Rating the rooks

[fronkalicious]

Ok, balls on the line. Rate the kids 1 through 6 (including cordy). Rating criteria can be your own (most career games or just "best player").

 

[King Harold]

Cordy
Webb
McLean
Daniel
Hamilton
Dale

 

[100action]

Boyd
dale
cord
Daniels
Webb
McLean
hamilton

 

[Pannalstaroz]

Daniel
Cordy
Webb
McLean
T. He. Others

 

[maddog37]

Daniels
McLean
Cordy
Webb
Dale
Hamilton

 

[doggies ftw]

Gee pretty tough, could go either way to be honest.

Webb
McLean
Cordy
Daniel
Dale/Hamilton - think these two could probably quite easily be the best but don't know enough about them so have them down the bottom.

 

[JJHunter]

Cordy
Webb
McLean
Daniel
Hamilton
Dale

This

 

[BEaston]

McLean
Daniel
Cordy
Dale
Webb
Hamilton

 

[dogzrule]

Daniel - 150 + games
Cordy - 100+ games
McLean - 100
Webb - 50 games
Hamilton - 35 games
Dale - delisted after 5 games

 

[Wizard17]

Cordy
Daniel
McLean
Webb
Dale
Hamilton

 

[#1 Dogs Fan]

Daniel = 225 games.
Cordy = 240 games.
Web = 125 games.

The rest could be duds or could make it. not sure to be honest.

 

[Doggies1972]

Bit hard to say till we see more of them. They all look good with ball in hand, or on the attack. Little footage on any of them tackling at all.
But what Ive seen
Daniel
Dale
mclean
cordy
hamilton
webb

 

[GreatSouthWest]

Rate them on/by what?

 

[Bont2Bruce]

Cordy
McLean
Daniel
Dale
Webb
Hamilton

 

[womble54]

Daniel deserves to make it. Kid has everything but height poor bugger.

It should go:

Daniel
Webb
Cordy
Dale
McLean
Hamilton

Could easily be Daniel last due to lack of pace v height.

 

[Norm De Guerre]

 

[VitalDread]

From what i noticed during last night event, just by a few chats and the look in their eyes i reckon.
Daniels- set for round 1 debut, bloke is set to destroy the league and push for senior spot straight away.
Hamilton- played a fair few senior games and has that professional look about him and how he walks/talks
Cordy- well take some time to develop but will be a lock 22 in the future.
McLean- Him and Hunter will be our midfield-forward mark of the year takers.
Webb- Reckon in two pre-season he will become a very solid small forward
Dale- needs to put on a fair bit of size around his arms to match afl level defender, i see him as the grant type role.


All these blokes are great kickers, decisions makers and can run for a long time.

 

[Unknown Caller]

McLean
Cordy
Daniel
Webb
Hamilton
Dale

 

[Doggies1972]

View attachment 95163

you nailed it!

 

[Cudi]

Cordy
Webb
Daniels
McLean
Dale
Hamilton

 

[Doggies7]

Like I said in the other thread, this year is so hard to pick who our best kid is going to be. A legitimate argument could be made for any of them which is rare for a draft class without being overly ambitious on your later picks.

I think it will be:

Cordy
Dale (underrated potential)
McLean
Daniels
Webb
Hamilton

 

[TempleKelvington]

This is hard, not having seen much as yet. The new draft boys, Daniel aside are pretty undeveloped, more so than I expected in terms of body shape. But that's ok.

Daniel
Cordy
Hamilton
Webb
Dale
McLean

I have Hamilton high.....just a feeling about him, looks like a Jarman big time in the face and has a look of self confidence. Seen Cordy moving already and he looks pretty good to me. Daniel will be the player of the draft full stop.

 

[Bazza Bulldog]

In order for me ... I like the way Hamilton moves. Webb to play 100 games (yes this is in order of best player) and Daniel more Harvey than Hooper. Will be the draft of the 'teens' surpassing the '12' squad (who are/will be exceptional). I love the pre-season!

Hamilton
Dale
McLean
Cordy
Daniel
Webb

 

[fronkalicious]

Quick summary of results so far (based on 6 points for being ranked 1st, 5 for 2nd etc):

1. Cordy
2. Daniel
3. McLean
4. Webb
5. Dale
6. Hamilton

Interesting.

 

[BEaston]

I think there is a clear top and bottom 3 at this stage, whether it pans out that way... who knows.