Rookies

[jim boy]

OK, now that the delistings/rertirements in the senior team have happened, its time to think about the rookies. I might have missed somebody but our Rookies are

First year rookies

Andrew Carrazo
Adam Chatfield
Will Slade (althouhg he might be 2nd year, I'm not too sure, maybe someone can tell me)

second year rookies

Paul Chambers
Jarad Rooke

Considering Chambers is doing weights, he seems a certainty to be promoted. And even Geelong wouldn't be so stupid as not to promote Jarad Rooke.

So that leaves the other three, will they stay at Geelong? Chatfield should've taken the next step by now. Carrazo seems pretty good, but I would imagine he'll go to a second year as a rookie and Slade may be left a little longer to develop.

What does everyone think?

 

[JUBJUB]

I'd say Chambers & Rooke will be added to the senior list.I think Chatfield is now to old for the rookie list.Carrazzo & Slade would most likely be kept as rookies.

 

[Fall Out Boy]

Yep, Chatfield is too old. So he either must be put on the senior list, or dropped.

I can only see two players coming on to the list, so, the two should be Jarad Rooke and Will Slade.

If Paul Chambers comes onto the list the club should hang its head. You don't re-sign a valuable commodity like Street if you're going to invest in a player like Chambers.

 

[JUBJUB]

I don't think Chambers should be added,but it sounds like he will.

 

[catattack]

Jarad Rooke should be premoted. Chambers should only be if he has drastically improved from last season. Chatfield is probably to old to bring up, and Slade should be premoted to the list!!

Go Cats!!
catattack

 

[badcat]

I don't think Rooke is a rookie.
Our 4 rookies are Slade, Carrazzo, Chambers, and Chatfield.

 

[JUBJUB]

We had 5 rookies [Rooke,Chambers,Chatfield,Slade,Carrazzo] at the start of the year & one veteran [McGrath]