Round 7 Votes - West Coast vs Kangaroos

[MDB]

Referring to Darky - Finally someone agrees with me!!!!!!

 

[Captain Random]

5 Braun
4 McIntosh
3 Fletcher - welcome back, now KEEP IT UP
2 Kerr
1 Cousins
0.5 Ph Matera
0.25 Gaspar
0.125 Pe Matera

... etc.

Argh, tough. Wanted to watch the video before voting but haven't had the chance.

 

[Eagle_Fan]

5. Brauny
4. Cuz
3. Fletch
2. Kerr
1. Callum

Sorry Jod, been offline a few days....

Now D, i know you said no correspondence, but surely you'll make an exception? The way I see it, Cuz is our 'link man'. Yeah, he does get a fair few 'soft' possesions, but without him the efforts of the rest are next to useless. Ever seen us when we weren't connecting? Its not pretty.... missed handpasses, turnover central... you get the idea. But when Cuz is there (and when he plays he's EVERYWHERE,,, never stops running), he is the connection between say, the in and under Kerr and the running Chambers etc... I used to be a stong critic of his disposal (remember that Jod? ), but he really has improved it, and is invaluable to our team. You won't agree I know, but so be it

EF.

btw... I haven't explained that very well... but I hope you get the drift anyway

 

[Darky]

Originally posted by Eagle_Fan
5. Brauny
4. Cuz
3. Fletch
2. Kerr
1. Callum

Sorry Jod, been offline a few days....

Now D, i know you said no correspondence, but surely you'll make an exception? The way I see it, Cuz is our 'link man'. Yeah, he does get a fair few 'soft' possesions, but without him the efforts of the rest are next to useless. Ever seen us when we weren't connecting? Its not pretty.... missed handpasses, turnover central... you get the idea. But when Cuz is there (and when he plays he's EVERYWHERE,,, never stops running), he is the connection between say, the in and under Kerr and the running Chambers etc... I used to be a stong critic of his disposal (remember that Jod? ), but he really has improved it, and is invaluable to our team. You won't agree I know, but so be it

EF.

btw... I haven't explained that very well... but I hope you get the drift anyway

I understand completely, and I never said he had a bad game. But as per our converasation on the weekend, it's a matter of perception... I rate such players differently from how you do, and (it seems) from how most others do too. Nothing wrong with my or your angle, they are just different.

Simpson usually plays a similar role (although sometimes he is the in & under) and is similarly not as damaging as King and Pickett who run with the ball then hoof it long, or Grant whose disposal (until this year) was super-accurate.

 

[jod23]

Ok as usual im waiting on WA But ill post up the leaderboard tonight and just add WA's when she gets them in.

 

[jod23]

Oh and Macca...ill PM him as he may have forgotten this week.

 

[WA]

Originally posted by jod23
Ok as usual im waiting on WA But ill post up the leaderboard tonight and just add WA's when she gets them in.

As promised jod (+ eka & everyone else who regularly reminds me I'm always late/last ) - I have improved....I'm not last this week.. (thanks Macca ).

It's starting to bother me that Troy hasn't featured in our votes for a few weeks, so -

5. Wilson

or, if I have to....
5. Kerr
4. Cousins
3. Braun
2. McIntosh
1. Mater Ph

 

[jod23]

Thanks WA...i think i might PM Macca now as he seems to have completely forgotten.

 

[Eagle_Fan]

He's posted them in the Round7 leaderboard thread actually Jod

 

[jod23]

Originally posted by Eagle_Fan
He's posted them in the Round7 leaderboard thread actually Jod

Yeah i noticed EF...wont bother PMing him now Will update the leaderboard in teh next few minutes.

 

[dbhattarai]

Originally posted by daddy_4_eyes

3:Kerr - From what the news people said, he was on fire. Our little champ is proving he's not a one year wonder (hint hint, Hasleby).

A bit harsh D4E. Hasleby has been pretty good this season and is averaging 21.9 possesions despite playing a fair bit of time in the forward pocket. On the other hand, Kerr is averaging about 17.4 possesions a game.

I'm not saying he's playing a whole lot better than Kerr (about even I'd say), but I would hardly call him a one year wonder.

 

[Eagle_Fan]

Hasleby's a very good, underrated player. If he hadn't spent so much time with that back injury I doubt there'd be much criticism at all.

Is he over that injury or is it a long term problem?

 

[jod23]

Haselby only really got his one year wonder tag because he couldnt back up his first year due to bad form and more so injuries. He seems past that now and is playing some great footy, I'd still prefer Kerr though.

 

[daddy_4_eyes]

Originally posted by dbhattarai


A bit harsh D4E. Hasleby has been pretty good this season and is averaging 21.9 possesions despite playing a fair bit of time in the forward pocket. On the other hand, Kerr is averaging about 17.4 possesions a game.

I'm not saying he's playing a whole lot better than Kerr (about even I'd say), but I would hardly call him a one year wonder.

Said in a light hearted manner . Hasleby is a great player, and apart from his 2nd year blues he seems to be coming along nicely.
I'd have Hasleby in my team anyday.