Rookie List

[occy437]

Who will stay go at the end of next year

My thoughts
Ed Clarke another year
Earl Shaw possible upgrade to the senior list if not another year
Stephen Garraba another year
Nick Potter run out of chances and we already have enough slow unskillfull short people
Heath Grundy possible upgrade to senior list if not another year
Andrew Hayes hasnt really shown much maybe delisted
Luke Vogels upgrade definatly
Guy Campbell delisted cant stay on the rookie list another year too old and doesnt deserve a spot on senior list

 

[Sharp9]

Bit harsh on Potter isn't that? From what I've seen he's a real goer...not necessarily silky but in the mould of Jude Bolton and Lenny Hayes.

In the bests in the twos fairly regularly, certainly not a midget (Jude size from memory) can't be that slow if he's winning the footy.

 

[MiniKirk]

the measurements of Ed Clarke are unreal 179cm and 95kg! Probably only once seen him play but how can he be a year away. Is it to get more experience because it can't be to bulk up. There is no player in the AFL ATM that is even close to that the dimensions.
What's he like as a player? The players in the AFL that are half close to this are Stuart Dew and Paul Wheatley, does Clarke have a kick on him as big as them?

 

[occy437]

Bit harsh on Potter isn't that? From what I've seen he's a real goer...not necessarily silky but in the mould of Jude Bolton and Lenny Hayes.

In the bests in the twos fairly regularly, certainly not a midget (Jude size from memory) can't be that slow if he's winning the footy.

Exactly like scooter mcglone last year and he has been on the rookie list too long from memory this is his last year he is able to be on the rookie list. I cant really see a spot on the list, and even if he did i could never see him getting a game with our midfield depth

Clarke is getting played in the back pocket for the reserves which is a bit give and take. He was touted as unaccontable in the championships so maybe they are trying to teach him a lesson but i think he could actually be in the team like a Sam Mitchell with a longer kick and better goal kicking