmac and Daniel, but seems unlikely

 

[BigRedRoo]

Based on what I saw today we should beat the Crows next week.

 

[shintemaster]

Id like to see Hardeman and Harvey in for Lmac and Daniel, but seems unlikely

Would love to see both in. Be nice to have a couple of players in the backline that can dispose of the ball with some threat.

 

[Roos92]

Another honourable loss imo

 

[Passmore]

Doubt there's any.

 

[Chadwiko]

OUT: McDonald, Logue
IN: Hardeman, Pink

I'm also cautious of the fact that the Crows have a much taller/more traditional key forward setup than the Swans do.

We dropped Corr and brought in Dawson this week but didn't play Dawson as a KPD. Meaning our only tall KPDs for most of today were Logue and Comben. We can't do that against Adelaide so either Dawson gets significantly more KPD minutes, or we might be forced into bringing one of Pink/Corr back into the side without dropping an equivalent player from today's team.

 

[shintemaster]

OUT: McDonald, Logue
IN: Hardeman, Pink

I'm also cautious of the fact that the Crows have a much taller/more traditional key forward setup than the Swans do.

We dropped Corr and brought in Dawson this week but didn't play Dawson as a KPD. Meaning our only tall KPDs for most of today were Logue and Comben. We can't do that against Adelaide so either Dawson gets significantly more KPD minutes, or we might be forced into bringing one of Pink/Corr back into the side without dropping an equivalent player from today's team.

Nah. I'm okay with your changes. Pink more accountable. Hardeman provides run, attack and dash. I'd be looking seriously at Harvey too and don't care much who makes way.

 

[Moti]

Here are my the changes I would make if I was in charge:

In: Hardeman Out: Mc Donald
In: Harvey Out: Larkey (Zurhaar moves forward and we play a more mobile lineup.

Probably only see the first happening.

 

[archereleven]

Here are my the changes I would make if I was in charge:

In: Hardeman Out: Mc Donald
In: Harvey Out: Larkey (Zurhaar moves forward and we play a more mobile lineup.

Probably only see the first happening.

You will see neither of them changes lol

 

[Moti]

You will see neither of them changes lol

 

[the big lebowski]

OUT: McDonald, Logue
IN: Hardeman, Pink

I'm also cautious of the fact that the Crows have a much taller/more traditional key forward setup than the Swans do.

We dropped Corr and brought in Dawson this week but didn't play Dawson as a KPD. Meaning our only tall KPDs for most of today were Logue and Comben. We can't do that against Adelaide so either Dawson gets significantly more KPD minutes, or we might be forced into bringing one of Pink/Corr back into the side without dropping an equivalent player from today's team.

No Tex. thilthorpe struggling with a back, and Fogarty first game back this week with a back issue

 

[Chadwiko]

No Tex. thilthorpe struggling with a back, and Fogarty first game back this week with a back issue

Stop disrespecting the GREAT Finnbar Maley.

 

[Moti]

Trembaths last quarter might have saved him. Been extremely poor the past three weeks and if we want to set standards ...

 

[shintemaster]

Trembaths last quarter might have saved him. Been extremely poor the past three weeks and if we want to set standards ...

Has been struggling. I think they need to rejig a bit as too much congestion forward.

 

[BigRedRoo]

Trembaths last quarter might have saved him. Been extremely poor the past three weeks and if we want to set standards ...

The problem is we have 4 forwards sometimes 5 all flying for the ball at the same time in a massive pack, that no one can take a grab. We need to sort this out and quickly.

 

[Chadwiko]

Has been struggling. I think they need to rejig a bit as too much congestion forward.

The first few weeks, Larkey looked happy to play second fiddle to Trembath and the forward structure worked accordingly.

The last few weeks, Larkey is playing selfish football and flying for balls that Trembath has a better position for.

I genuinely wonder if Larkeys ego got hurt by all the attention Trembath got.

 

[shintemaster]

The first few weeks, Larkey looked happy to play second fiddle to Trembath and the forward structure worked accordingly.

The last few weeks, Larkey is playing selfish football and flying for balls that Trembath has a better position for.

I genuinely wonder if Larkeys ego got hurt by all the attention Trembath got.

I'd be lying if I said the thought hadn't crossed my mind. Larkey arguably needs to be playing more of a decoy game. He is a smart player, so has no excuses not to compete and work over opponents on the lead.

 

[archereleven]

The first few weeks, Larkey looked happy to play second fiddle to Trembath and the forward structure worked accordingly.

The last few weeks, Larkey is playing selfish football and flying for balls that Trembath has a better position for.

I genuinely wonder if Larkeys ego got hurt by all the attention Trembath got.

It was only all about everyone else playing a role while Souv played for free kicks. That is literally his role at present.

 

[Hatchy1992]

Everyone calling for Lmac to be dropped don't see the lockdown job he does on his opponent. Rosas from 7 goals last week to 0 goals and 7 disposals this week.

He plays his role and does it well.

 

[the big lebowski]

Everyone calling for Lmac to be dropped don't see the lockdown job he does on his opponent. Rosas from 7 goals last week to 0 goals and 7 disposals this week.

He plays his role and does it well.

Facts

 

[Possession]

Hardeman needs to come in somehow.