Bluebear
Brownlow Medallist
Well it took Mick 11 years to be an overnight success, so I guess I've got some time to answer that.He's one a final and improving quickly but he's not Malthouse standard which most would consider an A grade coach as benchmark - I'm supporting the extension but you're not suggesting Brett is in his bracket are you ?

Is Ratten, in his ?4th year as good as Malthouse was in his 4th year?
Is that what you are asking?
You still didn't answer the question. He isn't Mick isn't an answer Jock.
Point out some specifics with Ratts your not happy with, because most of the "reasons" I have heard are rubbish. Surely you could elaborate on something that is so obvious?
What makes him a B grader?
"Great teams make great coaches". A Jeans.





